Verified Document

Japanese Correctional System Compared To American Correctional System Term Paper

Japanese Correctional System as Compared to the American Corrections System The Japanese correctional system places a strong emphasis on rehabilitation and preparing the prisoner for being released once again into society. The Japanese correctional system "is intended to resocialize, reform, and rehabilitate offenders" rather than enforce a system of retributive justice along the lines of the American model (Coutsoukis, 2004). This is why most sociologists state that the restorative philosophy of corrections is the predominant approach practiced in Japan, that is, the main aim of the system is to restore the pre-existing social order rather than enact retribution against a particular individual, or even to protect victim's rights, or to punish an offender in a fair manner (Hosoi & Nishimura 1999: 4).

Much like the American system, Japanese prisoners after conviction are classified "according to gender, nationality, kind of penalty, length of sentence, degree of criminality, and state of physical and mental health," and assigned to an appropriate facility, depending on all of these factors (Coutsoukis, 2004). They are then placed in special programs designed to treat individual needs, whether these needs are deemed to be mental health counseling, anger management, or vocational training. A large number of prisoners are given suspended sentences and are placed under the watch of probation officers rather than put directly into prison. Those citizens accused of minor offenses who confess and display remorse may be released without further official action (Hosoi & Nishimura 1999: 4).

In such minor cases, there is also a procedure called Jidan, or an informal settlement reached out of court to settle victim's claims for damages, "material or emotional, in either civil or penal cases. Jidan involves the victim's "temporary acceptance" of the offender's "expression of apology and offer of material reparations" (Hosoi & Nishimura 1999: 4). This acceptance of blame echoes the American civil litigation system, where acceptance of blame or refusal to accept blame may be a part of a settlement. However, in Japan Jidan can take place in criminal, even in penal cases, and is not a formal part of the legal process. It can occur before a trial, but the judge will have access to the Jidan terms of settlement...

"Jidan is informal in nature but formal in the sense that depending on the circumstances it brings about a suspension of an indictment or lenient sentencing to the defendant" (Hosoi & Nishimura 1999: 4). For example, a criminal who makes a Jidan settlement may still be tried and convicted of a serious offence under the law, but receive a less harsh punishment because of his or her willingness to make reparations and a formal apology to the victim.
Jidan exemplifies the importance of remorse and the need for symbolic and real efforts of restoration on the part of the offender in the Japanese correctional system. Although offenders with a high risk of recidivism are usually placed under the care of professional probation officers upon their release, there is also a system of volunteer probation officers, who are often retirees, for offenders who seem remorseful and thus require more gentle treatment. These volunteer officers, like professional correctional officers, willingly take on the responsibility for monitoring the offender's conduct and help him or her establish a more positive relationship with society. They are not paid by the state. Both professional and volunteer probation officers act as surrogate teachers of the offender and act for the benefit of the community as well in the interests the offender, to promote stability and harmony.

In prison, as in the United States, vocational and formal education is offered in Japanese prisons, as is "instruction in social values," and mental health and cognitive therapy groups and programs are featured in American and Japanese prisons alike. Like the U.S., convicts in Japan often work, from which "a small stipend is set aside for use on release" (Coutsoukis, 2004). The principles of many Japanese prison vocational training programs differ than those found in the West and may be based in Buddhist values, where the acceptance of all individual's imperfections is acknowledged, regardless of their incarcerated status. Another unusual feature of the Japanese system is that the prisons are governed by a system of under a system stressing incentives, where "prisoners are initially assigned to community cells, then earn better quarters and additional privileges…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Debito, Arudou & Dave Aldwinckle. (2002). "Arrest and Detention Periods of Criminal Suspects Under Japanese Law

http://www.debito.org/arrestperiods.html

Coutsoukis, Photius. (10 Nov 2004). "Japan: The Penal System." CIA World Factbook. Retrieved 11 Feb 2008 at http://www.photius.com/countries/japan/national_security/japan_national_security_the_penal_system.html

Hosoi, Yoko & Haruo Nishimura. (1999). "The Role of Apology in the Japanese
Criminal Justice System." Paper presented at the Restoration for Victims of Crime Conference. Australian Institute of Criminology Retrieved 11 Feb 2008 at http://www.aic.gov.au/conferences/rvc/hosoi.pdf
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Overcrowding in American Jails When
Words: 3087 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Court records also stick on, whether the charges are dropped or followed by a conviction. People of color or ethnic minorities, such as African-Americans and Hispanics, have come to accept that they cannot avoid acquiring a criminal record. The 1990 Washington DC-based sentencing project found that one in every four African-Americans aged 20 to 29 was in prison, in jail or on probation or parole. A research conducted by

Physical Activity in Prison the Effects That
Words: 4156 Length: 15 Document Type: Essay

Physical Activity in Prison The effects that prison incarceration has on the health and well-being of inmates are multi-faceted and complex. The prison environment presents stressors not experienced outside of the prison context that can bring about exacerbated health problems and psychological difficulties. Health care delivery in prisons is an important issue, as primary healthcare initiatives designed to focus on disease prevention are required in order to maintain health in the

Factors, Trends of Various Justice Issues in the US
Words: 1624 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Justice Systems What are the main factors that determine high or low incarceration rates? The last twenty years have witnessed a significant and historic shift with regards to the use of imprisonment within the United States. In 1980, less than half a million people were imprisoned in the jails and prisons of America. Today there are almost 2 million inmates and still rising. Annually, the U.S. is spending about $35 billion

Adolescent Substance Use Screening Instruments: 10-Year Critical
Words: 14685 Length: 53 Document Type: Term Paper

Adolescent Substance Use Screening Instruments: 10-Year Critical Review of the Research Literature Over ten million teenagers in the United States admit in a national survey that they drink alcohol, although it is illegal under the age of 21 in all states. In some studies, nearly one-quarter of school-age children both smoked cigarettes and drank alcohol. Over four thousand adolescents every day try marijuana for the first time. The dangers of use,

Positive and Negative Effects Video Games Have in Relation to Addiction...
Words: 5997 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

Computer Games Research When considering the short history of computers, video and PC gaming are very recent on the timeline of technology. This is one of the reasons why there have not been many conclusive studies on the negative and/or positive effects of electronic games on children and young adults -- the most formative years. With the ever-increasing interest and involvement of children in this activity, much concern has been expressed

Stressful Organizations and Worker Morale
Words: 8734 Length: 10 Document Type: Essay

Occupational Stress and Scientific MonitoringElena Georgiou*AbstractThe aim of this project was to review evidence available on occupational stress and how it can be monitored scientifically. Closed-ended questionnaires were used to obtain data from 150 participants. Data was analyzed using OLS (Ordinary Least Squares) regression analysis. Data included the demographic background of participants: age, sex, and their occupational background. From the demographic background, all participants (150) were literate where more than

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now