Verified Document

Improving Police Accountability In Law Enforcement Essay

¶ … law enforcement agents do better? The key to improving the efficacy of law enforcement agents is changing the organizational culture to one built on accountability. Walker and Archibold offer a new and potentially revolutionary framework for police accountability. The new vision for law enforcement centers on the PTSR model, in which policy, training, supervision, and review are the core parts of organizational change. The current organizational culture of law enforcement has several dysfunctional features, values, and norms. Viewing police culture from anthropological and sociological perspectives, as Kappeler, Sluder and Alpert suggest, shows how norms, values, structures, and institutions create dysfunction, misbehavior, and corruption. Problems like excessive use of force and abuse of power can only be controlled through systematic changes in the organizational culture of policing.

Changing organizational culture requires more than just altering departmental policies and procedural guidelines. After all, most departments will have codes of ethics and guidelines that reflect an idealized set of values. In practice, though, there are two distinct cultures within policing: the legitimate one projected in official literature like codes of ethics, and the tacit culture that is more implicitly conveyed through police culture socialization. Officers at an early stage in their training and careers are socialized into the police subculture, which perpetuates the dysfunctional behavioral habits and traits that lead to problems like abuse of power and excessive force.

Current police subculture includes values such as protecting other officers even when they do wrong or violate organizational policy. Even superior officers are socialized to protect those under them rather than intervene or use discipline. A new model for police accountability depends on supervisors and others in positions of leadership to change their behaviors...

Supervisors should no longer protect themselves and their officers from reprimand, and should encourage officers to inform on each other when the misbehavior is grave, serious, and has tangible consequences. Similarly, Walker and Archibold recommend a revised system of disciplining bad behavior, whereby punishment is eschewed in favor of an "early intervention system." An early intervention system comprises processes that are far less threatening and therefore far more effective than confrontational or punitive punishments that "do not necessarily result in better conduct by the officer," and which "only create resentment and ... reinforce negative attitudes on the part of the officer," (Walker and Archibold 24). Early intervention also engages officer training, calling upon training to be more standardized and professionalized, as well as capable of weeding out "bad seeds" before they become problematic additions to any police agency. An early intervention model identifies problem behavior and provides the immediate and appropriate interventions to stop that behavior, including social sanction and formal education. Education-based models aim to change behaviors among officers, with the ultimate goal of changing organizational culture.
Today's law enforcement agents can also improve their performance by welcoming processes of assessment like critical incident review, external reviews, and internal reviews (Walker and Archibold). Ongoing methods like these are used to improve organizational and officer accountability over the long haul, rather than offering temporary solutions. Police organizations have the potential to become "learning organizations," which are proactive and willing to change (Walker and Archibold).

In addition to the ethos of silence or protecting fellow officers, current dysfunctional police culture tends to encourage a false sense of bravery as well as exaggerated…

Sources used in this document:
References

Kappeler, V.E., Sluder, R.D. & Alpert, G.P. Forces of Deviance. 2nd edition. 1998.

Miller, L. & Tolivier, J. Implementing a body-worn camera program. Washington, DC: Office of Community Oriented Policing Services, 2014.

Sklansky, D.A. The persistent pull of police professionalism. New Perspectives in Policing, March 2011. Retrieved online: https://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/nij/232676.pdf

Walker, S. & Archibold, C.A. The New World of Police Accountability. Sage. Kindle Edition, 2014.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Leadership Options in Law Enforcement
Words: 2292 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Paper

Leadership StylesIntroductionLeadership is a crucial aspect of both policing and law enforcement administration. Current research in leadership styles includes, but is not limited to, situational, transformational and autocratic (traditional) styles. Differences in the contexts of action can affect which style works best at any given time. Ultimately, it is important to identify the needs of any given situation, the skills and qualities of the individual leader, and decide on the

Law Enforcement and Corrections
Words: 1720 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Law enforcement and corrections can be influenced by several external threats. These consist of external communication gaps and many environmental influences. One of the key external threats that impacts both corrections and law enforcement is politics. In delineation, politics is the art of wielding one's authority and power over the government or public affairs. In particular, political action can give rise to the imposition of one's interests within the government,

Law Enforcement: Responsibilities and Details
Words: 1612 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

Law Enforcement Function • Analyze the influence of the criminal justice model on the structure and mission of a local police department. In other words, how would a police department exhibit different structure and procedures under the crime control model than it would under the due process model? The influence of the criminal justice model on the structure and mission of a particular police department is indeed significant. The criminal justice model

Force in Law Enforcement the
Words: 9298 Length: 30 Document Type: Thesis

During the 1960's and 1970's, violent contact with the police, resulting in force occurred during anti-war, labor and civil rights demonstrations, during a politically tumultuous time. It is safe to conclude that excessive force was used during these clashes. Deaths and injuries were the results of political clashes at the Republican Convention in Chicago, during campus riots held at several universities, during political demonstrations held in public places and in

Future of Policing Law Enforcement
Words: 632 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Policing needs to change, especially has it has failed to live up to its potential in improving quality of life for all citizens. The ideal police force is indeed one that prevents crime, keeps order, respects the rights and dignity of citizens, is friendly and courteous, respects the laws, and does not abuse its power through corruption. Policing needs to be increasingly situated as integral to all other community organizations

Law Enforcement and Organizational Culture
Words: 1661 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Law Enforcement Organizational CultureThe state policing agencies have come under harsh criticism, resulting in some state police agencies coming under review by the federal government. After a four-year hiatus, the federal government will review the state police agencies for systemic constitution violations. The 2020 Black Lives Matter following the murder of George Floyd in Minneapolis and Breonna Taylor in Louisville warranted the local police departments to come under review of

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now