Verified Document

Healthcare And Immigration Policy Essay

Definition and Description of the Issue Health policy and immigration policy are interconnected, as attitudes towards immigrants—especially those who are undocumented—have impacted the substantive content of healthcare policies like the Affordable Care Act. Similarly, immigration policies have been influenced by real or imaginary threats immigrants may pose to public health or public health spending. Political and economic expediency guides both health and immigration policy, whereas frontline healthcare workers including nurses have a direct ethical and professional responsibility to patients regardless of immigration status. Effective public policy blends the ethic of duty to care with an honest evaluation of budgetary constraints and evidence-based practice. As much as possible, immigrant-related health policy ignores emotionally laden and fallacious rhetorical arguments.

Background

Since the nineteenth century, healthcare and immigration policy have been inextricably linked. New immigrants have been blamed for public health problems and for burdening the public health budget, and have also been labeled as being undeserving of health benefits (Mitchell, 2018). As a result, health policy in the United States has veered towards being anti-immigrant and exclusionary, culminating in a series of executive orders issued by President Trump that “fanned the flames of that anti-immigrant narrative, raising it into the country’s national consciousness,” (Center for Health Progress, 2018). The Affordable Care Act had only offered provisions for permanent residents, opening the healthcare insurance marketplace to green card holders and other documented immigrants—with strident provisions such as a mandatory five year residency period prior to eligibility (National Conference of State Legislatures, 2017). Therefore, even documented immigrants struggle to access essential services, and suffer from a wide range of mental and physical health problems as a result of denial of coverage. Undocumented immigrants are systematically excluded from accessing the healthcare insurance marketplace, but in some cases may be able to receive some emergency treatments, immunizations, and some disaster relief programs (National Conference of State Legislatures, 2014). The current state of immigrant health policy remains in flux, bogged down by inconsistencies among various states and rapidly changing rhetoric. The way forward is through a clarification of federal healthcare and immigration policy that aligns healthcare ethics with the principles of social justice.

Stakeholders

While the most vulnerable population, undocumented immigrants are also part of a broader social network. Therefore, American citizens and permanent residents are also primary stakeholders in immigrant healthcare policy. Immigrant healthcare policy also has a strong bearing on public health outcomes. Punitive immigration policies and irregular immigration policy enforcement leads to “profound mistrust of health services, avoiding health services, and sacrificing their health and the health of their family members,” (Rhodes, Mann, Siman, et al., 2014, p. 329). Fear of deportation also compounds mental health issues among immigrant communities—undocumented or not—with measurable increase in diagnosed cases of depression, anxiety, and post-traumatic stress disorder (Martinez, Wu, Sandfort, et al., 2015). Likewise, research shows that individuals living in states with “a more exclusionary immigration policy climate had higher rates of poor mental health days than participants in states with a less exclusionary policy climate,” (Hatzenbuehler, Prins, Flake, et al., 2017, p. 169). Both legal permanent residents and undocumented residents are underinsured; and about 28% of foreign-born residents in the United States are undocumented (Messias, McEwen & Clark, 2015). Undocumented immigrants and legal permanent residents can be considered primary stakeholders, but because healthcare policy ultimately affects all Americans, the stakeholder base should be expanded to include all taxpayers and all healthcare workers who daily meet with the struggle between the ethical duty to care and the financial barriers to providing care to individuals who need it.
Issue Statement

Immigration policy and health policy must converge to undermine the stranglehold insurers have on healthcare and allow for a single payer option that efficiently allocates funding for essential services. Anti-immigrant policy is not only unethical and impossible to align with healthcare ethics, but also impractical and ultimately, financially untenable. Boosting immigrant health promotes improved public health services for all.

Possible Methods of Addressing the Issue

Addressing the issue through policy change allows for an entrenchment of moral values that undergird the healthcare system. Furthermore, changes to immigrant health policy can spill over into other areas of concern including general immigration policy and economic policy. “When the…

Sources used in this document:

References

Center for Health Policy (2018). Immigration policy is health policy. https://centerforhealthprogress.org/blog/publications/immigration-policy-is-health-policy/

Hatzenbuehler, M.L., Prins, S.J., Flake, M., et al. (2017). Immigration policies and mental health morbidity among Latinos: A state-level analysis. Social Science & Medicine 174(2017): 169-178.

