¶ … consent a "yes or no" response? Enhancing the shared decision-making process for persons with aphasia
Informed consent constitutes a legal and moral requisite for any research works that involve fellow human beings. Study subjects are provided information regarding every element of a study trial deemed to be vital for subjects' decision-making, including study significance with respect to societal welfare and for advancing the medical field. After an examination of every trial related facet, subjects ought to be able to voluntarily confirm their readiness to be a part of the given clinical trial. This 'informed consent' principle has been imbedded in the Helsinki Declaration, Belmont Report and Nuremberg Code. It is compulsory before commencing any study that entails humans as research subjects (Jayes & Palmer, 2014). This provision essentially suggests if the subject's mental or physical state allows for informed, well- thought-out decisionmaking. But aphasics aren't always able to satisfy the aforementioned informed consent requisites, thus giving rise to moral and ethical challenges such as communication problems, wrong decisions, surrogate consent usage, conflicting doctor-researcher interests and respondent recruitment timing related challenges. A thorough analysis of the following two bioethical concepts -- the need for a detailed conversation on the advantages and risks of the study and respect for subject independence -- reveal their significance in the matter of informed participant consent.
What is the ethical dilemma? How does the dilemma affect nursing?
Ethical problems surface for aphasics, especially severe aphasics, resulting in their being typically excluded from study participation. Even researches that expressly aim at examining stroke survivors' experience do not include this patient population. Consequently, there is not much scope for generalizing study findings for aphasic stroke patients. Moreover, this type of research practice serves to deny aphasics the right of research participation. Even in case of researches intending to include aphasics, issues linked to obtaining their informed consent suggest their vulnerability in recruitment (Jayes& Palmer, 2014).
Diminished communication abilities can screen people's capacity of engaging in informed decision-making. It impacts the field of nursing as research scholars having a limited grasp of the condition (i.e., aphasia) may mistakenly reach the conclusion that individuals having impaired speech or language expression ability may not have adequate capability to offer informed consent. By contrast, mistaken judgment of people's comprehension abilities may cause research scholars to hold the wrong assumption that they can offer well- thought-out consent. Consequently, aphasics may be enrolled in research works without comprehensive understanding of the major implications of taking part. This may expose unwitting subjects to possibly upsetting, negative experiences (Jayes& Palmer, 2014).
Ethical aspects represent a key consideration in designing and performing clinical studies. Numerous completed stroke therapy trials give rise to typical challenging ethical dilemmas. Issues may surface when the treating doctor him/herself is the researcher as well or a research team member. In such scenarios, the severely ailing individuals or their family members will not be able to always differentiate between customary therapies, toxicity researches and therapeutic trials. They generally follow the advice of their...
Consent & Ethics Complications stemming from patient-counselor interactions remain a key source of ethical violations and complaints. Informed consent is a major issue with a direct bearing on the counselor-patient relationship. In clinical avenues, the origin of informed consent continues to have a direct outgrowth of advances in professional ethics, legal precedents, and continuous moral development. Through informed consent, patients have been able to take responsibility and explore options for
Obtaining Informed ConsentMr. Roberts is a patient that was admitted to the hospital Emergency Department (ED) following traumatic injuries caused by a motorcycle accident. Since admission, Mr. Roberts has undergone three surgical procedures. While the first two surgeries were successful, the third one was unsuccessful despite being performed accurately. As a result, he relapsed into a coma and his long-term girlfriend has appeared and holds the healthcare power of attorney
Katz introduces in his book, The Silent World of Doctor and Patient the origins of informed consent. "The birth date of informed consent was 22 October 1957" (Katz, 1984, p. 60). In those origins he shares that although informed consent and disclosure were introduced as standard, people have always had problems communicating with each other and therefore it leads to a disconnect when disclosure and consent are applied to medical
Ethical codes and informed consent are part of the modern world of healthcare. Informed consent allows people to understand the risks they take when accepting a procedure. Ethical codes allow organizations like hospitals conduct their business while avoiding potential lawsuits or other risks. Thanks to the use of ethical codes and informed consent, the public is protected from scenarios and circumstances that could potentially jeopardize health and well-being, increasing the
Anna's rationale for not obtaining informed consent? Not informing research subjects regarding one's purpose is unethical. In order to see just how unethical her decision is, Anna must understand ethical concerns linked to studies that utilize human participants. The basic principles of justice, independence, and goodness form the basis of the aforementioned ethical concerns and warrant attention (UNC Charlotte| Research& Economic Development Centre, n.d).). Ethics guidelines and codes explain the
Competence refers to the practitioner's accurate self-representation of credentials as well as contributing to the profession by undergoing ongoing professional development throughout the career. Although competence is a distinct value from integrity, it is also related to integrity because all social workers should have the personal and professional integrity to practice only within their realm of professional training and competence, and also to upgrade their skills according to emerging research,
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now