Verified Document

How Businesses Can Effect Positive CSR Essay

¶ … Corporate Social Responsibility Programs Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) programs are effective forms of management that directly and indirectly impact the "social, environmental and economic environment in which" the corporation functions (Castka, Bamber, Sharp, 2005, p. vii). In this context, corporations are viewed by societies as influential in the development of a "better world" (Friedman, Miles, 2002, p. 1). By using an ethical foundation for a business model, corporations have gained substantial market share and public trust because they are viewed as being good for the environment and for communities (as well as delivering a good product) while other companies have come under fire and social pressure for not living up to an ethical standard (Pearce, Doh, 2005). The factors that affect the implementation of CSR programs can range from governmental standards to stakeholder involvement to moral and ethical cultures (or lack thereof) within the corporate entity (AnyangoOoko, 2014). This paper will discuss these various factors and show how some act as facilitators towards implementation of CSR while others act as barriers.

Adopting a "spirit of mission" (Samaan, Verneuil, 2009) can be one of the best facilitators towards implementation of CSR. A spirit of mission within an organization creates an atmosphere of collective consciousness in which everyone at every level is a willing participant in the company's movement towards an ethical goal and objective. The company's aim, whether to provide a service or produce a product, is deemed beneficial to society, and the achievement of this aim is effected by way of ethical means, such as a virtue system or culture within the corporation/organization. This means providing guidance (corporate guidance for stakeholders) in terms of the value and importance of organizational culture maintenance and quality management. From a top-down perspective, this includes two-way communication flows and a theoretical model such as transactional management in order to facilitate internal growth in virtue behavior and external growth in community outreach and the maintaining of community/governmental standards (in terms of accounting, environmental waste, etc.).

Organizational discipline and "spirit of mission" are intimately linked in an organization's successful operation (Samaan, Vernueil, 2009) and greatly impact the implementation of CSR programs. The spirit of mission is collective in the sense that it is the motivating factor, the common interest, among individuals within an organization, driving them to achieve a specific aim or common good. Each individual adds to or takes away from the total spirit of mission. An apt metaphor may be found in the idea that each individual is a cylinder in an engine. If all cylinders are firing, working together and according to the precepts to which they are bound, the spirit of mission can be said to be operating optimally. The metaphor may be expanded in the sense that other factors contribute to the successful operation of an engine. However, for the purpose of this study, the essential "spirit" is such that it represents a guiding force or intelligence, without which no operation can succeed. When a discernible spirit is manifested, the surrounding community and consumer public are more likely to take note and show their appreciation, as the manifestation of a "spirit" demonstrates corporate social responsibility.

In organizations where the "spirit" is perceived to be reckless, say in a company like Enron, for instance, no CSR is demonstrated. As in the case of Enron, there was considerable irresponsibility in the keeping of financial records and oversight as the "spirit" of mission within the corporation was to get-rich-quick its way to the top. Some perceived this as a good, while others like Sherron Watkins did not. Conflict within an organization inevitably arises when the mission is perceived differently by two or more groups within the organization. One may accuse the other of lacking the right spirit. Aims may differ as a result and the corporation loses both cohesion and any grasp of CSR in the eyes of the public.

The idea of spirit of mission is, of course, thousands of years old. Sun Tzu (2010, p. 37) wrote, "He will win whose army is animated with the same spirit throughout all its rank." This idea is still commonly held today although generically and generally used in simplistic expressions, as in: team spirit, esprit de corps, community of interests, group spirit, etc. Regardless of the exact term, the idea is consistent in the sense of an entity (organization) rooted in achieving the common good, which is a notion that goes beyond the borders...

Thus, when NAFTA made it so that companies could go overseas for cheap labor, the level of corporate social responsibility that was displayed fell through the floor. Today, one of the talking points of front-running Republican candidate Trump is that his aim is to make companies more accountable and to bring jobs back home. This would line up well with the program of CSR because it would illustrate how the common good of a society is interwoven with its business practices. Thus, relaxed trade laws that tempt companies away from a desire to unite themselves to the national good is one barrier to the affective implementation of CSR -- and if Trump wants to be true to his promises, then ending the NAFTA will be a positive first step.
Another factor that affects the implementation of CSR is whether or not a company has an effective system of organizational discipline. Enron did not and its level of CSR, whatever it was, quickly fell apart. Organizations which suffer from corruption from within have failed to adopt a right spirit, a system of ethics, a habit of rightful acting and thinking, or a habit of virtue. A discussion of the merit of virtue ethics could coincide with a discussion of CSR because it is ethics which drives the mission, and as Samaan and Verneuil show in their study of the U.S. Coast Guard's response to Hurricane Katrina, it is this "spirit of mission" or level of corporate social responsibility that allowed them to be one of the only successful responding organizations at the time of that tragedy. Thus, the best recommended course of action for leaders responding to change in an organization would be to develop a "spirit of mission" that is ethical in the sense that it supports transparency and accountability.

