Verified Document

How Positive And Normative Economics Relates To The US Government Term Paper

¶ … POSITIVE AND NORMATIVE ECONOMICS RELATES TO THE U.S. GOVERNMENT The objective to the success of a specific science is the capability to identify and delineate opinions on 'what is' from 'what ought to happen'. This includes providing a demarcation between positive statements and normative statements. Positive statements deal with 'what is, was or what will be' but the normative statements deals with 'what ought to be' and are based on value judgments regarding what is good or what is bad. The positive conclusions could be considered as those which are extensively applicable throughout the whole world and they are testable whereas the normative instructions are not testable but constitute the basis for formulation of positive statements. Positive statements are for example, when we ask economists to inform us regarding how the price system operates, we are asking them to travel us along the road of positive economics. The following statement "if the price of petrol increases the demand for petrol falls" is a positive statement that could be either agreed or refuted. The normative economics on the other hand deals with the prescriptive statements, to illustrate, how the price system would function. Normative statements could generate positive hypothesis regarding the basis on which 'ought'-type conclusion depends on. It thus helps the policy decision makers to provide for the maximum well-being of all people. (The Tools of Economics Analysis) The positive analysis concentrates on becoming fully aware of the economic variables, unemployment, inflation, growth rates, interest rates etc. And the way they associate with one another. The normative theory contains the policy recommendations that the government activity in the economy is to be devised so as to maximize the national welfare. (The Demand Side: Keynesian Economics)

The U.S. trade policy exhibits three distinct modeling approaches: the normative approach that mostly associated with the goal of social welfare function, the positive approach associated with the basic postulates of the political economy and the transaction cost approach that is following a mid-way between the positive and normative approaches. The normative approach to the trade policy of the U.S. government emphasizes on the objective function that incorporates the issues of maximization of well being, optimization of resource allocation under the environment of perfect competition. The effective operation of such a system necessitates a type of government that itself functions perfectly and that is quite effective in handling the policies so as to accomplish the objectives of welfare maximization and efficiency objectives. (An Overview of the Modeling of the Choices and Consequences of U.S. Trade Policy)

However, in reality it is not necessary to examine in the normative modeling approach so as how a government is required to be organized and functioned to accomplish the conditions of first best world. On the theoretical framework at the minimum it is essential to assume that the government is fully aware of the economic indicators and functions so as to play the part of a beneficent dictator. However, what continues to be unclear in such circumstances is why governments will be originated initially and what should be the norms for guidance of their policy initiatives. The normative approach thus takes for granted the prevalence of perfect government and represents its part in policy making as an executing agency to implement the norms of normative approach for the benefit of the society. However, taking into account the prevailing structure of the U.S. government along the types and complexities of the concerned objectives it is apparent that an imaginary environment needs to be created so as to make the normative approach effective.

However, these are regarded as flexible approaches since the normative approach is unable to explain as to why the government has selected the trade policies that they do particularly, when such policy choices are so rapidly at variance with first-best optimal criteria. The political economy approach is considered quite effective since it improves the awareness of the factors that moulds the choice and designs the trade policies. The different positive models have universally accords more weight to some individual and interest groups than to others in finding out the policy priorities. The welfare objectives thus do not associate at all in the policy process or associated only along with the distributional objectives. The trade policy prioritizations are effected both in the Executive Branch and Congress particularly, while the probing authority of the ITC depended primarily on the facts and legal interpretations associated with U.S. trade laws as they were devised in other branches. As per the positive approach the private sector manufacturing interests along with the trade law actions of legal firms operating on their own are the impelling...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

(An Overview of the Modeling of the Choices and Consequences of U.S. Trade Policy)
Since the positive economic approach concentrates basically, on the effect of the goals of producers in restructuring policy priorities and electoral politics there exists some sort of specific objectives that does not sufficiently take into account. These incorporate differing public interests and advocacy organizations particularly those that are concerned with the trade polices and the circumstances, human rights and other non-economic, trade-related goals like improving of democratic political and social institutions. However, the main disadvantage of this approach is that it is not concerned with the merits and demerits of the substitute trade policies and it extends no guidance to the policy makers in selecting among the available policy substitutes. The Transaction Cost Approach signifies that society is consisted of innumerable agents reinforcing on behalf of innumerable principals and execution of numerous policies in real time basis. Unless a broad view is undertaken it is quite problematic to understand the alternative and consequences of trade policies. A combination of the normative and political economy approaches is therefore quite necessary.

A close look at the U.S. trade policy initiatives during the past half century ever since the conclusion of World War II, finds it worthwhile to consider such experiences within the transaction cost structure as involvement of the interplay between the forces of trade liberalization and protectionism / export subsidies as a radical process prevailing in real time. The close analysis and evaluation of the real consequences of the trade policy process strongly recommends on the balance that the U.S. economy has been subject to a distinguished liberalizing orientation and resulting all-round improvement in the economic well being, even when the variations in the income distribution are considered. The adherence process associated with the U.S. trade policies has been adequately strengthened so as to decline the transaction costs over time. However, we acknowledge that not everyone would grant such conclusion indicating particularly the frequent reliance on non-tariff protectionism in the last twenty years or more and the prolonged restrictions applicable to trade in agricultural products and apparel. (An Overview of the Modeling of the Choices and Consequences of U.S. Trade Policy)

However adoption of such principles the general direction of U.S. domestic and trade policies with regard to market oriented consequences and the reduction of U.S. And foreign trade impediments dominated the market. This has been strengthened by the prevalence of the General Agreement on Tariff and Trade that produced the necessary relevance and power for trade liberalization and non-discrimination with regard to the members of GATT and the regular multilateral trade negotiations. The U.S. dominance became the impetus for assisting in reducing tariff barriers for dealing with difficulties generated by the NTBs. This process has of course been far from perfect; however, the consequence has nevertheless been mostly advantageous to the major industrialized and developing nations associated with the global trading system. The continuation of the transition towards enhanced liberalization in the future is doubtful. However, it is apparent to be the rational working hypothesis that this will. This has been reinforced by the potentialities of a stronger agency represented by the WTO that has assured to be a more effective dispute settlement mechanism.

