Verified Document

Impact Of Culture On PTSD In The Middle East Essay

Related Topics:

PTSD in the Middle EastPost-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) is one of the most common mental health or psychological disorders facing people in the Middle East region. This condition emerges from episodes of social upheaval, combat, and violence that have become common in the Middle East over the past few years. Some of the major areas in the Middle East that have been characterized by increased conflicts in recent years include Palestine, Iraq, and Lebanon. Given increased conflicts and combat in the Middle East, PTSD and other trauma-related mental health conditions are expected to become public health crisis in the Arab world (Suto, 2016). Therefore, public health professionals in the Middle East face the need to develop appropriate measures for diagnosis and treatment of PTSD and other trauma-related disorders. However, the treatment of this condition and other traumatic mental health disorders is significantly affected by culture. This paper examines how culture in the Middle East affect

diagnosis and treatment of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder.

Prevalence of PTSD in the Middle East

The Middle East in one of the regions in the world that has experienced increased cases of violence, combat, and conflict. According to Neria, Bravova & Halper (2010), civilians in the Middle East have experienced frequent episodes of natural disasters, violence, and intra- and inter-group conflicts. These episodes have in turn generate psychological distress among civilians, particularly because they are extreme forms of psychological trauma. Since civilians in this region are repetitively exposed to these incidents, a significant portion of them are vulnerable to trauma-related psychopathology. Existing studies have established a strong link between Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder and repetitive exposure to violence, conflict, and natural disasters. PTSD is strongly linked to such incidents on the premise that they are extreme forms of psychological distress with tremendous negative impacts on an individual’s mental health and psychological well-being.

Since the Middle East has been characterized by increased episodes of conflicts, violence, and natural disasters in recent years, several studies have been carried out to examine the prevalence of PTSD on the general population in this region. Afana (2012) states that these studies have reported a wide range of prevalence rates for PTSD since they utilized different research instruments and were carried out in different countries. For example, a survey on Palestinian territories reported 34% prevalence rates of PTSD, while Lebanon is reported to have 29.3% PTSD prevalence rates (Afana, 2012). Generally, the overall general-population prevalence of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder in the Middle East varies depending on the research instrument and the population’s exposure to extreme forms of psychological distress.

Neria, Bravova & Halper (2010) reports that higher rates of prevalence of PTSD in this region are reported among children and in areas with recent or ongoing conflict, violence, war or natural disasters. According to Afana (2012), the most common PTSD cluster in the Middle East is enhanced arousal in the aftermath of experiencing traumatic events or exposure to incidents with extreme forms of psychological distress.

In light of the increased episodes of traumatic events in the Middle East, Suto (2016) argues that PTSD is and will be a public health crisis in this region and the entire Arab world. Large portions of populations in the Middle East are continually exposed to torture, witnessing murder, political/religious discrimination and oppression, and displacement. This contributes to increased vulnerability to PTSD, which is in turn a major public health issue. As these episodes continue to be prevalent, there have relatively minimal efforts by public health professionals in the Middle East to deal with this public health issue/concern.

Diagnosis and Treatment of PTSD in the Middle East

PTSD is an established diagnostic category that is listed in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM). However, the conceptualization and diagnosis of this condition needs to be revisited given the widespread episodes of natural disasters and other traumatic events (Nicolas, Wheatley & Guillaume, 2014). Most of the existing research and diagnosis of PTSD in the Middle East focuses...

While this framework is suitable for diagnosis of the condition, Nicolas, Wheatley & Guillaume (2014) argue that its important to place PTSD in a social and cultural context. The integration of a social and cultural context helps to generate a suitable diagnosis of this condition and plays a major role in the development of an effective treatment technique or approach.
In the Middle East, diagnosis and treatment of PTSD is based on the symptom clusters classified in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual for Mental Disorders (DSM). However, the use of these clusters is characterized with some challenges since they are based on an unproven belief that they are conceptually and culturally valid across different sociocultural settings (Afana, 2012). The clusters listed in DSM are based on conceptualizations developed in the United States, which may not represent the sociocultural context of a different country even when translated into the local language. Additionally, the use of these clusters does not imply that civilians in different sociocultural settings such as the Middle East will experience similar symptoms and mental illnesses.

Given these factors, a sociocultural conceptualization of mental health condition is critical towards effective diagnosis and treatment of PTSD and other trauma-related conditions in the Middle East. The use of symptom clusters derived from U.S. scales without integration of culturally relevant local idioms and social representations of psychological distress contributes to complexities in appropriate diagnosis and treatment of PTSD. Afana (2012) contends that local or sociocultural idioms of distress are culturally-specific measures of showing distress. Therefore, these factors play a critical role in appropriate diagnosis and treatment of trauma-related disorders like Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder as well as other mental health conditions.

