¶ … Ethical Analysis of Healthcare Rationing
The topic of health care rationing has been the subject of debate in the U.S. The last few years as government expenditures on health care have far exceeded budgeted levels. Central to the concern is the ethical issue over whether it is better if fewer Americans profit with a greater amount of health resource allocation or if the majority benefit to a lesser degree for an equity in health care benefits. In the essay, "We've Got To Ration Health Care," (author unknown) the position is taken that America would fare better to follow the course of health care action seen in other western countries, where it is considered better to ration medical procedures to the extent that a system provides "the highest possible level of basic health care that can be delivered to all the people." With the growing concern over health care rationing, and the discussion of developing explicit government policy to provide authority over resource allocation, the ethics of current practice in medical directives must be examined for its usefulness, privileges, and community benefit.
According to Raymond J. Devettere, university professor in the Department of Philosophy at Emmanuel College, the rights-based Utilitarian theory that supports the "happiness" of the greatest number of individuals, can be applied to the clinical ethics perspective of health care rationing. He takes an Aristotoleian position that the decision-maker should base his or her ethical values on patient well-being rather than established guidelines prepared by others external to the case. This involves incorporating the perspectives of all individuals involved: the patient, relatives, doctors, nurses, administrators,...
Health Care Rationing How Health Care Rationing Could Improve the Health of the U.S. Population Health care rationing has often been viewed as something horrific and voiced in the American media as a scare tactic by politicians. For instance, in September 2009 former U.S. vice presidential candidate Sarah Palin claimed that reforms proposed by the Obama administration would bring "rationing" into the American medical system (Hoffman, 2013). However, Palin's claims are rather
Nursing Management and Leadership An Analysis of Healthcare Rationing While nursing, and healthcare in general, often gets negative publicity for the idea of rationing care, in many cases it is a necessity. Hospitals and nurses only have so much time and so many resources available to them and have to decide where these resources are best invested in an ethical manner. Deciding where to ration care due to limited resources is a
And, secondly, what's the rush? If this is so good for us and everyone understands the program, then what is the answer to those two questions? The answers are, in order, because most Americans have no clue what the program is due to the fact that the menu changes so often and so quickly and all we get is sound bites. What's the rush? So politicians like Mr. Obama and
(Menzel, 1990, p. 3) Fisher, Berwick, & Davis alude to the idea of integration in health care, with providers linking as well as creating networks of electronic medical records and other cost improvement tactics. The United States and other nations over the last twenty or so years, have begun a sweeping change in health care delivery, regarding the manner in which health information is input, stored and accessed. Computer use
Libertarianism In what sense is Judge Napolitano's view of health care libertarian? There are several reasons it is libertarian. First, libertarianism is against the healthcare mandate in that they would be against a person being forced to buy anything, even healthcare. Also, Napolitano in particular does not believe healthcare is a right as it is not defined or stated in the United States Constitution. Indeed, the United States was founded in the
Healthcare Delivery System Challenges The American healthcare system has been criticized as favoring the middle and upper classes while ignoring the lower classes. Based on these speculations, the federal government has constantly tried to institute reforms in the healthcare sector though some of the proposals have failed to overhaul the industry. With rising insurance costs, the number of citizens barred from accessing quality healthcare has increased to more than 45
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now