Verified Document

Healthcare Legislation And Economic Competition Research Paper

Antitrust Legislation and Healthcare The Sherman Anti-Trust Act (1890) was designed to promote competitive practices in the marketplace and protect consumers from price gouging and other egregious practices generated from a lack of competition in monopolistic markets. It was not originally designed to impact the healthcare market but over the years its protections have been extended to do so

Strengths

Antitrust and anticompetitive laws were not always applied to physician and healthcare conduct. But in Goldfarb v. Virginia State Bar (1975), the “Supreme Court made it clear that professional conduct that interfered with normal market processes would face a heavy burden of justification and might even be unlawful per se” (Sage, Hyman, & Greenberg, 2003, par. 18). This ensured that collusion between healthcare providers, including withholding information, was illegal. It also meant that it was illegal to limit the actions of consumer ratings agencies which graded physicians and other healthcare providers. This was deemed to be necessary to the free flow of information needed for commercial activity. Antitrust laws are thus designed to promote transparency as well as consumer choice, given that transparency is necessary for a competitive economic system to flourish.

Weaknesses

Perhaps unsurprisingly, physicians have been largely opposed...

Physicians believe that collaboration between providers, healthcare agencies, and other regulatory organizations will improve rather than inhibit delivery of quality services. “Suppose a payer approaches you and several of your colleagues, who are competitors. The payer gives you a contract and fee schedule that you review with your colleagues’ (Cohen, 2003, par. 5). Physicians state that as professionals, reviewing such contracts between themselves could facilitate rather than inhibit better patient care.
On the other hand, critics of the Sherman Antitrust Act state that it has not done enough to protect consumers. In many healthcare markets, there are relatively few providers, which substantially limits consumer choice. Also, under current law, consumers cannot purchase healthcare policies across state lines and even the healthcare exchanges under the Affordable Care Act (ACA) are limited by state. Also, the limits upon government regulation to merely curtail a lack of competition does not address issues such as spiraling drug price costs, given that the federal government cannot cap drug prices (Chamseddine, 2015).

Opportunities

Given the recent passage of the Affordable Care Act (ACA) and calls for reform, there are hopes the legislative climate is…

Sources used in this document:

References

Chamseddine, J. (2015). Obamacare, antitrust laws can coexist, says FTC official.

Washington Health Policy Week in Review. Retrieved from: http://www.commonwealthfund.org/publications/newsletters/washington-health-policy- in-review/2015/dec/dec-21-2015/obamacare-antitrust-laws-can-coexist

Cohen, J. (2012). How antitrust laws hinder the goals of healthcare reform. Medical Economics.

Retrieved from: http://medicaleconomics.modernmedicine.com/medical- economics/news/modernmedicine/modern-medicine-now/how-antitrust-laws-hinder- goals-healthcare?page=full

Sage, W., Hyman, D. & Greenberg, W. (2003). Why competition law matters to healthcare

quality. Health Affairs, 22(2) 31-44. Retrieved from:

http://content.healthaffairs.org/content/22/2/31.full

 

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Public Healthcare Legislation the Public
Words: 3721 Length: 11 Document Type: Thesis

As the president works to pass what is most assuredly his most important legislative package to date, he is struggling against a great wall of opposition which appears to be driven by a philosophical aversion to public funding of a deeply privatized industry. The result is a tremendous amount of pressure on the president and a reigning fear in the public that he will be forced to capitulate. There are

Health Care Reform: One of the Major
Words: 1254 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Health Care Reform: One of the major topics that have had a long history in the United States is health care reforms, which has been characterized by huge debates. Following decades of failed attempts by various Democratic presidents, a new law was enacted by President Obama to overhaul the country's health care system. The enactment of this legislation came after a year of harsh partisan combat with the purpose of ensuring

Healthcare and the Uninsured According
Words: 1691 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Proposal

Polls examining public support of the bill and specifically the public healthcare option vary significantly. With regard to physicians, the New England Journal of Medicine surveyed over six thousand medical doctors and found there was a majority in favor of federally provided public healthcare insurance (Keyhani & Federman). Other polls have suggested an opposition to the public option (Marmor). The public option would provide an affordable alternative to the current

Healthcare Organization
Words: 2433 Length: 8 Document Type: SWOT

Introduction The main objective of this assignment is to conduct a SWOT analysis for a healthcare organization. Essentially, SWOT analysis is a beneficial framework for scrutinizing an organization’s strengths and weaknesses, and the opportunities and threats experienced. It is beneficial in being aware of the weaknesses and emphasizing on the strengths, alleviating threats, and capitalizing on the opportunities accessible. SWOT analysis lays emphasis on the internal factors of an environment, which

Healthcare Issues, Systems, and Policies America, Once
Words: 1435 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Healthcare Issues, Systems, And Policies America, once the global leader in the health of its population and among the nations with the highest quality and most readily available healthcare services, has now fallen behind almost twenty other countries, including some that only became industrialized in the last third of the 20th century, and with substantial assistance from the United States. While most other so-called "First-World" nations have already embraced several fundamental

Health Care in the U.S. and Spain
Words: 7032 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

Health Care in the U.S. And Spain What Can the U.S. Learn About Health Care from Spain? In 2009, Spain's single-payer health care system was ranked the seventh best in the world by the World Health Organization (Socolovsky, 2009). By comparison, the U.S. health care system ranted at 37 (Satiroglou, 2009). The Spanish system offers coverage as a right of citizenship that is constitutionally guaranteed. Spanish residents pay no expenses out-of-pocket, with

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now