Gorgias, Encomium of Helen
In the English language in the twenty-first century, the term "sophistry" still exists to refer to a plausible-sounding but misleading argument, an evaluatively negative term to describe bad reasoning. Although the term derives from the original Sophists in Athens in the 5th century BCE, the modern usage of the term is inaccurate in describing the likes of the Sophist Gorgias. By examining Gorgias' "Encomium of Helen" and the related "dissoi logoi" fragment (sometimes attributed to Protagoras) we can see the real origins of sophistry in legal argumentation. In a society -- like that of Athens, or like most of the contemporary world -- that believes in jury trials as a means of obtaining justice, a work like Gorgias' "Encomium of Helen" represents the idea that even the most unlikely candidates deserve a good defense.
Athenian sophists like Gorgias were basically teachers of rhetoric. Because Plato frequently depicted them as antagonists of Socrates, they are largely remembered negatively. However it is important to understand the Sophists within their historical context. To employ rhetoric skillfully, then as now, was a useful practice -- the chief example I would suggest bearing in mind is that of a trial by jury. We might consider the "dissoi logoi" fragment with this in mind. "Dissoi logoi" literally means, in classical Greek, "different words" or "different reasonings." And the fragment sets up the idea of logical
Williams, however, paraphrases this much more subversively as: "There are two arguments in every question, and both are true" (54). From a Platonic standpoint, this is dangerous, because there can be no such thing as two truths that stand in direct contradiction to each other. But in real-world practice, this makes perfect sense when we consider that opposing sides in a jury trial would each be permitted to make a speech, which would obviously have contradictory goals (either arguing for guilt or innocence).
This brings us to Gorgias' model for sophistic rhetoric in the "Encomium of Helen." It is important to recall that Helen of Troy was a byword for bad behavior in classical Athens. Helen was, of course, the cause of the Trojan War, when she threw over her rather boring husband Menelaus of Sparta for the young and beautiful prince Paris of Troy. Given the genuinely religious role that Homer's epics played in Athenian life, Helen might be understood as occupying a role not unlike that of Eve or Satan in the Book of Genesis: she is the most salient example of seductive bad behavior in the most culturally-central text that the Athenians had. Yet Helen had her defenders as well: the poet Stesichorus had written a standard denunciation of Helen, but then was struck blind by the gods, until he composed a retraction of his denunciation, and the dramatist Euripides offered a largely sympathetic portrayal of a post-Trojan-War Helen in a tragedy named for her. Gorgias' choice of topic, therefore, is not unlike a modern Christian law student being asked to serve literally as "devil's advocate" and compose a…
He uses alliteration and repetition to continue his argument throughout. While doing this his word choice is very intellectual with words containing more than two syllables. He uses this word choice to convey the power of language. He does this because as a Black man, he wants the white world to see different context is possible. In this respect, he establishes his argument by applying a strong tone along
Black Picket Fences Sharlene looked at me with her big, watery brown eyes. "No," she said emphatically, with a definite doleful tone in her voice. "I have never felt like I fit in here." Sharlene, who is 31 years old and has two children, is a black woman that falls into what Mary Patillo-McCoy calls the "black middle class." However, unlike the men, women, and children that Patillo-McCoy interviews for her
African-American Vernacular English can be described as an assortment of American English that is mostly used by urban-working class and mostly bi-dialectical middle-class black Americans. The language is also commonly known as Black Vernacular English or Black English. In some cases, particularly outside the academic community, it is referred to as Ebonics given its distinctive features and similarities with other non-standard English varieties. The similarities with other varieties are evident
Once they arrived, they were brought to a slave market and usually auctioned off to the highest bidder just as cattle and horses were auctioned off. The slaves then spent their lives of servitude helping white farm and plantation owners in their agricultural operations. The slaves weren't typically compensated and lived in deplorable conditions. Slavery helped many white land owners become rich, and the southern colonies, which turned into
Regardless of age, the desire for freedom remained. It is known that older slaves sometimes aided younger slaves to escape. Some of the aged also escaped to freedom. In some instances masters did not pursue older slaves because of their lower economic value. However, this was not always the case, as some older escaped slaves were still valued, and were advertised in the newspapers. Some owners granted their older slaves
A appreciate the fact that this English course also included sections on writing effective narrative papers. I found narrative papers to be fun to write because they involve storytelling and rich descriptive language. I feel more creative writing narrative papers, which is why I prefer writing them, as opposed to research papers. When we write narrative papers, I can draw from personal experience, which makes the writing process easier than
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now