Ku, L. & Jewers, M. (2013). Health care for immigrant families. Migration Policy Institute. https://www.migrationpolicy.org/topics/health-welfare-benefits

Kuczewski, M.G. (2017). How medicine may save the life of US immigration policy. AMA Journal of Ethics. https://journalofethics.ama-assn.org/article/how-medicine-may-save-life-us-immigration-policy-clinical-and-educational-encounters-ethical-public/2017-03

Martinez, O., Wu, E., Sandfort, T., et al. (2015). Evaluating the impact of immigration policies on health status among undocumented immigrants. Journal of Immigrant and Minority Health 17(3): 947-970.

Messias, D.K.H., McEwen, M.M. & Clark, L. (2015). The impact and implications of undocumented immigration on individual and collective health in the United States. Nursing Outlook 63(1): 86-94.

Mitchell, R.L. (2018). How does immigration policy affect public health in the US? Texas A&M Today. May 3, 2018. https://today.tamu.edu/2018/05/03/how-does-immigration-policy-affect-public-health-in-the-us/

National Conference of State Legislatures (2014). Federal benefits available to unauthorized immigrants. http://www.ncsl.org/research/immigration/federal-benefits-to-unauthorized-immigrants.aspx

National Conference of State Legislatures (2017). Immigrant eligibility for health care programs in the United States. http://www.ncsl.org/research/immigration/immigrant-eligibility-for-health-care-programs-in-the-united-states.aspx

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Health Care a Major Challenge
Words: 2346 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

The expectations for these kinds of changes will be to see gradual shifts at first. Where, it may not seem like anything is changing at the facility. However, over the course of time, these kinds of changes will be obvious in the quality of treatment that is being provided will improve. As a result, the strategy will take approximately one year to fully implement a change in the atmosphere of

Health Care 1875-1900 the History
Words: 1413 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

The American Public Health Association (APHA) is founded. This organization is concerned with the social and economic aspects of health problems. The National Quarantine Act is signed into law. This legislation is designed to prevent entry into the country of persons with communicable diseases. 1899 the National Hospital Superintendent's Association is created. It later becomes the American Hospital Association. Patel & Rushefsky, 1995, p. xvii) The seeds of health care legislation and centralization began

Healthcare Propsal: Are Immigrants Left
Words: 2880 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Proposal

Unless the physicians can succinctly argue their case for care and services, the managed care entity will, for reasons of medical necessity, deny access to care and services. What Cost-Added Ratio Based on Illegal Immigrant Population? The argument by opponents that loopholes exist that would allow illegal immigrants to access Obama's proposed legislation on healthcare services is rendered moot in lieu of the fact that those illegal immigrants are currently receiving

Healthcare Administration
Words: 835 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Healthcare Administration: Healthcare Law, Cultural Diversity, And Principles of Accounting Cities, Suburbs, And Rural Areas Rural areas are geographic areas located away from suburbs and cities, often characterized by a small population and abundant natural resources. Currently, in the U.S., rural residents make up 16% of the entire population - as compared to 17% in 1910. This implies that poor job opportunities and lack of skills that are evident in these areas

Health Care Disparity in Maryland
Words: 18449 Length: 67 Document Type: Dissertation

Figure 1 portrays the state of Maryland, the location for the focus of this DRP. Figure 1: Map of Maryland, the State (Google Maps, 2009) 1.3 Study Structure Organization of the Study The following five chapters constitute the body of Chapter I: Introduction Chapter II: Review of the Literature Chapter III: Methods and Results Chapter IV: Chapter V: Conclusions, Recommendations, and Implications Chapter I: Introduction During Chapter I, the researcher presents this study's focus, as it relates to the

Immigration Policy Discussion and Argument
Words: 1143 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Paper

Another state in the U.S., Utah, after the law enforcement which was delayed by the Arizona court, this state has adopted another option regarding the immigration policy for the state. The governor of the state said that Utah is not a state where the illegal immigrants can move and have jobs without having the fear for being deported, this is how should be (MSNBC, 2010).The Utah has a different model

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now