Verified Document

Is The American Education System In Trouble  Term Paper

Educational Problems IS THE AMERICAN EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM IN TROUBLE?

The United States has enjoyed a long history of providing public education for all students. However, many people believe that our educational system does not function well and that it has not for some time. Although multiple ways to improve public education have been tried, the belief persists that our schools produce under-educated students who are under-prepared for college or work. The goal of education is to teach students, but not all the students learn well, and for those who do not learn, we cannot always find either adequate explanations or solutions.

For some decades, the United States has attempted to use group testing to track the success of our educational programs. One attempt was by use of the National Assessment of Educational Progress (NAEP) tests (Ipka, 2003). These tests provide raw scores of from 0 to 500. The Department of Education decided that students would be classified as performing at a "basic" grade level if their raw score was 208. Below that was considered "below basic. Higher-performing students were classified as either "proficient" or "advanced." In 1994 40% of students fell below the minimum raw score of 208 for reading, suggesting a serious problem with reading instruction (McQuillan, 1998).

Naturally, experts then looked for the cause of these apparent reading problems. One possible cause was a learning disability in reading, often called dyslexia (McQuillan, 1998). Some research suggested that as many as 20% of our students might be dyslexic, which could, conceivably, explain a significant number of the reading scores below that basic cutoff mark on the NAEP.

Finding students with learning disabilities points to an immediate solution: provide reading remediation so...

Other possible causes for academic failure don't point to obvious solutions. We have seen significant social and/or economic differences among students for as long as we have had public schools. In his 1990 book, Savage Inequalities, Jonathan Kozol documented in great detail just how wide the differences in access to good education could be between groups in our country (Kozol, 1992). Kozol documented a number of serious problems including unequal school funding, language barriers for students for whom English is their second language, and the lingering effects of systematic segregation in our schools and in society. Kozol's book demonstrates just how hard it can be to diminish the impact of social problems on education, because the Brown vs. Board of Education decision, declaring that separate was not equal and forcing the dismantlement of systematic educational segregation, was passed in 1954 (Ipka, 2003). Nevertheless, significant gaps remain between the achievement of middle-class and poorer students (Ipka, 2003), and some racial groups outperform others for reasons that simply are not easily explained.
However, all these criticisms of public education have their own problems. Between 1971, when the NAEP was first administered, and 2001, average raw scores varied little, suggesting that student reading abilities have not plummeted in recent years (McQuillan, 1998). In addition, in 1991 the General Accounting Office looked at interpretation of NAEP test scores and saw serious flaws in their approach. The break point of 209 was arbitrarily determined, and using raw scores without statistical analysis is an invalid approach (McQuillan, 1998), raising serious questions about one of our major tools for evaluating our educational success or failure.

Other problems exist when we attempt to look at learning disabilities as a cause for school failure. While some statistics suggest that 20% of students may be dyslexic, the same authors concluded that while 20% might be behind in reading, when reading ability was compared to intellectual capacity, only 8% were significantly behind their peers. The authors used a discrepancy of 1.5 standard deviations to determine who was dyslexic (McQuillan, 1998). While McQuillan (1998) found…

Sources used in this document:
BIBLIOGRAPHY

Ipka, V.W. 2003. "At Risk Children in Resegregated Schools: An Analysis of the Achievement Gap. Journal of Instructional Psychology, Vol. 30.

Kozol, Jonathan. Savage Inequalities. 1992: Harper Perrenial.

McQuillan, Jeff. 1998. "Seven myths about literacy in the United States." Practical Assessment, Research & Evaluation, 6(1). Accessed via the Internet 8/23/05.

Schrag, Peter. 2004. "What's Good Enough? Advocates Are Demanding Not Just Equal but Decent Schools for All Children." Magazine article by Peter Schrag; The Nation, Vol. 278, May 3.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Is the American Education System in Trouble
Words: 2153 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

American Education System in Trouble? In an enlightening article by writer April Shenandoah, on March 20, 2002, the reality that Americas' education system is in real trouble becomes clearly evident. The writer feels that when a child in America attends school, he is, in fact, more at risk than if he did not attempt to attend. This is because, of late, it has become obvious that most negative influences that

American Education America Is Facing
Words: 736 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

According to the book, studies have shown non-native speaking students or students who have special needs physical or behavioral struggle depression because they are in a different country and away from family. "Psychologist David Pillemer has analyzed memories of school, and suggests that such memories have much to tell us about students' perception of success or failure. When I talk to people about their education, from factory workers to

Education System Cover Letter: What
Words: 1462 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

" (Hurtado et al., p. 1) This idea of a structural change is further girded in the article by Hiebert & Morris (2012), which agues in favor of altering the fundamental strategy of instruction. To the authors, the focus on improving the characteristics of educators rather than the educational resources and parameters given to these educators if wrongheaded and problematic. Hiebert & Morris "expose the assumptions on which this logic is

Education -- Major Policy Themes
Words: 711 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Even under ordinary circumstances, the NCLB motivates teachers to spend more time teaching standardized test-taking and less time on substantive teaching. The other principal set of interrelated problems currently plaguing American education is that teachers are underpaid, there is little if any correlation between performance and compensation, and tenure policies make it virtually impossible to remove bad teachers once they have achieved tenure. As a result, the teaching profession cannot

Utopian Education System
Words: 1434 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Utopian Model of Education The utopian model proposed in this essay is an attempt to incorporate utopian ideals into the modern, flawed, classroom setting. It includes ideas for dealing with the real issue of child abuse in the schools, and the problem of inequality in education. Further, it explores the important issue of ongoing teacher education, and promotes the incorporation of computers in the classroom. Finally, an open and warm classroom

Improving American Education: Thoughts and
Words: 1376 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

The idea of group study for students that are struggling, however, also ties in with another idea for the improvement of schooling. The students that are performing the best at a particular subject could help organize and operate these study groups, in effect acting as tutors but yet not providing that service in such a way that they would be paid for their services or would work exclusively one-on-one with

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now