Verified Document

Health Care How Would You Case Study

It is either that his condition is not curable and therefore the treatment that he is receiving is of no benefit. The common examples of these are that a surgeon is performing a surgery on a patient with terminal cancer. Patients who have terminal cancer have gotten the cancer spread all throughout their body. It is only until time that their organs will go into failure and they will pass away. Another example is of keeping brain dead people on life support for other reasons. As it would be expected, this is quite a sensitive area and it would involve arguments with the patient's relatives and friends. It is understandable that the loved ones do want to do anything they can to keep the patient in front of them and to cure them in whatever means possible. The major argument with futile care is that it only prolongs death and that there is no positive outcome with it. (Appel, 2009) In places where resources are limited, futile care takes away resources from patients who do have a chance of survival. It is true that it's not ethical to deprive a person medical assistance, but it is not also fair to hog up resources that could be used in more hopeful cases.

Question 4: Read over the EMTALA statute to see why the courts have used it to cover the case.

The Emergency Medical Treatment and Active Labor Act (EMTALA) is an act passed by the United State Congress. This act basically requires hospital to give care to anyone who requires emergency healthcare regardless of their legal status, economical condition or their citizenship....

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

The hospital that is presented with the patient can switch hospital or discharge the patient under the patient's own consent. They can also move the patient after he or she is stabilized or they can move the patient to a facility where services are better.
This act basically states that the hospital has to do something when the patient arrives in the emergency. Therefore, the hospital could not argue because having trouble breathing was a medical emergency. Using this act, the court ruled in favor of the mother that the hospital has to put the baby on ventilator when she has trouble breathing. This court does not rule out or define as to the prognosis of the case at hand. Due to this reason, the fact that chances of survival of this baby were almost zero did not make any difference to this act.

The act requires for the hospital to stabilize the condition and not to cure the underlying disorder. It should be noted that anencephalic infants are not brain dead because their brain stem is working. This allows for autonomic and voluntary process like breathing keep on functioning. This act also did not have any special clauses for anencephalic infants. Therefore, this act is applied to all of the cases that arrive in the emergency room. Thus, we see here that the hospital services should be provided to anyone who comes in the emergency room. However, if resources are scarce, then technically decisions should be made in favor of the people who have more chances of survival.

References

Appel, J. (2009). What's So Wrong with "Death Panels"?. [online] Retrieved from: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/jacob-m-appel/whats-so-wrong-with-death_b_366804.html [Accessed: 26 Jul 2013].

Doyle, D. (2010). WebmedCentral.com:: Baby K. A Landmark Case In Futile Medical Care. [online] Retrieved from: http://www.webmedcentral.com/article_view/969 [Accessed: 26 Jul 2013].

Gardent, P. And Reeves, S. (2009). Ethics Conflicts in Rural Communities: Allocation of Scarce Resources. [e-book] Lebanon, NH: University Press of New England. http://geiselmed.dartmouth.edu/cfm/resources/ethics/chapter-09.pdf [Accessed: 26th July, 2013].

Pomerance, J., Morrison, A., Williams, R. And Schifrin, B. (1989). Anencephalic infants: life expectancy and organ donation.. Journal of perinatology, 9 (1), pp. 33-37.

Sources used in this document:
References

Appel, J. (2009). What's So Wrong with "Death Panels"?. [online] Retrieved from: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/jacob-m-appel/whats-so-wrong-with-death_b_366804.html [Accessed: 26 Jul 2013].

Doyle, D. (2010). WebmedCentral.com:: Baby K. A Landmark Case In Futile Medical Care. [online] Retrieved from: http://www.webmedcentral.com/article_view/969 [Accessed: 26 Jul 2013].

Gardent, P. And Reeves, S. (2009). Ethics Conflicts in Rural Communities: Allocation of Scarce Resources. [e-book] Lebanon, NH: University Press of New England. http://geiselmed.dartmouth.edu/cfm/resources/ethics/chapter-09.pdf [Accessed: 26th July, 2013].

Pomerance, J., Morrison, A., Williams, R. And Schifrin, B. (1989). Anencephalic infants: life expectancy and organ donation.. Journal of perinatology, 9 (1), pp. 33-37.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Health Care Law Ethics
Words: 383 Length: 1 Document Type: Essay

Healthcare Health Care Law Ethics Health care over the years has become one of the most important debates to take place within the United States of America. This fact holds particularly true for the major part of the Obama Administrations whose New Health Care policies has been criticized extremely (Zhi Qu, 2010). The world, however, is still waiting for the final curtain to rise and to witness the climax which would be

Healthcare Must Be Provided by the Government to All Citizens Who...
Words: 2176 Length: 6 Document Type: Research Paper

Health Care As human beings, our health and longevity have never been better. Many people today live to 100 years and beyond, and often in good and active health. One of the major reasons for this is better health care and more access to health care for more people. On the other hand, however, many people do not have access to the same health care services as others. Often, the main

Healthcare Issues, Systems, and Policies America, Once
Words: 1435 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Healthcare Issues, Systems, And Policies America, once the global leader in the health of its population and among the nations with the highest quality and most readily available healthcare services, has now fallen behind almost twenty other countries, including some that only became industrialized in the last third of the 20th century, and with substantial assistance from the United States. While most other so-called "First-World" nations have already embraced several fundamental

Healthcare Economics Overall Healthcare and Economics Healthcare
Words: 1497 Length: 4 Document Type: Research Paper

Healthcare Economics Overall Healthcare And Economics Healthcare economics: Current challenges from a nursing perspective Although the subject of healthcare economics has been hotly-debated, on one issue there is widespread agreement: the aging of the population will substantively increase the demand for healthcare in the near and far future. As the population worldwide is aging and living longer, the need for essential services over a longer lifespan will generate more costs for an already-beleaguered

Healthcare Reform Lowering Costs in
Words: 918 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

The amendments have had practical impacts such as repealing the tax mandate of the employer, health insurance tax of small businesses and decreasing the burdens on individuals and businesses. The compliance cost for small business owners has risen by 36% higher than that of larger corporations. Similarly, the average U.S. citizen has already been overtaxed. Since the passing of the Affordable Care Act, Americans have not enjoyed the benefits that

Healthcare Information Technology Electronic Medical Record: User
Words: 1472 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

Healthcare Information Technology Electronic Medical Record: User friendliness is among the significant factors- probably the most essential factor- hampering extensive usage of Electronic Medical Record EMRs in respiratory therapy within my organization. User friendliness features a powerful, usually direct connection with my organization's efficiency, error level, operator exhaustion and operator satisfaction- are all essential elements for EMR usage. Moreover, within my organization, it's been observed that efficient coaching and execution techniques impact

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now