Verified Document

Hospital Policies: Do They Always Apply In Emergency Situations  Essay

School Nurse Conflict Mission Mary Jackson did exactly what a professional RN should do -- she tended to the injured children that were her responsibility. It happened that her efforts spilled over into a hospital emergency room, which technically she did not have the legal right to practice in. But still, she acted according to the values that she was trained in and moreover, as a professional healthcare employee of a school, she knew these children and her instincts were to boldly provide triage and other emergency procedures to help the children. In addition, Mary is not just an RN, she is a Nurse Practitioner specializing in pediatrics, and her skills and training are well beyond those of an RN. Hence, she deserves respect and she deserves the benefit of the doubt when she acts in behalf of the children she is contractually and morally obliged to protect and care for.

The fact that the hospital is now questioning the legality of her presence in the emergency room puts Mary on the defensive albeit the real legal heat is on Dr. Edmond Yee and the Chief Nursing Officer Beatriz Garcia-Chavez for permitting Mary to work in the hospital without the proper credentials. Still, while the questions being raised are legitimate, the situation that Mary Jackson participated in was by any definition an emergency, and in most states a nurse is covered under Good Samaritan laws when she or he provides assistance to injure people in a disaster or an emergency -- in particular nurses are protected by Good Samaritan laws when an "unplanned act" occurs...

The more "formalized and planned a rescue becomes, the less you appear to be a spontaneous Good Samaritan" (Northrop, 51).
Do Good Samaritan Laws Protect the Nurse in Emergencies?

According to the peer-reviewed journal Nursing90, all states have Good Samaritan laws but those laws aren't all uniform, of course. In New York State, for example, the Good Samaritan law "…relieves nurses of liability for injuries that may have resulted from negligent nursing care at the scene of an accident or during another emergency" (Northtrop, 1990). In this case of course Mary was not negligent at all. And in fact a chemical spill is a terrifyingly dangerous emergency, because no one really knows at the time what the fumes from that spill have done to the lungs of the children. It is already known the children have suffered from burns, respiratory distress, and hydrogen chloride is an extremely toxic substance, but the real question is not whether Mary had the legal right to serve the children; the most pertinent question is, should the hospital staff insisted that Mary go through the facility's credentialing process.

And even though Mary's work was excellent and there is no reason for her to be sued for gross negligence or malpractice, under New Jersey laws nurses and paramedics are "…immune from liability for negligence that occurs while…'rendering advance life-support services in good faith and in accordance with the law" (Northrop, 51). Certainly providing life-support services was…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Klein, C.A. (2006). Nursing Responsibilities in a Disaster. The Nurse Practitioner, 31(11), 56.

Northrop, C.E. (1990). How Good Samaritan Laws Do Protect You. Nursing90, 20(2), 50-51.

Riverbend City: School Nurse Conflict Mission. Washington Allston Elementary School.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Policy Analysis of Oregon's Death
Words: 8143 Length: 25 Document Type: Term Paper

In March of 2005, she was finally removed from life support and died thirteen days later. The case had 14 appeals, numerous motions, petitions and hearings in Florida courts, five suits in the Federal District Court; Florida legislation struck down by the Supreme Court of Florida; a subpoena by a congressional committee in an attempt to qualify Terri for witness protection; federal legislation and four denials of certiorari from

Hospital the Facts: The Community
Words: 3048 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

During this period, market share is normally held fixed as a core planning assumption, with the potential share gains modeled inside specific strategies after sometime in the process. The genesis of strategic business planning is to secure, and if possible enhance, the financial situation of the organization, facilitating it to continue its mission well into the coming years. Midvale must build a macro level financial model connected to its

UK Mental Health Policy Mental Healthcare Service
Words: 5534 Length: 12 Document Type: Essay

UK Mental Health Policy Mental healthcare service delivery in the UK has been subjected to a series of significant imperative policy in the last few decades, and number of people suffering from mental illness is on the increase. Recent statistics reveal that one out of four people in the UK has been diagnosed of mental problem. (Mental Health Foundation, 2013, Singleton, Bumpstead, O'Brien et al. Meltzer 2001). Although, mental disorders are

Futile Care Policy for Hospitals
Words: 1108 Length: 3 Document Type: Research Paper

The hospital should always defer to the patient and family that has an advanced directive in place, and if the patient cannot speak for themselves but has an advanced directive, then a proxy must make the decision. The only case where the hospital should be allowed to make the decision on futile care is in the absence of a proxy, in the absence of an advanced directive, and only

Suicide Prevention Intervention in the Emergency Department
Words: 3348 Length: 11 Document Type: Essay

Lack of Mental Treatment and Support Introduction and Overview Emergency departments (EDs) can play a major role in reducing the risk and occurrence of suicide, self-harm and harm caused to others by taking steps to create a safety plan for the patient (Stanley et al., 2018). However, many EDs do very little to actually assist patients in this regard. My own experience at Legacy Treatment Center, where I interned, allowed me to

Nursing Law and Ethics Name
Words: 1913 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

The death of a child is significant and in this case avoidable and a plaintiff has the right to seek compensatory damages as is allowed by law. Case Study 1 Part B At the end of the night shift, Nurse Brown took a verbal handover and then noticed the observation chart had not been filled in. To assist her friend, Nurse Harvey, whom she knew had a busy night, filled in the

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now