Verified Document

History Of Religion Historians Of Term Paper

As Tapper (1995) points out, the three major approaches of Western social theory are each "flawed by their commitment to positivism, objectivity, and scientific detachment," (p. 186). Some may wonder how it could be possible to study religion with scientific detachment, since scientific detachment is partly defined by the absence of religious sentiment. If a historian is too detached, he or she cannot come to terms with the language best used to understand any given tradition: for example the "body" of Muhammad and the Prophet's tribe. Denying relevance of mystical experiences, subversive or minority views, or even non-linear representations of history would be doing a disservice to the history of religion. A scholar doesn't necessarily have to spend time in a monastery to understand Zen but it wouldn't hurt. Encounters with terms and ideologies add the missing semantic value that can make a history of religion whole and truly meaningful. If scholastic inquiry aims to present an unbiased and thorough understanding it may be essential to temporarily adopt alternative frames of reference. At the same time, the scholarly history of religion depends on the presentation of historical material and artifacts without placing any value judgment upon those artifacts and texts. One of the problems Tapper (1995) found in the attempted construction of an Islamic anthropology was a hypocritical bias: in critiquing Western social science for its narrow-mindedness, Islamic anthropologists were themselves creating even less tenable methodologies. Any ideological approach to the social sciences can be problematic, but as Tapper (1995) shows, ideology can offer interesting and valid alternative points-of-view. Without Marxist or feminist ideologies, academic would be bereft of a thorough understanding of history and likewise, an Islamic ideology is welcome as an integral part of the history of religion.

Finding a common lexicon and agreeing upon terms remains one of the fundamental challenges...

Religious terms take on whole other meanings when used by insiders: keepers of the faith. Believers, practitioners, and even those members of a society who do not ascribe to the theological reality of a religion but still acknowledge its social function: all ascribe different semantic values to religious terms too. The social function of religion is indeed important, whether or not a practitioner acknowledges any mundane function of religion. Religion is an especially problematic area of research because it intertwines elements of the sacred with the mundane. Varisco's "sacred history" offers a bridge between sacred and profane realities: ways to understand religion from a multitude of perspectives and remain as unbiased as possible.
Assumptions and researcher bias will continue to plague social scientists in any field. Because its practitioners are human, historians of religion are not exempt from researcher bias. Minimizing bias therefore remains a core challenge for the historian of religion. To minimize bias, historians of religion can engage in responsible scholarship by clearly defining terms at the outset of the research, adopting a lexicon and semantic framework relevant for the study, and by acknowledging and expressing the ideological standpoint from which the research is conducted. Finally, the responsible historian of religion clarifies goals and aims of the research. The evolution of theological thought, changes in the social function of one or more religions, comparison of various religions in terms of theology, individual-level or community-wide impact are a few of many possible discourses.

References

Tapper, R. (1995). 'Islamic anthropology' and the 'Anthropology of Islam'. Anthropological Quarterly. 68(3): 185-193.

Varisco, D.M. (1995). Metaphors and sacred history: the geneaology of Muhammad and the Arab 'Tribe'. Anthropological Quarterly.…

Sources used in this document:
References

Tapper, R. (1995). 'Islamic anthropology' and the 'Anthropology of Islam'. Anthropological Quarterly. 68(3): 185-193.

Varisco, D.M. (1995). Metaphors and sacred history: the geneaology of Muhammad and the Arab 'Tribe'. Anthropological Quarterly. 68(3): 139-156.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Religions of Rome
Words: 817 Length: 3 Document Type: Book Review

Religions of Rome Throughout history, religion has been having a major impact on the societies around the world. In the case of the Romans, they had numerous religions that were practiced throughout the reign of the empire. To fully understand these ideas requires looking at the chapter titled Sol the Sun in the Art and Religions of Rome. This will be accomplished by summarizing the various points and discussing a broad

History of the Resurrection Tradition
Words: 3003 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

History Resurrection The History of Resurrection Tradition According to Merriam-Webster dictionary, the word 'resurrection' stands for "the state of one risen from the dead." Generally, resurrection refers to restoration to life of the person who is clinically dead. Concept of resurrection has been in existence in one form or the other since the very birth of the first human being in this planet. Over the centuries, different religions and mythological schools of thought

History of Science
Words: 331 Length: 1 Document Type: Term Paper

History Of Science Islam has made enormous contributions to modern science. However, in the article "Science and Civilization in Islam," Seyyed Hossein Nasr discusses not necessarily how Islam impacted modern science, but rather, shows how science was viewed in the ancient Islamic world. The author talks about both religion and science in context and illustrates how spiritual beliefs affect the worldview of a culture. Because of Islam's rich tradition of scientific

History in Three Keys Cohen,
Words: 1518 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

" However, as strange as these ideas may be to a modern reader or historian, that is all the more reason to demand the rigorous perspective demanded by Cohen. If objectivity is impossible, then looking at historical events from as many interpretations as possible provides a potential solution. Cohen's embrace of folklore, and of piecing together a patchwork quilt of perspectives is useful in unpacking the influence of people outside of

History of the Areas of
Words: 4350 Length: 15 Document Type: Essay

It was founded on the knowledge that spurred during the Renaissance and has placed significance on rational thought and cultural emphasis, which was not present before. Furthermore, with regards to the popularity of Baroque during this period, it is important to note that this style was able to combine the principles of science and the philosophies and doctrines of early Christianity, which has been very prominent in architectures built on

Religion in Human Transformation of the African-American
Words: 3249 Length: 12 Document Type: Term Paper

Religion in Human Transformation of the African-American topic with a focus on the African-American Christianity experience. The writer explores the transformation to Black Christianity and uncovers some of the underlying features of its existence. The writer examines the patterns and experiences of spirituality for the Black Christian experience in North America as well as the ways that the particular historical experiences of Blacks in the United States assisted in

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now