Verified Document

Ineffective Assessment Methods For A Test To Term Paper

¶ … Ineffective Assessment Methods For a test to be accepted within the academic community, it must be both reliable and valid. A reliable test produces consistent results. A valid tests measures what it purports to measure. A good example of reliability is the 'kitchen scale' example. If you weigh the same cup of flour and it is 4 ounces, then 4.25 ounces, then 4.5 ounces on various attempts to use the scale, one after another, it is not a reliable scale (Classroom assessment, 2013, Florida Center for Instructional Technology). Similarly, a test which suggests that the same student is above or below grade level, after the same student takes the same test in rapid succession with no additional preparation raises questions about its reliability. "Generally, if the reliability of a standardized test is above .80, it is said to have very good reliability; if it is below .50, it would not be considered a very reliable test" (Classroom assessment, 2013, Florida Center for Instructional Technology).

A test can be reliable but not valid. For example, the cup of flour might reliably weigh 4 ounces on a scale with every attempt but if it actually weighs 5 ounces, the scale is not valid. Similarly, a test which suggests a student is above or below grade level -- although he is not, based upon other accepted assessments of his or her validity -- is not valid. But test validity can be more subjective to assess regarding human beings.

A good example of this is the previous version of the SAT, the required test many students must take to be considered as an applicant for a college. Virtually all students entering undergraduate programs in the nursing profession must take the SAT. The SAT was purportedly reliable predictor of students' grades during their first year of college (it is not an intelligence test, contrary to what many people believe). "The College Board's Handbook for the SAT Program 2000-2001 claims the SAT-V and SAT-M have a correlation of .47 and .48, respectively, with freshman GPA (FGPA)" (SAT I: A faulty instrument for predicting college success, 2007, Fair Test).

However, this assessment is controversial: furthermore, while the validity of the SAT as a predictor of performance of first...

"After a three-year validity study analyzing the power of the SAT I, SAT II, and high school grades to predict success at the state's eight public universities, University of California (UC) President Richard Atkinson presented a proposal in February 2001 to drop the SAT I requirement for UC applicants. The results from the UC validity study, which tracked 80,000 students from 1996-1999, highlighted the weak predictive power of the SAT I" (SAT I: A faulty instrument for predicting college success, 2007, Fair Test). In other words, when a student's entire academic career was considered, SAT scores were poor predictors of performance, indicating that as a valid test of predicting overall achievement in college, the test fell short. Critics have long complained that the SAT fails to measure "high-level intellectual strengths, imagination, judgment, inductive reasoning, and abilities to reflect, organize, and synthesize" which are important in taking upper-level college classes (Heller 1997:110).
From the perspective of the nursing profession, there are also serious concerns that standard admissions tests like the SAT do not fully test the scientific reasoning skills demanded of a nursing program as well as the additional motivation demanded in nursing schools. This is why an additional component has been added to many nursing acceptance requirements in the form of the HESI A2 Exam. This exam "consists of seven academic exams and a personality profile that identifies the applicant's learning style" (HESI Admissions Exam, 2013). There are assessment sections of the applicant's basic knowledge of anatomy, biology, and chemistry as well as a personality profile and learning style assessment which attempt to determine if the candidate's personality and learning style is conducive to the approach taken by the nursing profession. The HESI is an attempt to enhance the overall validity of the admissions process for incoming nurses.

The SAT has since been reformed to some degree, and data is still being accumulated to see if changes such as including an SAT essay portion have improved…

Sources used in this document:
References

Classroom assessment. (2013). Florida Center for Instructional Technology. Retrieved:

http://fcit.usf.edu/assessment/basic/basicc.html

Heller, D.A. (1997). Testing what? English Journal, 86(3), 110.

HESI Admissions Exam. (2013). Retrieved from:
http://chamberlain.edu/hesi-admission-assessment-exam-faqs
http://internal.psychology.illinois.edu/~nkuncel/gre%20meta.pdf
http://www.fairtest.org/satvalidity.html
Strauss, V. (2011). The dangers of building a plan in the air. The Washington Post. Retrieved from:http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/answer-sheet/post/the-dangers-of-building-a-plane-in-the-air/2011/09/30/gIQAojqWAL_blog.html
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Reflection on Assessment Competencies for School Leadership
Words: 1602 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Assessment Competencies Abstract Assessment in education is referred to a range of tools or methods used by educators to measure, document and evaluate the academics readiness, skill acquisition, progress and learning needs of students. The tracking progress report plays an important role to the student since it gauges where they are heading in terms of academics. Assessment is often likened to the traditional standardized tests but educators nowadays, use different types of

Ineffective Public Policy
Words: 1643 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Ineffective Public Policy -- No Child Left Behind One of the most widely criticized educational policies of recent years was / is No Child Left Behind. It is widely referred to an ineffective policy (or legislation). Despite high hopes and bipartisan support, the policy has not worked out as planned. This paper delves into the problems with No Child Left Behind -- and will present the changes that could make it

Theory and Methods in Clinical Psychology
Words: 1273 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Psychological test or assessment method. "The Substance Abuse Questionnaire -- Adult Probation III Brief Description of the Test The recent release of one of the youngest convicted child murders in our nation's history, Lionel Tate, now an adult, into the general population, has highlighted the difficulty of determining if a former prisoner should be eligible for parole. Psychologists have attempted to answer this difficult and subjective question by designing the objectively-assessed test

Ed Assessment Oral Hygiene Educational Assessment Tools
Words: 530 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Ed Assessment Oral Hygiene Educational Assessment Tools Assessing educational outcomes and thus the efficacy of certain specific educational efforts and methodologies is an important part of any educational program regardless of the specific educational area or setting. Choosing the appropriate methods for such assessment, however, is highly dependent on specific aspects and parameters of the education being assessed, and thus should incorporate evidence of successful assessment practices previously identified in specific fields

Psychometric Assessment of Autism
Words: 3635 Length: 13 Document Type: Essay

Psychometric Assessment Autism Background of Autism What is autism? Autism is a disease, which poses tons of questions, while providing least of answers. This being said, autism is one of the five diseases coming under Pervasive Developmental Disorder (PDD). It shows in early years of a human and effects the brain's functioning. An autism website states that, 'it's a result of a neurological disorder, which hampers the proper operations of a brain,

Psychological Assessment and Communication
Words: 833 Length: 2 Document Type: Research Paper

Facilitated communication is widely under scrutiny and doubt owing to the fact that one cannot ascertain the authorship of the typed messages. FC, as it is commonly known, is designed to assist a person with autism to communicate by use of a message board or even an electronic device. The procedure involves a facilitator supporting the hand or other body organ of the affected person with the intention of assisting

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now