Verified Document

Interpretation Analysis Evaluation Of A Short Story Term Paper

¶ … Birthmark, by Nathaniel Hawthorne, is the story of a man consumed by the pursuit of perfection. He seeks absolute knowledge and absolute control, and imagines that he has discovered great scientific absolutes including the nature of the very heavens and the reason volcanoes erupt. After he marries, he becomes obsessed by a small birthmark on the cheek of his otherwise flawlessly beautiful young wife. His obsession with perfection combined with his scientific hubris leads to the death of his wife. Ironically, in death, the hated birthmark finally fades. The story demonstrates the danger of hubris in assuming that science will have all our answers, that we can manipulate life to meet our arbitrary standards. Hawthorne demonstrates the protagonist, Aylmer's, obsession through various references. In the opening paragraph he says Aylmer.".. had made experience of a spiritual affinity more attractive than any chemical one. He had left his laboratory to the care of an assistant, cleared his fine countenance from the furnace smoke, washed the stain of acids from his fingers, and persuaded a beautiful woman to become his wife." Aylmer is greatly concerned with his own appearance. He scrubs away his only imperfection, something not really part of himself, before proposing to the beautiful Georgina. Hawthorne tells us that Aylmer is so obsessed with science that he is destined to try to combine his love of his wife with his love of science. This marriage takes place through Aylmer's growing obsession over and hatred of a small birthmark on Georgina's cheek.

At first Georgina sees the birthmark as charming, but eventually accepts her husband's judgment that it is abhorrent. Aylmer approaches the topic first by saying that she is "so nearly perfect..." except for the birthmark on her cheek. Aylmer, who had spent his entire life prior to his marriage pursuing great scientific discoveries in his laboratory, is sure he can find...

Georgina believes in Aylmer's genius and is sure he can erase the now hated mark.
Other references throughout the story emphasize Aylmer's growing obsession with the birthmark. His ego does not allow him to realize that his experiments have all been failures, but when he and Georgina begin to live within an apartment attached to his laboratory, she eventually reads his laboratory notes and realizes that his experiments have been failures. But by this time she hates the birthmark as much as he does, because she knows he cannot really love her until it is gone.

Hawthorne makes sure we understand how Aylmer could be seduced into putting such inordinate faith in science, as he lived during a period or great scientific gains. Electricity had recently been discovered and many other facts about the nature of the world were being proven. Aylmer claims scientific greatness, saying in the beginning of the story that his discoveries were celebrated all over the world, that some scientific discoveries were so amazing they might be considered miracles, and that he might even discover how to create life itself. In today's light it sounds more like alchemy than science.

According to Beauchamp (2002), Hawthorne was wary of attempts to use science to improve life, pointing out that such attempts often did not turn out how one wished it would. He believed that divine providence should bring change to society and that people who attempted any kind of social engineering would not get the outcomes they wanted. For this reason he opposed the abolitionists even though he was opposed to slavery (1).

Hawthorne uses vivid imagery in his story to demonstrate this. He tries several concoctions on Georgina before the final, fatal draught. With each attempt, the birthmark, which always resembled a hand but at first seemed gentle,…

Sources used in this document:
Bibliography

1) Beauchamp, Gorman. 2002. "Hawthorne and the Universal Reformers." Utopian Studies 13. (Beauchamp, 2002)

2) Fitzpatrick, Martin. 2000. "To a Practised Touch': Miles Coverdale and Hawthorne's Irony." ATQ 14:1, pp. 27+. (Fitzpatrick, 2000)

3) Wohlpart, A. James. 1994. "Allegories of art, allegories of heart: Hawthorne's 'Egotism' and 'The Christmas Banquet.'" Studies in Short Fiction, June 22. (Wohlpart, 1994)

ALSO:
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Short Story the Lottery by Shirley Jackson
Words: 2966 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

Lottery" by Shirley Jackson The meaning of Shirley Jackson's 'The Lottery' "It isn't fair, it isn't right." These are the last words expressed by the victim in Shirley Jackson's short story 'The Lottery', which provides a unique but shocking perspective of the innate evil that is part of human nature. The story starts off by describing a town scene that could not be more commonplace or predictable. The descriptions provided by

Alice Walker's Short Story Everyday
Words: 1196 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

By simply concentrating on connecting with their African heritage many failed to understand that their parents and their ancestors who lived on the American continent in general created a culture of their own that entailed elements belonging both to the African continent and to the American one. Most of the short story is about how Dee struggles to find her personal identity by turning to cultural values. While Dee is

Symbolism Analysis Symbolic Imagery in
Words: 1678 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

In a metaphorical way, this image is transposed on the image of the woman "showing her teeth." She responds with the symbolic implications that she too is living in a sate of fear and resentment. The reality that Elisa aspires to is again conveyed through the imagery and symbolic of a longing for a better existence. This can be seen when she whispers, "That's a bright direction. There's a glowing

Child Case Study: The Story
Words: 1816 Length: 7 Document Type: Case Study

In relationship of his reading comprehension -- Manuel knows how to read at grade level. He really does get the plain indication and can figure out the connotation of a lot of words in the course of context clues. He can effortlessly recapitulate what he has just read and grabbed some of the main ideas as well as extrapolations. His writing needs a lot of work. A lot of

Bartleby the Scrivener Analysis Essay
Words: 4391 Length: Document Type: Essays

Abstract Engaging in a Bartleby, the Scrivener analysis essay is bound to test one’s patience. It is one of the most inscrutable works of Herman Melville. While Melville is perhaps most famous for his nautical adventure tales, this paper delves into the enigmatic cogs and wheels that make this short story a piece of eternal literature. Eternal literature transcends the constraints of time and relatability, touching upon themes and symbols that

Leaf Storm About the Author the Short
Words: 1002 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Leaf Storm About the Author The short story Leaf Storm is written by Gabriel Garc'a Marquez. He was born in 1928, Columbia. Being the finest man of letters of Latin America, he was regarded by many as one of the greatest writers of the twentieth century (Powells. Com). As a journalist he started his writing career and later became the author of several works of fiction and nonfiction including, One Hundred Years of

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now