Verified Document

Human Intelligence Twin Studies And The Acquisition Essay

Human Intelligence Twin Studies and the Acquisition of Human Intelligence

The question of nature vs. nurture has been a topic of conversation, a hotly debated issue and reason for researchers to gather copious amounts of material for thousands of years. Philosophers discussed whether a child was mainly constructed of inborn (nature) or learned/observed traits (nurture) before Alexander the Great had conquered anything. Nature refers what is commonly called genetics today; nurture, conversely, is what an individual picks up from the environment. Many have been in one camp or another, but only recently have scientists had the ability to truly assess which is more correct.

One facet of this study, that of intelligence, may be the single greatest issue of discussion among scientists and lay persons. Intelligence as nature has taken a beating in the public arena due to such publications as "The Bell Curve." Many did not appreciate the findings, especially along racial lines in the book, so it was dismissed. Scientists have also shown many areas where the authors used faulty evidence. But, this essay is concerned with what nature vs. nurture truly is, how the study relates to intelligence, and an evaluation of the competing evidence in the argument.

Some terms must first be defined prior for this investigation to begin. Much of the evidence examined relates to twin studies performed with what are typically referred to as identical and fraternal twins. In these scientific studies identical twins are termed monozygotic (MZ) or coming from a single egg, and di-zygotic (DZ) or coming from different eggs (Mackintosh, 1998, 71). The identical twins will be referred to as MZ and the fraternal twins as DZ. Another term, common in many studies, is correlation. Eric Gander (2003, 83) defines this term as "the degree of similarity between two variables."

Psychology, generally being considered the study of behavior rather than specific...

The question of genetics vs. The environment is paramount in understanding many of the different theoretical wanderings of different researchers such as the noted behaviorist James Watson. Many of the scientists have discussed the role of intelligence in the contrast of nature vs. nurture.
The genetics argument is that a child will gain a large amount of their intelligence makeup from heritability. This means that intelligence will vary little when compare to the intelligence of one's parents. Nurture, on the other hand, states that these traits of intelligence are largely gained after one is born. The environment in which ones lives and gains' understanding has more of an effect than does to whom the individual was born. Intelligence is at the core of the nature vs. nurture debate because it is a trait which people can anecdotally being passed from one person to another (such as eye color, height or weight). But, studies with both DZ and MZ twins who have been raised with their biological parents and raised apart have shown a light on which side of the argument is more true.

First, a not on intelligence studies in general. There has been some bias associated with the studies with regard to twins, especially thos who have been adopted and separated at birth. "The nonrandom placement of adopted? out twins further assures a high similarity between rearing families and biological ones. Again, a marked bias is present that leaves suspect any unqualified generalizations from the data"

(Farber, 1981, 18). This does not mean that the studies should e discounted, only that they should be carefully scrutinized before one relies on the results. But, this could be said about many studies.

To say the least, the research…

Sources used in this document:
References

Collins, W.A., Maccoby, E.E., Steinberg, L., Hetherington, E.M., and Bornstein, M.H., 2000. Contemporary research on parenting: The case for nature and nurture. American Psychologist, 55(2). pp. 218-232.

Farber, S.L., 1981. Identical twins reared apart: A reanalysis. New York: Basic Books.

Gander, E., 2003. On our minds: How evolutionary psychology is reshaping the nature- versus-nurture debate. Baltimore, MD: John Hopkins University Press.

Mackintosh, N.J., 1998. IQ and human intelligence. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Intelligence Agencies What Exactly Is
Words: 11218 Length: 28 Document Type: Term Paper

Sometimes, it is even necessary to carry out certain clandestine operations like deceptions, clandestine collection of information, covert actions, and also the carrying out of the exercise of distributing disinformation or misleading information, which would mislead the suspected threat. The United States Intelligence Community is, as stated earlier, made up a number of different agencies. The Central Intelligence Agency is one of these. Also known popularly as the CIA, this

Nature Vs Nurture Essay
Words: 3597 Length: Document Type: Essays

In this Nature vs. Nurture essay example, we will offer topics, titles, an outline, and what it takes to make a great paper. We begin with a strong introduction and thesis statement, followed by body paragraphs that offer in depth analysis of the topics as well as current evidence. We end the essay with a succinct recap of everything under the conclusion section. In critical essays, the main thing to

Level-Six Leader Are You a
Words: 2103 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Paper

Firstly, in Piagetian manner, the subject is confronted with a moral dilemma, that is, a short story in which two or more moral principles oppose each other. He or she is asked to make a choice. Secondly, the interviewer uses intensive probing, that is, why-questions, and questions which stimulate the respondent to consider varying situational contexts. Thirdly, stage scoring of interview is based on well conceived and meaningful measurement

Neo-Confucianism Is a Philosophy Which Was Born TEST1
Words: 6352 Length: 20 Document Type: Research Proposal

K-12 Curriculum and Instruction: Changing Paradigms in the 21st Century This is not your grandfathers' economy or his educational paradigm however; today's curriculum still appears as such and therein lays a very significant and challenging problem that presents to today's educators and leaders. According to Sir Ken Robinson, "We have a system of education that is modeled on the interest of industrialism and in the image of it. Schools are still

Compare And Contrast Nature Vs Nurture
Words: 2249 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Essay Topic Examples 1. The Influence of Genetics vs. Environment on Intelligence: This essay analyzes the degree to which intelligence is shaped by an individual's genetic makeup versus their environmental influences. It delves into various studies that dissect the heritability of IQ and how factors like education, socioeconomic status, and family upbringing contribute to cognitive development. 2. Behavioral Outcomes: Innate Temperament vs. Learned Responses: Focusing on

Autism: Diagnosis, Intervention, and Social
Words: 4495 Length: 15 Document Type: Literature Review

The children were scored in terms of whether they imitated the action that had been modeled for them as well as for the presence of any "errors" -- the introduction of actions not in the modeled behavior. The results were then subjected to multivariate statistical analysis. The researchers found, in contrast to previous similar research, that children with both conditions did not evidence any greater problems with either gross motor

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now