Verified Document

Job Analysis And Recruiting Research Paper

Org Structure Job Analysis

There are a number of different approaches to job analysis that can be taken. Three main ones are the observational method, the interview method and the questionnaire method. Interviews and questionnaires are basically the same thing using different methods, so a better third will be task inventory (MSG, 2016). The observational method involves sitting in on the people working at the call center and observing what they do in their daily work. Ideally, this information would be compared with other call center jobs. Further, it is possible that this information would be compared with other data regarding the local workforce. The downside of the observational method is that there might be things that are difficult to observe that are actually quite important to the job. It takes a certain amount of training in that type of work to truly understand what is necessary to succeed.

The interview/questionnaire method can be better for gaining insights, because it asks the people working in the position about what they do. There may be things that they tell you that are not easy to observe. Furthermore, these individuals can often provide insight into the trade -- offs that they are making to work for your company. The latter is critical here, because the problem is that the customer service department is having trouble recruiting people. If the department is located in a very expensive area, it is possible that people cannot live in that area on the money the company is paying. Alternately, the company can find out from talking to people that there is more money available in other jobs nearby, but the people who are working at the position do so for other reasons. It is easier to understand the comparative problem that the company has with interviews in particular, because they allow for open-ended responses. The downside of this method is...

The task inventory can also be expanded to understand the qualifications that are needed to perform these tasks (Wright, 2016). The main advantage of the task inventory is that it is what HR uses when hiring for the position, so it is something that is communicated to applicants. However, there may be deviations between the task inventory and the actual work. Those deviations are important for the company to understand. However, they do not affect a recruiting problem. Recruiting problems stem from a mismatch between the task analysis and the compensation; other equivalent positions may be paying more. The downside of a task analysis is the risk that there is a gap between the task analysis as provided by management and the actual on-the-job requirements. Ideally, the task analysis should be paired with either interviews or observations to get a full picture of what the job really entails.
That said, the task analysis combined with interviews and observations can have a lot of value. For example, suppose the task analysis contains things that are not actually part of the job. If those things -- tasks or qualifications -- are at the high end, then that could be the cause for the mismatch. The company might be asking for a lot from applicants but actually not paying for it. If in reality the company does not need to ask for that much, it can cut some things from the task list, reduce the qualifications, and thus better align with the compensation offered. The marketplace might then be more receptive.

Approaches…

Sources used in this document:
References

Chand, S. (2016). Top 6 approaches to job design. Motivation. Retrieved May 11, 2016 from http://www.yourarticlelibrary.com/motivation/top-6-approaches-to-job-design-motivation-tools/35361/

Dwyer, D. (2008). Job analysis-based performance appraisal. Society for Human Resource Management. Retrieved May 11, 2016 from https://www.shrm.org/Education/hreducation/Documents/Instructor's%20Manual_JA-Based%20Perf%20Appraisal_Final.pdf

MSG (2016). Job analysis methods. Management Study Guide. Retrieved May 11, 2016 from http://www.managementstudyguide.com/job-analysis-methods.htm

Wright, T. (2016). Advantages and disadvantages of task inventories. Houston Chronicle. Retrieved May 11, 2016 from http://smallbusiness.chron.com/advantages-disadvantages-task-inventories-73508.html
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Job Analysis Selection & 8226; Conduct a Job
Words: 1175 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Job Analysis Selection • Conduct a job analysis. • Outline a workforce planning system. • Create a selection process staffing. Course Assignments 1. Readings • Read Chapter 5 -- 7 Managing Human Resources. Job Analysis Selection As InterClean and EnviroTech completed their merger, the operational complexities of the resulting companies significantly increased. At the primary level, one could observe the fact that the organization would no longer simply offer cleaning products, but

Job Analysis Selection Interclean Merged Envirotech, a
Words: 1216 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Job Analysis Selection InterClean merged EnviroTech, a result, a strategic direction. The company longer sell cleaning products, provide full-service cleaning solutions organizations health care industry. Job analysis and selection As InterClean merged with EnviroTech, the resulting company is one with an increased operational complexity. Specifically, instead of simply selling cleaning products, the new firm would also be offering cleaning services to customers in the health care industry. This specifically means that the

Job Analysis on Key Jobs Within the
Words: 643 Length: 2 Document Type: Research Paper

job analysis on key jobs within the organization in order to make sure the positions are being handled correctly. The people in those positions should be the right ones for the jobs, and should be working at their maximum capacity. If that is not the case, it is important to determine why -- which can be done through a job analysis that can be matched up to the skills

Talent Management Handbook Job Analysis
Words: 1450 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Proposal

Others -- other components of job specification are recurrent from the previous sections and may include the title of the position, ordinary and extraordinary characteristics required from the occupant of the position, the main tasks of the job, or the expertise required from the candidate 4. Job Design Introduction to Job Design A major part in conducting a proper process of talent management is that of creating an adequate environment in which the

Recruiting and Staffing
Words: 666 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Job analysis is an essential part of recruiting. To find the right persons to fill positions, the necessary skills required to perform the job must be clearly understood. Candidates must also understand what is expected of them before, not after they take the position. Job analysis minimizes workplace conflict, which can occur when an employee feels that he or she is being asked to perform tasks that were not part

Recruiting an Employer Brand Is
Words: 1254 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

However, some of these may be former employees, a group that has been demonstrated to be among the strongest of candidates (Zottoli & Wanous, 2000). The second recruiting source recommended is the internal job board. Wellpoint has a large staff from which to find a suitable candidate. The candidate will be familiar with the company and clearly seeking to build a career within the company. The employer brand will not

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now