Verified Document

Human Resources And Compensation Philosophy Essay

Compensation Philosophy Introduction

Compensation philosophy refers to the approach that a company takes to determining compensation. Total compensation is a mix of pay and benefits, and the structure that the pay takes as well. The compensation philosophy should be aligned with the company’s overall strategy. For example, Wal-Mart pays at low rates in order to help it compete on a low cost basis – a lower cost of doing business is conducive to that approach. Costco takes a different approach, believing that paying above market for its employees will deliver higher workplace engagement, and a more experienced, efficient workforce. The gains in efficiency and engagement will offset the higher cost per worker, is the general thinking there. So the compensation philosophy can be different between two firms in the same industry, but the philosophy has to be aligned with the rest of the business, including the key business objectives.

Different Compensation Philosophies

There are three basic compensation philosophies – lead, lag or follow the competition. The sort of base philosophy is to follow the competition, which means to set compensation policies in line with the market (SHRM.org, 2015). Under this approach, the competition basically sets the bar for compensation for the different roles, and your company follows what they are doing. This is also known as a match strategy.

The lead strategy is when the company takes the lead, setting compensation. Other companies follow you. As the compensation leader, typically the company will focus on having higher compensation rates, paying more than competitors. This is often done to attract better candidates, and in many cases there are sound operational reasons for this. Companies with the best talent are often the best performing companies – having your pick of great applicants can be a source of competitive advantage for a company.

The lag strategy is to pay below the market for jobs. There are two ways that this works. First, the company can offer far superior things in other areas – the work environment,...

This is something seen in tech startups, where there are cash flow issues but people are willing to take less because there is more opportunity or the work is more intrinsically rewarding. The lag strategy is also used by companies that utilize a lot of low-grade labor. Unskilled labor often comes with high turnover, and higher error rates, so companies that have to choice but to leverage the unskilled labor pool typically want to pay as little as possible, in order for each worker to have a net positive contribution to the company.
Recommendation

I normally recommend that companies take the lead approach to compensation, but because compensation philosophy needs to be aligned with strategic objectives and the rest of the operational strategy it is important that even a leading strategy takes these factors into account. The reason I recommend a lead strategy is that I believe companies should take a lead strategy in all their endeavors. The most successful companies are the ones that strive to be the best, to dominate their industries. I do not advise any company to be happy with anything other than the #1 position in their market, because any other position in inherently less stable in the long run. The reality is that in order to be the best on the market, a company needs to have better, smarter people than its competitors. To attract the best people, a company typically needs to offer better compensation. The reality is that top companies often offer talented people opportunity, and on average employees prefer to make more money, all other factors being equal.

Sturman and McCabe (2006) note that the lagging strategy typically does not pay off. It offers poor utility because a company that attracts weaker workers will continually struggle in the marketplace. The best workers from that company will be picked off by competitors – they have higher turnover intention. Their study showed that total utility is higher for the lead strategy at all levels,…

Sources used in this document:

References

Bowman, Jeremy. “Why Wal-Mart will never pay employees as much as Costco” Motley Fool [Web]. 2016. Retrieved December 5, 2017 from https://www.fool.com/investing/2016/1

SHMR.org “Planning and design: Compensation philosophy: What are the advantages or disadvantages of lead, match or lag compensation strategy. SHRM.org 2015. Retrieved December 5, 2017 from https://www.shrm.org/resourcesandtools/tools-and-samples/hr-qa/pages/cms_024253.aspx

Sturman, Michael & McCabe, David. “Choosing whether to lead, lag or match the market” Scholarly Commons 2006. Web. Retrieved December 5, 2017 from http://scholarship.sha.cornell.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1338&context=articles


Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Compensation Philosophies Up to This
Words: 1031 Length: 3 Document Type: Case Study

This problem was mostly raised within the financial sector in light of the credit crisis, but is now also being addressed in other companies as well. The focus as such now falls on responsible governance (Muller, 2012). Chapter 13 questions 1) Strategic importance of benefits Today, the dynamics of the business environment are suffering dramatic challenges, emerging from various fields. Customers for instance become more demanding; the domestic and international competition intensifies;

Human Resource Management in International Business Impact
Words: 2633 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Human Resource Management in International Business Impact of Cultural Differences, Socioeconomic or Political Factors on international HRM Challenges to HRM posed by growth in International Business By looking at the changing trends of the world of commerce in recent times, one can significantly notice the fact that this business community is becoming more and more competitive. This clearly signifies the truth that the elevating competition within the community has given rise to international

Human Resources Management
Words: 2782 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Paper

Human Resources Management If what is learned in an important college or university course is not put to use in some pragmatic way -- or understood in the larger social context -- then that learning may be viewed as meaningless time spent. No doubt there is a percentage of students that are simply going through the process of education, working for a degree that will open doors and lead, hopefully, to

Human Resource Management Using the Example of
Words: 2063 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

Human Resource Management Using the example of Google, evaluate whether the following HR practices/policies is strategic or not. Does this HR practice help the organization to achieve its goals and objectives? In this paper, we are going to be looking at the impact of different policies and procedures on Google. This will be accomplished by studying the strategies that they are using to attract and retain employees. Once this takes place, is

Human Resources Over the Last Several Years,
Words: 2617 Length: 9 Document Type: Research Paper

Human Resources Over the last several years, the issue of employee compensation has been increasingly brought to the forefront. This is because globalization is requiring firms to have employees with specialized skills. In the case of the mid-level manager position, the ideal candidate must be able to meet the basic qualifications to include: a good communicator / listener, leadership, someone who can work well with others, a minimum of a four-year

Human Resources Policies and Guidelines
Words: 2702 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

As to her argument that the entry qualifications are a "good first degree," it might be pointed out that what is constituted as a good first degree in these two departments differs. The question is whether her degree is more closely related to engineering or it, or neither. These differences would be considered a "material factor." A good first degree is not the only material factor that will determine the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now