Verified Document

Iliad Aeneid Homer And Virgil: Term Paper

Even if one accepts that Homer's age was more barbaric than our own, the description conveys nothing of a balanced match between equals, only blood and death. This is not to say that the "Iliad" is lacking in tales of great warriors, but that the author was not enamored with conflict and war to the degree that he was immune to its seeder side. Even though Ajax's display is impressive, and merits the man being called by the word "Great" as he often is because of his size and strength, his deployment of this strength in brutal fashion is not given equal admiration as it is warriors that fight fairly, with proper weapons, and with valor. In contrast, Virgil's chronicle of the sacking of Troy, even in the words of one who suffered greatly because of the unfair, tricked destruction of his native city with the infamous "wooden horse," seems almost beautiful in comparison. While sailing away from the wrecked city that was once his homeland, and facing the turbulent waves stirred up by Poseidon, Aeneas cries:

O, three and four times blessed were those who died before their fathers' eyes beneath the walls of Troy. Strongest of all the Danaans, o Diomedes, why did your right hand not spill my lifeblood, why did I not fall upon the Ilian fields, there where ferocious Hector lies, pierced by Achilles' javelin, where the enormous

Sarpedon now is still, and Simois has seized and sweeps beneath its waves so many helmets and shields and bodies of the brave!" [1.130-144]

Unlike Homer, this cry...

Unlike the bloody pulp of the skull of the fallen warrior in Homer, there is little visceral quality to Aeneas' cry to the gods above, to help him in his distress. He says he wishes he were dead like his brothers, who were killed before old Priam. But the diction of blessing the man who enacted the killing is so convoluted, there is little sense of the depth of sorrow, of someone cut off from his land might feel, even in an ancient world where being banished from one's city was a fate feared almost as much as death.
This does not necessarily mean that Virgil was less skilled as a poet than Homer. Rather, Virgil chooses not to dwell upon Aeneas' extensive emotional mourning of Troy because he was more interested in the positive aspects of founding Rome in the aftermath of the death of the ancient, forgotten city that gave birth to Rome's founder. The immediate effect upon the reader is that the main character comes to focus more as a speaker and a weaver of words than an active participant in battle. The interest of the reader is not on what has happened, violently and recently to Troy in the past but where Aeneas' fate will lead him in the future.

Works Cited

Homer. "The Iliad." Translated by Robert Fagels. New York Penguin Classics, 1999.

Virgil. "The Aeneid." Translated by Allen Mandelbaum. New York: Bantam Books, 2003.

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Homer. "The Iliad." Translated by Robert Fagels. New York Penguin Classics, 1999.

Virgil. "The Aeneid." Translated by Allen Mandelbaum. New York: Bantam Books, 2003.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Odyssey & Aeneid Homer's Odyssey
Words: 937 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Eumaeus heard the discussion and said: "Don't listen to this girl, she has gone mad after having lost her father, the queen is not ready to pick a suitor yet!" I couldn't tell Eumaeus about my arrangement as he could have ruined it all. After all the suitors had gathered in the great hall, I've locked all of the doors so that none could escape my father's revenge. My father

Homer and Virgil
Words: 597 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Virgil and Homer -- World Literature The Trojan Legacy: Textual Similarities in the Epics Iliad by Homer and Aeneid by Virgil In the study of world literature, it is essential that one must know about the earliest forms of literature, especially the works of Homer and Virgil. Homer, considered one of the greatest literary writers of Greek literature, was said to have composed his great epic poems, Iliad and Odyssey, during 8

Virgil's Epic Poem the Aeneid Is Often
Words: 1191 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Virgil's epic poem "The Aeneid" is often described as the poet's response to Homer's epics "The Iliad," and "The Odyssey" in that it details the Trojan War and its aftermath from the Roman perspective. It is a Roman claim to great and far-reaching origins, and because of this apparently patriotic purpose, many classical scholars have attributed the poem's inspiration as Virgil's attempt to praise the emperor Augustus. However, to ascribe

Aenied by Virgil With Reference
Words: 663 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

S. Eliot to Robert Frost. According to Theodore Ziolkowski,"Virgil has permeated modern culture and society in ways that would be unimaginable in the case of most other icons of Western civilization" (ix). In the Aeneid, Virgil through out the story emphasizes through his characters that responsibility is of higher precedence than of love. He makes it apparent in Book II, in which Aeneas focuses on his responsibilities rather than on his

Dante, Virgil, and the Classics
Words: 555 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Finally, Virgil's presence throughout the Divine Comedy is there for a philosophical reason, as well; he is meant to represent the clarity of reason in a spiritually chaotic universe. Homer, author of the great epic the Odyssey, also appears in Dante's Divine Comedy, in the Limbo section of the Inferno. Homer was also the author of the Iliad, which tells the story of the Trojan War. Homer's presence in Dante's

Dante Homer Machiavelli Beowulf Grendel Gilgamesh
Words: 720 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Dante's Inferno And The Heroic Quest Like Homer's "The Odyssey," and "The Iliad," Dante's "The Inferno" begins with a kind of god's eye view of the world. However, rather than the gods looking down and squabbling about the morality of humans they see, Dante begins with his hero's face-to-face encounter with the divine, or at least a representative of the divine, the pagan poet Virgil. Virgil will be the poet's first

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now