Verified Document

Immigration Policy Research Paper

Immigration Policy Immigration has always been an important part of America’s heritage. Its towns and cities are full of different cultures and peoples from around the world, pointing to the many different types of people who came to America seeking opportunity and a new home over the centuries. The early Spanish and French missionaries came in the 16th century seeking converts to Christianity. The Puritans and English followed. The Germans and Italians and Irish and Polish all came to America in the wake of Industrialization. Over time, America was host to so many different populations and groups of people that it was referred to as the melting pot in 1909 (Higgins). However, America’s approach to immigration has changed over the years—especially in the wake of 9/11. Indeed, the world seems very different from out the shadow of the fallen Twin Towers. That horrific tragedy altered the American consciousness, led to new wars in the Middle East, heightened security in the homeland, and a new approach to the concept of immigration. The flood of refugees into Europe and the rise of nationalism in countries like Poland and England, Russia and China, shows that the idea of a national identity is resurging in response to the “open borders” policy of activists like George Soros (Hasson). In America, a surge of nationalism brought Donald Trump to the White House, as he pledged to be tough on immigration, build a wall between the U.S. and Mexico, and make America great again by making it safer. This paper will show why immigration policy is getting tougher and why policy makers should be smart about how they go about addressing this issue.

The recent acquittal of the homeless illegal immigrant Jose Ines Garcia Zarate in the murder of Kate Steinle in San Francisco (Dobuzinskis) highlighted the already tense environment in which America today finds itself: on the one hand is the left-leaning half of America, which wants to give immigrants...

On the other hand is the right-leaning half of America, which views immigration as out of control, dangerous, and clearly a problem. The latter will point to Zarate’s acquittal (as President Trump did in a series of tweets following the decision). The former point to America’s past and to its history. The two perspectives are irreconcilable.
While it is easy to say that American needs tighter borders and better safety procedures in place when it comes to letting foreigners into the country (the 9/11 hijackers, for instance, lived and worked in the U.S. while they plotted their attack), the solution is not as simple as just “getting tough on immigration.” A lot of immigrants come to America genuinely seeking to make a better life for themselves: they have no intention of causing trouble or breaking the law. In fact, many of them go out of their way to engage in civic duties and show Americans that they want to be good citizens. As Jody Vallejo shows, Mexican immigrants for instance seek a pathway to citizenship are typically more “civically active” (22) than their white American counterparts just to demonstrate their care and concern for the community that they have entered into.

Admittedly, the problem is not one of legal immigration. Even President Trump has expressed the sentiment that it is illegal immigration that he wants to stop (alongside the influx of immigrants from countries that are hotbeds of terrorism). Thus, talking about the struggles of everyday immigrants who come to the country legally is a strawman argument that distracts from the actual issues of safety and legality. The toughness of the immigration policy that the Trump Administration seeks to implement is based on the loss of innocence felt by all Americans in the wake of 9/11. There is an urgent need felt by at least half the American voters who voted in 2016 to close…

Sources used in this document:

Works Cited

Dobuzinskis, Alex. “Illegal Immigrant Acquitted of Murder in San Francisco, Trump

Slams Verdict.” Reuters, 30 Nov. 2017. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-california-crime-immigrant/illegal-immigrant-acquitted-of-murder-in-san-francisco-trump-slams-verdict-idUSKBN1DV3CR

Hasson, Peter. “Soros Transfers $8 Billion to His Open Society Foundations.” Daily

Caller, 17 Oct. 2017. http://dailycaller.com/2017/10/17/soros-transfers-18-billion-to-his-open-society-foundations/

Higgins, Julia. “The Rise and Fall of the American ‘Melting Pot’.” Wilson Quarterly, 5

Dec. 2015. https://wilsonquarterly.com/stories/the-rise-and-fall-of-the-american-melting-pot/

Vallejo, Jody. Barrios to Burbs. CA: Stanford University Press, 2012.


Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Immigration Policies Describe U.S. Immigration Policies Within
Words: 1000 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Immigration Policies Describe U.S. Immigration policies within a historical framework. The current policies of the United States toward immigration are much different when compared to the historical strategies of the country. As: work was bountiful, immigrants were entering the nation in droves, and the availability of jobs was suited to employ the masses of people. The reason why is because historically, immigration was encouraged. This is because, it was considered to a

Immigration Policy Typically, American Textbooks
Words: 591 Length: 2 Document Type: Discussion Chapter

Much of the difference in assimilation patterns between this group of Latins and previous European and Asian groups surrounds the restructuring of the American economy and the sheer volume of immigrants. Contemporary immigrants face a dichotomous situation: "either they maintain their cultural and communal distinctivness, thus selectively acculturating while keeping some distance from the mainstream, or they will be forced into the position of racial minorities, imposing great disadvantages

Immigration Policy Discussion and Argument
Words: 1143 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Paper

Another state in the U.S., Utah, after the law enforcement which was delayed by the Arizona court, this state has adopted another option regarding the immigration policy for the state. The governor of the state said that Utah is not a state where the illegal immigrants can move and have jobs without having the fear for being deported, this is how should be (MSNBC, 2010).The Utah has a different model

Immigration Policy the Border Fence:
Words: 629 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

3, 5). Stromsta additionally offers that, due to their lack of even a high school education, many immigrants will never be able to substantially contribute to the tax pool (sec. 5). Since no immigration policy has yet even slowed the number of illegal immigrants (Beinart par. 1), the only way to resolve these economic issues is to stop illegal border crossings completely with a full-scale wall. A border wall is

Immigration Policy
Words: 2252 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

Wet Foot Dry Foot Policy History of Cuban Immigration Opposition to wet foot dry foot Fidel Castro Haitian American Activist Elian Gonzalez Recent Haitian Immigrants Human Right Advocates immigration policy has long been the center of much debate. In recent months the treatment of Haitian immigrants has come into question. Many in the Haitian American community question why Cuban immigrants are granted asylum while Haitians and other immigrants are deported. The purpose of this discussion is to

Immigration Policy
Words: 522 Length: 1 Document Type: Term Paper

Two immigration policy moves and interventions that would be worth highlighting in this text are the Border Protection, Anti-terrorism, and Illegal Immigration Control Act of 2005 and the Trump Administration immigration policies. According to the Center for Immigration Studies (2017), the Border Protection, Anti-terrorism, and Illegal Immigration Control Act of 2005 “was limited to enforcement and was focused on both border and the interior.” In essence, the law was passed

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now