Verified Document

Gore Vidal -- Drugs In Essay

Wouldn't the government need the same amount of money, or perhaps even more, to regulate the new drug system. I can' only imagine the bureaucracy necessary to manage the legal trade of things like heroin, crack cocaine and meth. The other prong of Vidal's argument is that "forbidding people the things the like or think they might enjoy only makes them want those things all the more." He claims that this psychological insight is obvious and yet denied by our government. As evidentiary support, he points to prohibition, but his arguments about prohibition don't directly support his thesis. He argues, correctly, that crime increased because of the prohibition of alcohol, and that the law caused a general contempt for the government, but he does not prove that people wanted to drink more because alcohol was prohibited to them.

The analogy between alcohol and drugs also does not hold up to close scrutiny. Alcohol, although addictive, has always been consumed legally by human beings for centuries, only to be abruptly prohibited by the 18th Amendment. Yes, people broke laws to get alcohol, but this is not evidence that there were more drinkers than before or after prohibition, only that these drinkers were breaking the law. They were trying to obtain something that had been legal to them and part of their culture, the national culture, before being abruptly taken away from them. Vidal cites no statistics on an increase in alcoholism resulting from the prohibition -- perhaps because the evidence just doesn't exist.

Vidal also insists that if there were no money in the drug trade for the Mafia to profit from, there would be no playground pushers and addicts would not commit crimes to get their fixes. First, this supposed that all drug addicts would...

The rise in black market cigarettes recently in response to high government taxes serves as evidence that a legal supply does not prohibit illegal trafficking (Caruso). There would also exist an illegal market for underage users, as there does now for alcohol. Everyone who participates in such transactions is committing a crime, so not all crime would be eliminated by legalization. There would still be illegal uses and users and criminals to provide the product for them. Thus, not only would the government have to absorb the cost burden of setting up the necessary regulatory agencies, they would also have to keep law enforcement in place to catch the abusers of the system.
It may be the 40 years that have passed since Vidal wrote his article and now, but he seems to be ignorant about the nature of addiction as a disease. He equates a restrictive drug policy to moralism that has no practical value.

At its core, Vidal's argument is based on a libertarian ideal of a small government which does not get in the way of individual freedom. Vidal goes all the way back to the founding fathers, recalling that their idea of freedom was that "each man has the right to do what he wants with his own life as long as he does not interfere with his neighbor's pursuit of happiness." He admits that things get confused when not everyone has the best intentions toward each other, but he doesn't include anything about drug use in the possibly negative category. Vidal's arguments miss the mark and are not convincing because they are not set on a firm foundation but rather a twisted idea of utopia, where everyone behaves as they should and people are able to overcome anything with willpower. If only it were so, Mr. Vidal, I may support your policy.

Works Cited

Caruso, David B. "Higher Cigarette Taxes Lure Buyers to Black Market." The Huffington Post. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/04/10/higher-cigarette-taxes-lu_n_96094.html April 10, 2008

"Number of Adult Smokers." Smoking from All Sides. http://smokingsides.com/docs/us_adults_bystate95. November 8, 1996

"Richard M. Nixon." United States History. http://www.u-s-history.com/pages/h1948.html.

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Caruso, David B. "Higher Cigarette Taxes Lure Buyers to Black Market." The Huffington Post. http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/04/10/higher-cigarette-taxes-lu_n_96094.html April 10, 2008

"Number of Adult Smokers." Smoking from All Sides. http://smokingsides.com/docs/us_adults_bystate95. November 8, 1996

"Richard M. Nixon." United States History. http://www.u-s-history.com/pages/h1948.html.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Crack Cocaine As One of
Words: 1127 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

In some ways, the prevalence of crime related to selling and using crack cocaine may be due to the effects which the user experiences. For instance, heavy users become alienated from their friends and families and tend to be isolated and suspicious of everything and everyone, a form of drug-induced paranoia. Most of their time is spent thinking about ways to obtain more and more of the drug which may

Crack Cocaine Vs. Powder Cocaine
Words: 896 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Henderson notes that "minimal violence is involved with crack cocaine cases -- far less than half of the crack cocaine cases involved a weapon, while most actual violence is associated with the drug trade and not the drug itself." With this knowledge that there is no scientific difference in the dangerousness of the two drugs and that violence is not necessarily associated more with crack cocaine, it becomes clear

Crack Cocaine and Its Impact on Miami Gardens
Words: 715 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Drug Related Issues in Miami Gardens Miami Gardens is a location where there are large numbers of minorities and immigrants. This is the location just north of Miami and it composes of a number of different neighborhoods. The most notable include: Andover, Bunche Park, Carol City, Lake Lucerne, Norwood, Opa Locka North and Scott Lake. In general, the community is facing drug related challenges from its close proximity to Central and

Sentencing Disparities Between Crack Cocaine
Words: 8900 Length: 32 Document Type: Term Paper

The judge must choose a sentence from within the guideline range unless the court identifies an aggravating or mitigating circumstance that was not adequately considered by the Sentencing Commission. In mandatory minimum drug cases, judges can depart only upon motion from the government stating that a defendant has provided substantial assistance in the investigation or prosecution of another person. All guideline drug sentences are indirectly affected by the mandatory minimums.

Crack Capturing the Audience's Attention
Words: 673 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

A. Supporting details (Give citation) Crack is a powerful central nervous system stimulant that can increase risk for cardiovascular incidents, strokes, and other deadly effects (National Institute on Drug Abuse 2009). B. Supporting details (Give citation) Addicts may even use crack cocaine while pregnant, severely harming their children. "Fetal cocaine effects include premature separation of the placenta, spontaneous abortion, premature labor, low birthweight and head circumference at birth, greater chance of visual impairment,

Cocaine and Crack: Proletariat Hunger
Words: 1433 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

There is no valuable sustenance in crack or cocaine, and is used mainly as a recreational drug by many. This, in some ways, leaves the inner cities and crime and moves to the wealthier middle and upper middle classes who use the cocaine and not the crack version for recreation. This is the society of Jay McInerney's seminal 1980s fictional tale of New York 20-something lives, "Bright Lights, Big

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now