According to Suto (2016), the diagnosis and treatment of Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder in the Middle East has been affected by the increased episodes of violence and other traumatic events. Public health officials in different countries in the Middle East region have experienced tremendous challenges in their efforts to diagnose and treat PTSD because of increased episodes of traumatic events. Rewar (2015) concur by stating that high rates of exposure to traumatic events has limited mental health care provision in the Middle East despite increased need for such healthcare services. Therefore, ongoing traumatic events have significantly affected the provision of mental health care for treatment of PTSD.

Role of Culture in Diagnosis and Treatment of PTSD in the Middle East

Existing literature has established the case for culturally-specific ways of diagnosis and treatment of PTSD. Skinner & Kaplick (2017) state that while PTSD is an established diagnostic category, culture is an essential factor in the symptom manifestation, diagnosis, and treatment of this condition. Over the past two decades, there has been increased interest in consideration and examining the role culture plays in diagnosis and treatment of PTSD. This is largely because culture has been identified as an influential factor in how mental illnesses like PTSD forms, manifests itself, and is treated.

In the Middle East, culture influences how civilians respond to various forms of psychological distress in light of the increased episodes of traumatic events. Additionally, culture determines social representations of trauma and meanings associated with it. Unlike the western world, trauma in the non-western world such as the Middle East is presented using culturally-appropriate metaphors that have not been embraced in psychiatric nosology. For instance, in Palestine, trauma is presented using three metaphors i.e. sadma, faji’ah, and musiba. While sadma is used to refer to sudden painful events, faji’ah is used to refer to response to an extraordinary event or tragedy and musiba is used to refer to persistent traumatic events with long-term consequences (Afana, 2012). In the Arab culture in the Middle East, anxiety and depressive responses are considered as normal states and reactions that people should learn to live with. This is primarily because of the use of a socially-based vocabulary instead of…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Veterans with PTSD
Words: 2068 Length: 7 Document Type: Research Paper

The War on Terror has led to an extended war in the Middle East that started with a U.S. intervention in Afghanistan, spread to Iraq, and has steadily engulfed other states as well. Returning veterans from Afghanistan and Iraq have suffered from post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), which has impacted the work and family life of these veterans (Vogt et al., 2017). 1.3 million veterans of the Afghanistan and Iraq

East Asian Culture the Health
Words: 4675 Length: 17 Document Type: Term Paper

(ACS Publication June 2006 A Growing Crisis In Patient Access to Emergency Surgical Care at (http://www.facs.org/ahp/emergcarecrisis.pdf) Statement of Problem There is a growing problem in the ability of individuals and communities to receive care, according to the American College of Surgeons, as the changing face of emergency care and medical care in general is putting patients at risk. The ACS and the AMA have both recently conducted professional surveys that indicate

Health Maintenance Organization Impact on
Words: 13949 Length: 50 Document Type: Thesis

" (AAFP, nd) The Health Maintenance Organization further should "…negotiate with both public and private payers for adequate reimbursement or direct payment to cover the expenses of interpreter services so that they can establish services without burdening physicians…" and the private industry should be "…engaged by medical organizations, including the AAFP, and patient advocacy groups to consider innovative ways to provide interpreter services to both employees and the medically underserved." (AAFP,

Comparing Irans Military and Culture to the U.S. Military and Culture...
Words: 2313 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Introduction Military is an extension of culture, politics and history. As Eric Ouellet (n.d.) points out, understanding a nation’s military requires that one focus “on the organized violence of armed groups; whether this violence is actual, potential, or symbolic” (p. 30). When it comes to the U.S. and Iran, no two countries could be more different. The U.S. is a liberal, Western democracy with the world’s biggest all-volunteer military. Iran is

High Risk Family Analysis Veterans
Words: 2331 Length: 7 Document Type: Research Paper

, 2011, pp. 263). In implementing something as simple as phone-based CBT with the veterans in the research project at hand, an overall improvement in mental health and well-being could be achieved through relatively few treatments as research has shown, and in seeing the willingness of participants in this research project to provide information regarding their feelings and general mental health, it can be assumed that these same individuals would

The Violence and Anti Social Actions of the Taliban
Words: 1680 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Psychosocial Assessment Malala Yousafzai -- A Girl with a Message Description of Issues and Problems The psychosocial review of Malala Yousafzai, a girl who was shot in the face while trying to promote education in a region of the world where girls and women were not permitted to do many of the things that boys and men can do, is a fascinating story of resistance to cruelty and resilience in the face of

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now