According to Robert Kastenbaum, using the term "stages" implies that there is a set order of set conditions, and asserts that there is no evidence that dying people go through the exact Kubler-Ross stages in their proper order (Stages pp). He believes that any patient could experience the stages in a different order, or could experience emotions not even mentioned in the Kubler-Ross stages (Stages pp). He explains that in her research Kubler-Ross showed that various patients exhibited qualities from the five different stages, but no one particular patient demonstrated all five stages in order, thus any emotional experience during the dying process of a person could be considered a stage (Stages pp).
Many feel that Kubler-Ross' research needed to be followed up by another form of data gathering, and that had she done this, her theory would be more valid (Stages pp).
Some critics suggested other methods of research, such as behavioral studies and personal diaries kept by patients, might make up for some of the flaws of the interview process, for example, the fact that the information gathered by the interviewer may vary depending on the relationship between the researcher and the patient, and what a patient feels and what a patient reveals in an interview may be two different things (Stages pp). Moreover, many feel that the Stage Theory tends to prescribe rather than describe, and that since the theory has become so popular, it is common for positive value to be place on the attainment of each new stage (Stages pp). Thus, patients may rush themselves or may be pressured by family members to move through the stages on some imaginary schedule (Stages pp). In other words, patients may feel that they must accept their death in order to die properly, simply because that's what the "famous" theory prescribes (Stages pp). Furthermore, the stages of dying can become an easier and more convenient way for patients to deal with their death, rather than doing what comes naturally to them or having to seek answers on their own (Stages pp). Therefore, an individual's entire life may be over-looked in favor of the stages they feel they are supposed to be going through, because as a person nears death, it is easier to focus on the last months or weeks of life rather than to celebrate a person's life as a whole (Stages pp). The unique personality and identity of the person may be lost as they supposedly move through these generic stages (Stages pp). Each individual's experiences are unique and different, thus each person's death process is unique (Stages pp).
However, regardless of her critics, Kubler-Ross' model had an impact on society and motivated people to think about coping with death, and to appreciate that it is important to help understand and care for the needs of those in their final weeks and days (Stages pp). Moreover, many of the problems with the Kubler-Ross model are in society's interpretation and misuse of her research and failure to follow-up her study with more research and data (Stages pp).
Aside from the death of a loved one, there are many circumstances that arise during one's lifetime that may result in loss and grief. In the book, "Many Voices," edited by Doreen Mellor and Anna Haebich, is a compassionate and painful product of Australia's history wars (Rowse pp). The editors brought together a logistically and emotionally challenging research program in response to the Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission's 1997 report (Rowse pp). It is also the product of a recently emerged formation within Australian society, an empowered Indigenous middle-class joined with progressive non-Indigenous professionals, dealing with the legacies of colonization strategies known by various terms (Rowse pp). Thousands of Australians experienced sad and angry childhoods and have been left with emotional wounds unhealed (Rowse pp). Embracing assimilation and trained in social science, the authors recalled having witnessed the phasing out of child removals, and that some of these children were neglected and at risk of abuse (Rowse pp). Some officers recall parent's expressions of grief and loss, and no matter whether the removal was short-term or long-term, the pain and suffering caused by the policy was long-term and appears to have been a great burden on the parents and the children (Rowse pp).
Another study by Peter Westoby, published in the May 01, 2003 issue of "Australian Journal of Social Issues," discussed the enormous challenges faced by young people from refugee backgrounds when involved in the settlement process within Australia (Westoby...
Grief Schiz Precautions and Procedures for the Prevention of Suicide and the Treatment of Depression in Recently Diagnosed Schizophrenics Any major chronic medical diagnosis can have psychological and emotional reverberations for the patient, as chronic conditions can often be perceived as a "life sentence" of sorts. The inescapability of symptoms and the long-term prognosis of many chronic disorders can cause patients to seriously question their future quality of life, the impact that
An organized effort, in this case, means knowing who is responsible for what, when the time comes. This prevents chaos in the event of a disaster. Planning for who is responsible for organizing a public memorial is the best way to quickly get the community back on the road to recovery. Another aspect of the community plan needs to address special populations that may have difficulty accessing services. At-risk populations
Figure 1 portrays three of the scenes 20/20 presented March 15, 2010. Figure 1: Heather, Rachel, and Unnamed Girl in 20/20 Program (adapted from Stossel, 2010). Statement of the Problem For any individual, the death of a family member, friend, parent or sibling may often be overwhelming. For adolescents, the death of person close to them may prove much more traumatic as it can disrupt adolescent development. Diana Mahoney (2008), with the
Lament for a Son, Wolterstorff talks about how a Christian worldview can help coping with grief and loss. Wolterstorff's perspective corresponds with Kubler-Ross's five stages of grief, even though the narrative is not formally about those stages. The stages of grief provides a model for the ways human beings process death and loss, not to show that there is a "right" or "good" way of experiencing grief but simply
.....bereavement research has focused primarily on heterosexual, married couples, frequently within the later years of life. The latest research has taken a step towards understanding bereavement among members of the LGBTQ community, particularly, lesbians (Fenge, 2013). By understanding main themes in relation to same-sex bereavement, one can better draw a clear plan of assessment to help someone like Emily deal with the grief of losing a loved one. Some main
26). Two other writers note, "Nurses must be aware that there is no one right way for a patient to respond to dying. Nurses must adapt their care based on patients' current responses and needs and not expect them to always progress through defined stages" (Craven & Hirnle, 2009, p. 1327). Thus, nurses need to be attentive to their dying patients and their moods, and need to take the
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now