Verified Document

Ideas And Politics Article Critique

Competing organizations will seek to limit the extent of the other's influence. A strong organizational culture heightens the difficulty of compromise. As Drezner writes, "compromise implies the acceptance of other beliefs and values, which can prove anathema to bureaucrats who genuinely believe that their ideas are superior" (737). Institutional leaders must carefully analyze the benefits of compromise, as any deal that goes against the organization's values will hurt morale. On other hand, an embedded agency has their unique set of advantages and disadvantages. An embedded organization has greater access to resources and information. They also possess the ability to influence other organizations to their unique point-of-view. They can bargain and increase their clout while promoting their own agenda. However, embedded organizations are not at liberty to create their own organizational culture especially if they are within a larger bureaucratic organization with their own beliefs and norms. Agency leaders cannot build an organizational culture consistent with their founding principles. However, this gives them more leeway in regards to making compromises.

Drezner uses the Peace Corps as the primary example of an insulated missionary institution. It was created with the founding notions of reducing poverty and promoting development through direct action (740). This insulation...

It had some successes during its formative years, sending volunteers all over the world, particularly throughout Asia and Africa. Their dedication to their beliefs caused friction with other organizations, which was ultimately to their detriment. This was evident during the Vietnam War. The Peace Corps was as Drezner says, too small and narrow an organization to have any significant impact and more importantly, unable to change U.S. policy on aid (742). The organization's dedication to direct commitment limited its ability to change foreign policy on a grander scale. Ultimately, the Peace Corps survived, firmly dedicated to their ideals but could not influence other agencies.
Drezner makes interesting and compelling arguments in his article. An organization that refuses to compromise faces the reality of limited influence. These embedded organizations survive due to their dedicated members that remain steadfast to the foundational ideals. An organization that is part of a larger bureaucracy is at jeopardy of losing sight of its mission statement with the benefit of being able to exert a greater sphere of influence.

Works Cited

Drezner, Daniel W.. "Ideas, Bureaucratic Politics, and the Crafting of Foreign Policy." American Journal of Political Science 44.4 (2000): 733. Print.

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Drezner, Daniel W.. "Ideas, Bureaucratic Politics, and the Crafting of Foreign Policy." American Journal of Political Science 44.4 (2000): 733. Print.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Politics, Violence, Language: Political Plays of Harold Pinter
Words: 1773 Length: 5 Document Type: Dissertation

Politics of Violence in Pinter's Late Plays When Harold Pinter received the Nobel Prize for Literature in 2005, he spoke quite directly about the subject of political theatre: Political theatre presents an entirely different set of problems. Sermonising has to be avoided at all cost. Objectivity is essential. The characters must be allowed to breathe their own air. The author cannot confine and constrict them to satisfy his own taste or disposition

Politics Has Never Reached the Importance in
Words: 799 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Politics has never reached the importance in people's daily lives as it has any time before in history. In today's world, the globalization trend has made all of our lives interconnect whether we are aware of these connections or not. Furthermore, our world population has become so large that the competition for natural resources, especially non-renewable ones, has become an intense rivalry among many different nations and even some of

Politics of Information Management the Art of
Words: 954 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Politics of Information Management The art of information management is widely known as the tactic of policy makers guiding the policy followers into doing so. Therein comes the practice of politics and it is known that politics portends power; consequently understanding power and its application to the art of information management is both appropriate and timely. Organizations now have been proliferated by computers to an extent that they control the entire

Politics Heywood Describes a Number
Words: 727 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

I think the state should be neutral, and there should be opportunities for everyone, but that is not real life. I think that men mostly run government, but to call states patriarchal seems too extreme for me. I believe that there will be more opportunities for women both in government and the private sector, and that this is a wiser and less volatile outlook than the more radical feminist

Politics There Were a Few Things That
Words: 1445 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Politics There were a few things that changed in American political culture between 2004 and 2012. The political culture became more polarized, as media and political rhetoric escalated significant following the 2008 election. The political landscape was change by the 2008 election, which saw an expansion of red states, and renewed interest in politics from African-Americans and Hispanics, two groups that traditionally vote Democrat. The heightened rhetoric can be seen as

Politics and Program Evaluation Getting
Words: 1467 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

25). On the other hand, there is often an assumption on the part of the users that evaluations are "an ivory tower process…too late to be useful, too full of jargon to be understood, too lengthy [to read]…, and too likely to be answering a question quite different from the policy question originally posed" (Ibid). The last user complaint set forth by Chelimsky -- that the question answered is often not

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now