Verified Document

Idea Of Human Rights Term Paper

Human Rights What is the biggest problem in constructing a theoretical justification for the idea of human rights? Be as precise as possible, and try to show how this problem plagues at least two theories. (These two theories would be relativism and universalism.)

Relativism vs. universalism. Since the very beginning of the idea of 'universal' organizations that transcended national borders came into being, this debate has plagued theorists of international human rights. Human rights have, in classical Western philosophy, been "held to be universal in the sense that all people have and should enjoy them, and to be independent in the sense that they exist and are available as standards of justification and criticism whether or not they are recognized and implemented by the legal system or officials of a country." (Nickel, 1992:561-2) Furthermore, the world is growing 'smaller,' or 'flatter' with the advent of the globalization of the world economy. Thus -- in theory -- it should be easier to arrive at a doctrine of universal human rights that stretches across borders. But globalization also means that the world is growing increasingly pluralized in its conceptions of what constitutes universal human rights.

Thus, comes the question of how can universal human rights exist in a culturally diverse world? "As the international community becomes increasingly integrated, how can cultural diversity and integrity be respected?...

On one hand, to assert that there is a universal doctrine of human rights seems to impose a singular, rights-based system upon the world in a colonial fashion. Quite often, a Caucasian, Western, narrow conceptualization of rights that stresses the individual over the collective is preferred to traditional systems, it could argued, under the guise of so-called human rights.
One could also argue that human rights are in contradiction, even amongst the universal espousers of such rights. Do "human rights" across borders imply more than mere individual liberty and extend to include security from violence and the necessary material conditions for personal survival? (Fagan, 2004) What of the conflict between Western powers regarding their own citizen's rights -- is there a right to health care for all human beings? Sweden would say yes, in the form of its socialized medicine system the United States would deny this right to its citizens. Is capital punishment humane? The United States agrees in some contexts, England does not and outlaws capital punishment. But if there are no human rights on a universal level, then atrocities, such as transpired in Rwanda, say, one falls into the trap of relativism. One must allege that some rights extend across cultural boundaries, rather saying that no standards are possible, for fear of treading on cultural landmines. "While the history of colonialism and racism cautions us against the misuse of power…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Ayton-Shenker, Diana. (1995) "The Challenge of Human Rights and Cultural Diversity." United Nations Background Note. Published by the United Nations Department of Public Information. Retrieved 5 Jun 2005 at DPI/1627/HR -- March 1995 http://www.un.org/rights/dpi1627e.htm

Fagan, Andrew. (2004) "Human Rights." The Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Retrieved 5 Jun 2005 at http://www.iep.utm.edu/h/hum-rts.htm#source

Nathan, Andrew J. (1997) "Cultural Values and Relativism:

The Example of Women's Rights." Viewpoints. Retrieved 5 Jun 2005 at http://www.aasianst.org/Viewpoints/Nathan.htm
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Human Rights and Child Prostitution in Haiti
Words: 6002 Length: 20 Document Type: Essay

Human Rights and Child Prostitution in Haiti The Republic of Haiti is a Caribbean country occupying smaller portion of Hispaniola Island. It shares the island with Dominican which is equally another Caribbean country with population of just over 600, 000. In 2011, the population of the Republic of Haiti hit 9 million-mark with chances of a tremendous growth projected in the subsequent years. With the capital located at Port-au-Prince, the country's

Human Rights in Human Security
Words: 2863 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Paper

As a result, many citizens continue suffering by losing business opportunities due to insecurity. They develop ineffective policies, implement them, and when they fail, blame it on local authorities. Therefore, the crime rate continues to go higher and the government remains quiet about offering long-term solutions to such problems (Griffin 110-111). Solutions Long-term solutions or strategies are essential in helping an individual deal with their fears because they will have a

Human Rights Are Important Because They Serve
Words: 1311 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Human Rights are important because they serve to achieve a certain level of human dignity. But what does one mean by the term human rights? Human beings have an inherent value simply by virtue of being human. One generally treats something of value with respect and holds it in esteem. Simply, human rights dictate a basic treatment to which every human has the right. Dignity is the outward emanation of

Human Rights the Challenges of
Words: 1986 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

It is also unlikely that the UN will ever really have an aggressive standing army but will continue to be required to call upon others to be its arms in any given place. "Is it not true that the nation state and state sovereignty will be with us for some time? But in what form?" (Forsythe, 2006, 26) State sovereignty will be a universal application for many years to

Human Rights the Concept of Human Rights
Words: 1978 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Human Rights The concept of Human Rights has a long history of over two thousand years and its origin can be traced to the moral philosophies of Aristotle and the Stoic philosophers. The theory of human rights, however, has broadened in concept over the centuries and its contemporary form reflects the development in human thought over time. In the present day world, Human Rights aim to secure for individuals the necessary

Human Rights Donnelly, J. 2007 .
Words: 916 Length: 3 Document Type: Book Report

The human rights police occasionally violate human rights in the name of rights preservation. Therefore, those who have the political power to underwrite human rights legislation also have the power to re-write that legislation or simply be excused from the table. In some cases, human rights violations are clear-cut. Genocide is a prime example of a situation in which the global community screams for a more conscientious enforcement of human

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now