Hiring Quotas
The idealism of the 1960's civil rights movement left the United States with social and moral standards that do not necessarily reflect the reality of the culture of business and opportunity. Within the words of the civil rights activists and even the non-activist everyday person there are ideals associated with diversity that are rarely reflected in the work place. For many compounded reasons including opportunity, de jure segregation and even outright discrimination women and minorities still hold fewer positions of power in the work place, especially in representation to their statistical occurrence in the larger population. It was for this reason that many organizations adopted hiring quotas as a part of what is today known as affirmative action. Yet even though these quotas have engendered change in the diversity of the workplace, these quotas are being challenged today, by some, as unnecessary and even unjust.
Stepping away from neutrality, the Nixon administration began defending the rights and responsibilities of labor boards and companies to meet hiring quotas that would establish higher percentages of minorities in the construction trades. They recognized the inability of some trades to increase minority hiring without such mandates.
Attorney General John Mitchell defended the Labor Department's policy [of minority hiring quotas] by arguing that "it is now well recognized in judicial opinions that the obligation of nondiscrimination... does not require, and in some circumstances may not permit obliviousness or indifference to the racial consequences of alternative courses of action which involve the application of outwardly neutral criteria."
Bryner 60)
Prior to these decisions by congress the civil rights legislation that was intended to assist the minority workers was being used to discriminate against them as individuals and businesses practiced "legal neutrality" which without proof of discrimination, a very difficult kind of proof to obtain, was considered legally responsible.
The Labor Department hailed its policy [of hiring quotas] as a "major breakthrough in the fight for equality of opportunity in employment."
(Bryner 60)
During the Reagan administration challenges were made to the hiring quotas, again through the view of them upholding discrimination rather than combating it, because they used race and gender as a part of the process.
Laham 74)
Reagan reiterated his diehard opposition to racial and gender quotas in employment, arguing that "Quotas deny jobs to many who would have gotten them otherwise, but who weren't born a specified race or sex. That's discrimination pure and simple and exactly what the civil rights laws were designed to stop.9"
Laham 74)
Opponents, in the Reagan era were successfully able to challenge the attempts to discredit and abolish these affirmative action tools by arguing with the real numbers that proved their effectiveness. Yet, a more modern assault on the system seems to be gaining steam and threatening to abolish these effective tools for diversity. Opponents of affirmative action even call the policies discriminatory to the majority, referring to the white male as the invisible victim of discrimination.
Lynch iii)
Yet clearly the hiring quotas established by the civil rights legislation and it aftermath have clearly demonstrated a good, albeit artificial, start to the establishment of representative diversity in the work place. "In 1964, just as the Civil Rights Act was being passed, it condoned 'temporary' hiring quotas in organizations with a history of racial discrimination. It continued to reject 'reverse discrimination,'"
Gavora) Reverse discrimination is a concept that claims that hiring quotas and other affirmative actions standards discriminate against the majority. Most legislators agree that the standards have and continue to make a difference in the opportunities of minorities and women to establish careers…
Law Enforcement and Hiring Laws Types of Policing Community policing primarily consists of law enforcement through police patrol and presence. Problem oriented policing is very similar to community policing, except that instead of merely patrols actions are directed to address a specific problem. A problem oriented policing response is exemplified by increased patrols at problem traffic intersections or enforcement of pedestrian crossing from speeding traffic. Problem oriented policing is noted to have
Affirmative Action in Hiring and Firing in the Ad Industry and/or Ad Firms Advertising in the United States means a lot of money and as much as $2.1 million is spent on each advertisement during the Super Bowl advertisements lasting for 30 seconds. There is now a question as to whether the composition of workers within the industry, both in the creative sections and in the non-creative sections will affect the
With this ruling the Court upheld legality of affirmative action. In considering the reasoning behind the Court's upholding of the highly debated principle, the rationale was that to remedy past discrimination, a program that is race-based must be put into effect. Clearly, the Court was concerned with becoming intertwined in the daily administration of academic programs, and the same would have likely held true for the workplace. The Bakke case had
H-1B Visa In recent years the debate over immigration has taken center stage. In particular, the federal government's H1B visa program has become a particularly contentious issue. Those who oppose the program or the size of the program believe that it takes jobs away from American citizens in fields that have traditionally high pay such as technology. Those who are proponents of the program believe that it is beneficial because it provides
2%; 7.8% minority females and 1.51% minority males. Minorities comprise 29.8% of its workforce in the U.S. They are 6.2% Asian, 14.4% African-American, 8.4% Hispanic and .8% Native American. Minorities account for 22.% of its officials and managers and 35.5% of newly hired employees. Of these,. 31.4% are female (Xerox Corporation). Its diversity initiatives consist of a balanced workforce strategy, a minority or female vendor program and work life programs (Xerox
The way that this relates to the work place, is that any kind of slight variation in the quota system can open the flood gates for these kinds of suits to occur. Then, when the court does not provide consistency in their rulings it creates even more confusion. When you look beyond the quota system, it is clear that this basic principal, of taking something away from one group and
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now