Verified Document

Hot Seat; An Ethical Decision-Making Article Review

The simulations presented in the beginning pertinent background information and then subsequent screens presented at least three decision choices. Based on the selection, a new screen presented the client's response. The process ended when the students reached the end of a decision pathway. The simulation also took into account that many counseling situations do not have right or correct answers, and may be ambiguous. The realistic choices offered, were meant to encourage students to engage in critical thinking. Moreover, situations were also designed so that more than one ethical code would apply to each situation. But when students chose a decision pathway, the responses were true to life. After making the decision, the students had to confront with the typical consequences of their decisions. Ethical decisions required that students determined the relevant sections of the various ethical codes and prioritize the standards. Debriefing consisted in small groups' activities that reviewed individual decision-making processes and compared the advantages, disadvantages and consequences of their choices. The instructor also facilitated the exchange by pointing out the ways in which counseling's ethical standards can be interpreted and compared. The instructor provided feedback on the logical course of decision-making.

The evaluation stage consisted of a formative assessment of the simulation's strengths and weaknesses. An expert in computer-based training program design, a subject matter expert and 10 students participated. The evaluation consisted of both the participants' reaction to the program and one-to-one interviews. The results of the evaluation pointed out that the simulation made a good use of critical thinking skills and the notepad proved to be an effective tool for reflection. The classical screen design was also appreciated. Some of the concerns were that some students may need additional instructions to use the program accurately.

The authors...

Moreover, using such programs will help students to develop their ability to cope with ambiguity and provide a clear rationale for different professional and ethical behaviors. Another great advantage pointed out by the authors is that the program may be easily adapted to other disciplines such as business, legal, or medical ethics.
The strengths of the article are those already underlined by the authors and by the evaluation process: to develop critical, ethical thinking in counseling students, to increase their tolerance to ambiguity and provide familiarization with different ethical professional codes. The program was projected minutely, taking into account the students' needs about using the program; online help was provided to coach students use the program. Another great initiative on the part of the authors was the notepad pop-up window. Each time students made a decision a notepad pop-up appeared and recorded automatically the text for review. After completing the simulation, students took the printed simulation to class and the instructor reviewed the simulation. The instructor-initiated interactions can increase achievement and provide feedback.

The authors tried to increase the efficacy of the tool by including the needs of the participants, the ethical decision-making process, the ethical guidelines in the particular field of counseling, the ease of use, the cognitive gain of the participants and their critical and ethical thinking education, and the result obtained was important in the field of counseling and in the learning environment.

References

Frame, M.W., Flanagan, C.D, Frederick, J., Gold, R., Harris, S.(1997). You're in the hot seat; an ethical decision-making simulation for counseling students. Simulation and Gaming, March Vol. 28, No. No. 1, 107-115

Sources used in this document:
References

Frame, M.W., Flanagan, C.D, Frederick, J., Gold, R., Harris, S.(1997). You're in the hot seat; an ethical decision-making simulation for counseling students. Simulation and Gaming, March Vol. 28, No. No. 1, 107-115
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Moral or Ethical Difference if
Words: 2029 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

(2001, October 1) Self-esteem at work, Psychology Today, Retrieved from http://www.psychologytoday.com/articles/200310/self-esteem-work 6. Describe the needs present in Maslow's hierarchy. How can organizations attempt to meet these needs so that employees are motivated to produce more work? Discuss the answer in detail. According to Abraham Maslow (1970), there is a hierarchy of needs that define human development. These are: Basic Needs (food, shelter, clothing), Safety, Love and Belonging, Skill Accomplishment and Self-Actualization.

Informed Consent and Consent
Words: 2235 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

consent a "yes or no" response? Enhancing the shared decision-making process for persons with aphasia Informed consent constitutes a legal and moral requisite for any research works that involve fellow human beings. Study subjects are provided information regarding every element of a study trial deemed to be vital for subjects' decision-making, including study significance with respect to societal welfare and for advancing the medical field. After an examination of every

Leadership Style: What Do People Do When
Words: 1664 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Leadership Style: What Do People Do When they are Leading? Hewlett Packard (HP) remains one of the most successful computer and related services company in the Diversified Computer Systems industry. In this text, I concern myself with the leadership style of Meg Whitman -- the CEO of HP. In so doing, I will amongst other things analyze how her leadership style aligns with the company's culture. I will also examine Whitman's

Ethics and Risks Exercise 1 How Would
Words: 488 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Ethics and Risks Exercise 1 How would you measure the unethical behavior in an organization? "In its simplest terms, measuring performance means assessing business results to determine how effective a company's strategies and operations are and make changes to address shortfalls and other problems." (Performance Measurement) Performance is a good measurement against unethical behaviors. The process includes defining objectives, or setting clear objective goals, defining critical success factors, actions that must be

Home Depot Vs. Lowes Executive
Words: 8368 Length: 21 Document Type: Term Paper

Apart from that there is another type of risk which can surface even in case the market continues its upward march. In the event employees exercise their ESOPs in huge numbers, external shareholders could oppose the diluting impact of these option grants on the value of their shares. A situation might crop up that old possible tensions among employee interests and shareholder interests are not all of a sudden

Frivolous Lawsuits Hurt Our Country
Words: 3456 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

Frivolous Lawsuits The author of this report is charged with comparing and contrasting two example lawsuits that many people would deem frivolous. One of the cases relates to a man that apparently thought that the Winnebago motor homes could drive and steer themselves on par with the self-driven Google cars that are coming out just now in 2015. The other case pertains to a man that literally sued for $54 million

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now