Misconceptions About Sharia Law
Much Islamophobia is grounded in misguided assumptions about Islam and particularly about Sharia law. According to Ali (2014), "nearly two dozen state legislatures" have proposed laws banning Sharia without developing even a modicum of understanding of what Sharia law is, and what it entails (Ali, 2014, p. 1027). Sharia law is central to Islam and to Muslim identity and practice, but only small fraction -- five percent -- of Sharia law addresses criminal law; the majority of Sharia law impacts personal matters including religious rituals and obligations (Ali, 2014). Sharia law is really just a "moral code," derived from Quran, Hadith, Ijma (scholarly consensus), and Qiyas (analysis) (Ali, 2014, p. 1063-4). About 25% of Sharia law concerns matters related to family, dietary custom, and economic practices, which are personal or private issues and not relevant to public policy (Ali, 2014). While some Muslim nations have embraced the tenets of Sharia law as the foundations of their legal system, Sharia law is not infiltrating the American criminal justice or legislative systems, contrary to fears prevalent in the United States. Islamophobia underwrites anti-Sharia legislation, the bulk of which can readily be decreed as unconstitutional given the Establishment clause (Ali, 2014). As Ali (2014) points out, proposed legislation against Sharia law represents a clear case of "institutionalized" Islamophobia (p. 1027).
Types of Discrimination
Discrimination related to Islamophobia takes on many forms, including workplace discrimination, discrimination directed specifically at women, legal and political discrimination including racial profiling and differential treatment, restrictions on freedom of movement and participation in American public life, and discrimination leading to violence or hate crime. After September 11, the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) reported a "statistically significant" increase in hate crimes directed against Muslims and persons misidentified as Muslims, with a total of 400 confirmed hate crime cases nationwide in just a few weeks after the terrorist event (Byers & Jones, 2007, p. 53).
Non-violent but equally as abusive instances of bigotry and discrimination in the daily lives of individuals are even more common than hate crimes and have become unfortunate realities for many Americans, including those who are not Muslim but who may appear to be so in the prejudicial and misinformed consciousness of the brainwashed public. As Love (2009) points out, Islamophobia affects all Americans, as it refers to multiple forms of "bigotry, discrimination, policies, and practices directed towards Islam and a racialized group of people that includes Muslims" (Love, 2009, p. 402). In other words, Islamophobia has been affecting Sikhs, Hindus, Jews, and Christians as much as Muslims because of the tendency to perceive persons from the Middle East, Central Asia, and South Asia under the same ethnic, racial, religious, or cultural umbrella. Livengood & Stodolska (2004) conducted qualitative research on individuals from Mexico and Korea, in addition to Lebanon, Iraq, Egypt, Tunisia, Algeria, Turkey, Pakistan, India, and other countries not implicated in the September 11 attacks and found that all participants had experienced some degree of discrimination following the terrorist attack related to their being perceived of as threatening.
A stricter or narrower definition of Islamophobia, when it specifically does target Muslim individuals and organizations, could include broader "efforts to distort the teachings of Islam, to discredit and defame Islamic organizations and to marginalize and impugn the religion itself" (Love, 2009, p. 402). Thus, incendiary media reports and the rantings of political pundits against the scourge of Islam or religion in general fuels the fire of racialized fear and bigotry. Misinformation and slander against Islam is also connected to the ignorance over terms like Sharia law (Ali, 2014).
Within this narrow framework, Islamophobia leads to distortions of truth portraying the Muslim world as being monolithic and the religion of Islam being also "static and unresponsive to change," when in fact the Muslim world is as diverse as the human race and the religion has been anything but static in its history (Ciftci, 2012, p. 295). Islamophobia leads to the portrayal of Islam and of Muslims as being backwards, sexist, "primitive," "barbaric," "irrational," "violent, aggressive, threatening and supportive of terrorism," (Ciftci, 2012, p. 295).
The political and legal ramifications of Islamophobia are palpable. As Ali (2014) points out, Islamophobia has been "depriving American Muslims of citizenship" in a number of different ways ranging from impeding access to public spaces without fear of reprisal and even more pernicious effects such as the "Save Our State" law in Oklahoma, which abuts Constitutionally guaranteed rights of religious expression (p. 1027). The "practical rights and political activity" of Muslims...
Islamophobia and the Media Islam is a minority religion in America, and many Americans have never had contact with Muslims. As a result, a substantial portion of the American population relies on the media for information about Islam and related topics like the Middle East. Since September 11, but arguably before that watershed event, the news media has built a platform of fear against terrorism but against Islam in particular. Although
Ali, Y. (2012). Shariah and citizenship. California Law Review 100:1027 Ali (2012) focuses on the pernicious trend towards institutionalized Islamophobia and racism in America. Starting with the 2010 "Save Our State" amendment in Oklahoma, several states have adopted similar approaches that essentially legislate discrimination. According to the author, such legislation is not only based on mistruth and has no basis in fact or evidence; the legislation is overtly unconstitutional and deprives
104).. Berlin district mayor, Neukolln, asserts that multiculturalism in German has fallen short. Evidence shows that the recent increment in immigration is because of economic refugees from southern European nations because of the euro disaster (Conradt 2013, p.117). However, the debate regarding the considerable rise in immigration in German falls back to the Turkish community integration, which depicts the uppermost number of foreigners in Germany, the Europe largest economy. Scores of
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now