A further consideration is made to the significant part played by the international investment in the global economy. It has been established that the control of international capital movement among the major industrialized nations particularly have been remarkably declined the last five decades. This is marked by considerable lowering of interest differentials that can be considered as a symbol of enhanced efficacy in the functioning of international financial markets. Such markets have also represented many innovations by international financial institutions that have been indicated in variations in their organizational structure and enhanced in the types of international financial tools made available to the market associates. Moreover, the considerable enhancement in foreign direct investment and the associated trade resulted in by multinational corporations. As most of the FDI is continued by the operating MNCs among the group of major industrialized nations there have been sizable movements of FDI to the newly industrialized countries particularly in East and Southeast Asia and also in Latin America. More significantly, the FDI serves to promote more efficient international allocation of resources…

Sources used in this document:
References

"Americans on Globalization: A Study of U.S. Public Attitudes." (28 March, 2000) Retrieved from http://www.pipa.org/OnlineReports/Globalization/introduction.html Accessed on 14 May, 2005

Deardorff, Alan V; Stern, Robert M. "An Overview of the Modeling of the Choices and Consequences of U.S. Trade Policy." The University of Michigan. Discussion Paper No: 400. Retrieved from http://www.fordschool.umich.edu/rsie/workingpapers/Papers376-400/r400.pdf Accessed on 14 May, 2005

Economics 104B - Lecture Notes Part III (November 9, 2004) "The Demand Side: Keynesian Economics" Retrieved from http://64.233.187.104/search?q=cache:1BoqrVQy0tgJ:economics.wustl.edu/~e104sf/lec-notes-III.doc Accessed on 14 May, 2005

Higgs, Robert. "Book Review: The Future of U.S. Capitalism." New York: Cambridge University Press. Retrieved from http://www. the.net/bookreviews/library/0554.shtml Accessed on 14 May, 2005
Introduction to Economics- Lecture Three. (2004) "The Tools of Economics Analysis." Retrieved from http://64.233.187.104/search?q=cache:DoVPMFlHSLkJ:www.sussex.ac.uk/economics/documents/ielec_0304.doc Accessed on 14 May, 2005
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Economic Growth and Happiness Economic Growth Can
Words: 1551 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Economic Growth and Happiness Economic Growth Can Lead to Healthier and Happier Societies More Availability of Goods Higher Income Increase in Tax Revenues and Better Welfare Programs. Increase in Purchasing Power Technological Advancement Health Industry Benefits Business Sector Benefits General Benefits Reflective statement Economic Growth Can Lead To Healthier and Happier Societies Economic growth has long been termed as the precursor to any society's success, and in this paper, we shall be looking at various aspects of economic growth that are directly

Economic Globalization Has the 2008 Financial Meltdown
Words: 2832 Length: 11 Document Type: Essay

Economic Globalization Has the 2008 financial meltdown in the U.S. And the ongoing economic crisis in Europe have practically ended the era of economic globalization? Following the financial crisis that marred the U.S. economy along with other global economies as well as the ongoing Eurozone debt crisis, there have been projected concerns that this predicament would end economic globalization. The purpose of this paper is to assess this claim. Going by Immanuel

Economic Final Report
Words: 1317 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Economic Final Report Types of economic systems Economic systems vary from one nation to another. Traditional economic systems refer to an economic system founded by tradition. The services and goods that people provide through the work they do, how people exchange and use the resources are trends that follow permanent patterns. These are not dynamic economic systems because there are minimal changes. In this economic system, people live on static standards. They

Economic Final Report
Words: 1491 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Economic Systems: An economic system is basically described as specific set of principles that addresses the production, distribution, and consumption of products and services. The involved parties in the production, distribution, and consumptions processes are usually determined by or dependent on the economic system. Throughout the history of humanity, different types of economic systems have evolved because different societies have placed varying emphasis on distinctive goals and priorities as part of

Economics the Keynesian Economic Theorists Follow an
Words: 1698 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Economics The Keynesian economic theorists follow an economic model that considers three factors in macroeconomic growth. These are income distribution, savings, and investment functions. These factors are derived from the theory's determination of equilibrium in the economy as determined by the relationship between employment, prices, and gross-domestic-product (Padalkina 18). The theory suggests that the economy does not have full employment, autonomous demand-component affect rate of growth, and investment decisions are not

Economics Mexico; How Interest Rates Can Be
Words: 1554 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Economics Mexico; How Interest Rates Can Be Used to Manage an Economy The management of the economy, undertaken with strategies from the government and decision fro the central bank, is usually undertaken with the aim of promoting and supporting a stable economy, balancing the desire for sustainable growth with the need to constrain inflation. This is an issue faced by almost all countries; inflation can be harmful to an economy, impacting not

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now