Verified Document

Hitler's Willing Executioners By Daniel Goldhagen In Term Paper

¶ … Hitler's Willing Executioners by Daniel Goldhagen In his book, Hitler's Willing Executioners: Ordinary Germans and the Holocaust, Daniel Goldhagen attempts to explain why the Holocaust happened. Central to his thesis is the notion that German citizens were essentially regular human beings, living conventional lives, with complex social relationships and family obligations, who also happened to be staffing police battalions, organizing death marches, working in concentration and slave labor camps and basically facilitating Hitler's overwhelmingly murderous plan.

Daniel Goldhagen explores the motives behind the seemingly normalized crimes of mainstream German society, using as examples thousands of ordinary people who tormented, starved and murdered their former friends and neighbors. The author suggests that the nature of anti-Semitism at the time offered a palpable motive to German society, and partly explains the perpetrators' actions. Furthermore, Goldhagen tracks the history of anti-Semitism in Germany for several centuries and points out that it was a sentiment so deeply rooted in the collective conscience, for so many generations, that Germans were willing to kill Jews even when they would not have been penalized for refusing to do so.

The Holocaust, Goldhagen writes, was "the defining feature of German society during its Nazi period"; "No analysis of German society," he continues, "no understanding or characterization of it, can be made without placing the persecution and extermination of the Jews at its center" (p. 8).

Because the roots of anti-Semitism in Germany...

Anti-Semitism was a part of German culture, and the Nazis were able to introduce the concept of Holocaust with such ease, because for ordinary Germans, it simply made sense.
On page one of his book, Goldhagen quotes a German (non SS) commander who vocally protests a decree calling for his men to sign a promise not to steal. The commander felt strongly that this was an insulting assumption, and an affront to their character, and he led his men in a protest refusing to sign. This same commander was already responsible for the killing of tens of thousands of Jews, but was not the least bit reluctant to vociferously protest issues that struck him as immoral. But annihilation of the Jews was different, according to Goldhagen, since it did not strike ordinary German citizens as being the least bit immoral.

For much of his book, Goldhagen challenges conventional accounts of the Holocaust, which tend to focus on the few factory-like extermination camps such as Auschwitz. Though he understands the morbid interest in these unbelievable killing machines, he argues that most of the killing of the Holocaust was much more personalized and mainstream. "Virtually no evidence exists," Goldhagen writes, "to contradict the notion that the intense and ubiquitous public declaration of anti-Semitism was mirrored in people's private beliefs" (p. 30).

Goldhagen takes all previous scholarship to task, characterizing existing analysis…

Sources used in this document:
Goldhagen concedes that his radical interpretation presents a complicated proposition, and that his history of German anti-Semitism is not meant to be definitive. Still, he offers an important theory in that ordinary perpetrators were motivated by a pervasive type of anti-Semitism that had taken root from the 19th century onward and was widespread in German society. By the 20th century, leaders like Hitler were able to leverage this seething, collective hatred and to transform it into a public desire for extermination.

Chapters 13 and 14 of Hitler's Willing Executioners, focus on the westward death marches of camp inmates in 1945. A single march in particular (pp. 330-63) exemplifies the growing collective psyche of German society. No longer under orders, guards continued to behave as brutal killers, as they beat and humiliated their Jewish victims. With photographic support, Goldhagen depicts the cruelty of these marches and the faces of the sadistically grinning bystanders. Goldhagen also documents instances in which unit commanders offered their men the opportunity to opt out of the killing, but he finds few stories of soldiers who accepted the offer. Those who did opt out almost always did so because they were physically repulsed by the prospect of killing, though emotionally they would have gladly obliged.

The many hundreds of pages of support in Goldhagen's book have challenged the realm of Holocaust scholarship in a profound manner. Since its publication, the book has been hotly debated and disputed by academics and experts in the field, worldwide. Whether his claims are accepted universally, he has offered a perspective that enlightens a misunderstood period in modern history. Since it is only through understanding that we can keep history from repeating itself, Daniel Goldhagen has done the world a tremendous service in writing Hitler's Willing Executioners.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Germany and the Holocaust
Words: 1489 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Goldhagen and Browning: How the Holocaust Could Have Happened The Jewish Holocaust has inspired countless theories on how such an atrocity could take place in a seemingly humane and otherwise "normal" society, as Germany was in the 20th century. In other words, it was not really any different from any other society or culture in the modern era -- and yet understanding how the Holocaust could have happened, how human beings

Anti-Semitism Although the Term Anti-Semitism
Words: 1589 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

" (Jahoda 1998). Consequently, such points-of-view may be difficult to back. Anti-Semitism had ancient beginnings throughout Europe, but the Nazi's added a more modern scientific twist to these long-held beliefs: "The adversary is not Judaism, but Jewish genes. Nazism inverts the crucial diagnosis: the carrier of pollution is not ideology, religious dogmatics, discrete beliefs in and about God, it is, instead, the carnal being of the Jew, his or her very

Administrative Evil Review of Unmasking Administrative Evil
Words: 1343 Length: 5 Document Type: Book Report

Administrative Evil Review of Unmasking Administrative Evil In Understanding Administrative Evil, authors Guy B. Adams and Danny L. Balfour explore the idea and evolution of the concept of evil. Adams and Balfour begin by defining historical evil as "knowingly and deliberately inflicting pain and suffering on other human being" (xix). However, in modern times, this idea has undergone a critical change. Historical evil has evolved into administrative evil, a form of evil

Auschwitz Concentration Camp Frei, Norbert.
Words: 1810 Length: 6 Document Type: Article Review

This makes his argument less-than-convincing and too vague and philosophical in tone. Even many of his citations merely note authors, rather than actual page numbers. He references the authors' general ideas, rather than specific evidence they present. And some of the sources are in German, which make it difficult to trace his sources or even read the titles of many of the articles used in writing his piece. The most

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now