¶ … Glass Menagerie
The world of 1930s America was certainly quite different from the one we have today. For this reason, it is important to study the relationship of Laura and Amanda with this disturbing industrialized society in mind. In those days, single parenthood was not as common as it is today and thus we can imagine the problems women went through when they were abandoned by their husbands. If Amanda appears to be highly neurotic and rather too possessive of her children, then blame must be put not on her but on the times in which she lived.
1930s was the time when America was undergoing severe economic depression and the world had increasingly become too industrialized and materialized for simple people to breathe easily. This materialization was not only regarding money but also applied to everything from beauty to values to a person's worth. We notice that in the case of Laura, she becomes a victim of this materialization when she notices that most people are either interested in beauty or money. None could truly harbor romantic feelings for a gentle quite girl, who was slightly crippled.
Laura and Amanda often appear like two vague figures that are nothing more than figments of Tom's imagination. In the beginning of the play, Tom makes it clear that he is narrating his story from the 1930s so there is no way we can prove the existence of these two female figures. But even if they existed, it appears that their characters adopted completely different attitudes and behavior in order to occupy an important place in the play.
While Laura is a soft-spoken gentle person who wants to be loved and respected, Amanda demands the same thing ferociously. This is the major difference between heir characters. It is the differences in their characters and not the similarities, which define their relationship which is rather disturbing and somewhat bizarre.
Laura signifies everything gentle and beautiful while Amanda symbolizes extreme possessiveness, which borders on neediness. It is this neediness of her character, which makes her adopt rather unpleasant attitude towards Laura even though she wants the very best for her. She urges Laura to be more like herself, believing she is this perfect South belle who is highly resourceful and confident. This is what disturbs Laura as she starts comparing herself with others and thus into a very meek and timid figure. Laura doesn't have any self-respect and this is due to her disturbing relationship with her mother who herself is a victim of her times and distorted psyche.
We need to understand that Laura and Amanda may be figments of Tom's imagination but their characters have been developed so well that they almost command the central place in his consciousness. While Tom's own thoughts and behavior does play dominate roles in this story, it is the relationship of his mother with her children, which is the most interesting feature of the plot.
The most important thing that emerges from the study of Laura's relationship with her mother is the way the latter influences the former's personality and her sense of self-wroth. While she wants Laura to turn into a pushy confident young woman, her approach is flawed which has a negative impact on her daughter. For example, instead of teaching her the right skills to become a confident person, she points out her flaws and problems, which make Laura, feel worthless.
This is evident from the conversation between Jim and Laura where latter confesses her lack of confidence in herself to which Jim replies, "You don't have the proper amount of faith in yourself.... Think of yourself as superior in some way!
Why, man alive, Laura! Just look about you a little. What do you see? A world full of common people! All of 'em born and all of 'em going to die! Which of them has one-tenth of your good points! (99) "......
In connection with Williams' feelings vis-a-vis his sister's lobotomy, Jack Tamburri, writing in www.courttheatre.orgbelieves that the narrator in the Glass Menagerie (e.g., Williams) "...Spins a story of regret and abandonment [regarding Laura] that must have mirrored the guilt Williams felt over his own sister's situation." CONCLUSION: The helplessness of Laura as she tries to get through the pain of her physical disability, her shyness, and the razor-sharp barbs thrown at her
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now