In the U.S., Archer Daniels Midland (ADM) demonstrated a complete lack of CSR when it set aside law and ethics when it engaged in price-fixing of the lysine market with its competitors. Price-fixing is illegal in the U.S. and when the FBI was alerted to the actions of ADM, a sting operation was put into effect. Top executives at ADM were found guilty and sentenced to prison (Eichenwald, 2000). Here is an example of a business failing implement an effective CSR program within the accepted parameters of society's ethical/moral system and the codified laws of the nation. Instead of adhering to an ethical code, it participated in the act of dividing up market share, violating the trust of the U.S. government and costing itself millions of dollars in fines. It also contributed to the loss of the public's trust in large corporate entities as it served as a perfect example of how corporations are primarily concerned with their own good first and not that of the average citizen or consumer.

The reason that law and ethics are so readily flaunted in corporate systemology is fundamentally simple: there is a lack of respect either for the value of law or for the value of the other side of the negotiating party. Oftentimes, unsuccessful implementations of CSR will show that corporations view their competitors and even their consumers with distrust, trying to judge how the counterpart is taking advantage of him. This mentality goes against the principle of mutual respect and the spirit of collaboration that is so helpful in successful CSR implementations.

What fosters this lack of respect? Graham's (1983) study hints at the different cultural mentalities that breed unsuccessful negotiating skills. In America, for instance, Graham cites representational bargaining strategies as the most fundamental in American negotiations. By contrast, Brazilian negotiations are hotbeds of deceptive bargaining strategies, utilized to create outcomes that favor only one side of the negotiating table. Graham examines how cultural mentalities affect the way negotiators respect law, ethics, and the counterpart at the negotiating table.

In Leung and Tong's (2004) study of corporate models, they discuss culture as the arbiter of law and ethics. In this sense, it may be argued that the development of culture is essential in the maintaining of a law-abiding and ethical mentality, which can then be used to support successful, principled negotiations. Leung and Tong state that "cultural differences in justice practices may constitute significant barriers to intercultural negotiation" (Leung, Tong, 2004, p. 330). Because of cultural differences, however, (as the example of Russia's Gazprom and its European counterparts, for instance, shows), ideas of justice, fairness, law and ethics can actually become barriers. One side of the party, for instance,…

Sources used in this document:
References

AnyangoOoko, G. (2014). The environmental factors that influence implementation of corporate social responsibility (CSR) in an organization. Journal of Humanities and Social Science, 19(12): 95-102.

Castka, P., Bamber, C., Sharp, J. (2005). Implementing Effective Corporate Social

Responsibility and Corporate Governance: A Framework. UK: British Standards Institution.

De Maria, W. (2005). Whistleblower Protection: Is Africa Ready? Public
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Positive Effects of CSR
Words: 4374 Length: 16 Document Type: Research Paper

Corporate social responsibility and business ethics have become the focus of an increasing amount of attention from the business sector and academicians following the scandal-ridden era of Enron and others during the 1990s. Although the findings from the research to date are mixed, there is a growing body of research in this area that has lent support to the notion that ethical business practices and corporate social responsibility initiatives have

CSR Companies Talk a Lot About "Corporate
Words: 3276 Length: 11 Document Type: Essay

CSR Companies talk a lot about "corporate social responsibility," but quite frankly nobody really knows what the term means. Every company seems to interpret the idea a little bit differently. There is nothing inherently wrong with that, but it raises challenges for managers trying to understand the concept and what relevance it has to their organizations. The best approach has to be to analyze the different elements of CSR individually, and

CSR Corporate Social Responsibility Corporate
Words: 3757 Length: 14 Document Type: Term Paper

This kind of competition can prove to be more effective than governmental regulations since firms are reluctant to follow government mandates. Methodology: Secondary research has been used as the main tool. Important journal articles, case studies and analyses have been included to understand the concept of CSR and its use in gain competitive advantage. ANALYSIS and DISCUSSION Social responsibility is closely connected with concern for financial growth. According to this belief, firms seek

CSR Motivations CSR Motivations Behind Corporate Social
Words: 1494 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

CSR Motivations CSR Motivations behind Corporate Social Responsibility Organizations embark on social and environmental reporting for a variety of different reasons and not to simply improve credibility with stakeholders; although that is a primary reason in many organizations. However, other organizations have different objectives altogether that can include a range of different motivations. Some models have broken the range of motivations into signaling or greenwashing or used legitimacy theory to explain the motivations

CSR Responsibility Some of the
Words: 3415 Length: 8 Document Type: Research Proposal

In an era of terrorism and turbulence in global markets the greater the level of shared risk and transparency, the greater the likelihood financial institutions will be more resilient in the face of greater challenges of operation. This is a critical point that must be kept in mind in the context of the IFI CSR Maturity Model, as globalization forces a higher level of inter-process and cross-functional coordination throughout a

CSR Plan
Words: 2329 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Essay Topic Examples 1. The Intersection of Profit and Social Responsibility: Crafting a Balanced CSR Plan:     This topic explores how businesses can design a Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) plan that aligns with their profit goals while effectively contributing to social issues. The essay would delve into strategies for integrating ethical practices into the business model without compromising financial performance. 2. Measuring the Impact of CSR Initiatives on Community Development:     Focusing on the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now