Verified Document

Future Research Agenda That Judge, Et Al. Essay

¶ … future research agenda that Judge, et al. (2008) present addresses their critique of personality research in organizational behavior. According to Judge, Klinger, Simon and Yang (2008), the various criticisms directed at early organizational behavioral theories have been countered by a growing body of evidence that supports these fundamental precepts. In this regard Judge et al. report that there have been three main pieces of evidence to date that have been particularly influential:

The growth of meta-analysis allowed for cumulation of results across studies. This development was particularly important in the area of personality, given the myriad traits that had been considered over decades of scientific research.

The widespread acceptance of the five-factor model (or the 'Big Five' -- Extraversion, Conscientiousness, Agreeableness, Neuroticism, and Openness to Experience) of personality provided a framework to organize the diverse set of traits. While the gains from the five-factor model have been considerable, its acceptance in organizational behavior is so widespread that it threatens to 'white out' other potentially relevant traits.

3. There was an accumulating body of evidence in personality psychology that supported the enduring nature of personality traits, their genetic origins, and their neuropsychological basis (Judge et al., 2008, p. 1983).

Despite the criticisms leveled at the use of personality traits for human resource research and planning, the research to date supports this practice because personality has consistently been shown to be relevant to individual attitudes and behavior as well as team and organizational functioning (Judge et al., 2008). An excerpt from their literature review makes this clear: "Personality traits do matter at work, and indeed, the data appear to support [this] conclusion" (p. 1983). Notwithstanding this growing body of evidence, though, Judge et al. also note that not everyone is convinced of the efficacy of personality research for organizational behavior applications....

In this regard, Judge and his associates emphasize that, "Perhaps the most intensive application of personality research in organizational settings, and arguably the most controversial, has been in relation to job performance. One reason for this interest -- and controversy -- concerns the role of personality testing in hiring decisions" (p. 1983).
Because the decisions that are based on personality traits affect people's lives, it is vitally important for them to be legitimate and evidence based, but this is not currently the case. In this regard, Judge and his colleagues note that, "The acceptance of personality traits as important predictors of employment outcomes is far from universal" (p. 1983). Personality traits, though, are not the only factors involved in employee performance. Indeed, work motivation, job attitudes, and the type and quality of leadership have all been shown to play critical roles in shaping employee morale and organizational performance (Judge et al., 2008).

As noted above, though, the research to date remains controversial in spite of the growing consensus concerning its legitimacy. In this regard, Judge et al. report that, "Though there is general acceptance that personality predicts most broad organizational attitudes and behaviors, not all scholars are convinced of the usefulness of personality measures in organizational research" (p. 1990). Among the criticisms that have most often been directed at personality traits include:

1. The validities are sufficiently weak as to question the usefulness of personality measures in predicting organizational criteria, particularly job performance; and,

2. Because items on self-report personality measures are socially desirable (i.e., the 'right' response is transparent), faking undermines the usefulness of personality measures (Judge et al., p. 1990)

There are also some gaps in the existing body of knowledge concerning the influences of so-called "dark-side" traits that may contribute to higher performance levels compared to more seemingly desirable…

Sources used in this document:
References

Chen, J-K & Chen, I-S. (2008, Fall). How can institutes of technology change successfully? A

discussion from a human resources perspective. Business Renaissance Quarterly, 3, 85-

88.

Judge, T.A., Klinger, R., Simon, L.S., & Yang, I.W.F. (2008). The contributions of personality to organizational behavior and psychology: Findings, criticisms, and future research directions. Social and Personality Psychology Compass, 2, 1982-2000.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Nursing Research
Words: 3631 Length: 10 Document Type: Essay

Nursing Research and Evidence-Based Practice I requesting username BOLAVENS work. If, . These questions related NURSING RESEARCH AND EVIDENCE-BASED PRACTICE. refer book titled Nursing Research: Generating assessing evidence nursing, IBM# 9781605477084 answers. Discuss the differences between research, research utilization, and evidence-based practice. you may want to link this to the historical evolution of research in nursing. Research refers to the systematic process of searching and generating knowledge about a particular topic in order

Machine Translation, and the Future Computers Are
Words: 7864 Length: 24 Document Type: Dissertation

Machine Translation, And the Future Computers are being used in many areas to speed and automate tasks that are tedious or strenuous on human beings. Computers aid us in making our daily lives better in many ways. Computers are being used for a variety of tasks. As the world moves toward a global economy, communication has become a major issue of the agendas of almost any industrialized nation. Machine translation is

Biology As a Cross-Interdisciplinary Study
Words: 1621 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

There are many different types of website that talk about biology; some of them include university websites which allows access to differing portals of biological information. Such websites as University of Michigan's "biology resource network" is an important source of information for all access to biology articles and databases from U. Of Michigan scholars and professors. Other websites include organization websites such as those of the American Society of

Predominantly Latino Gangs, Mara Salvatrucha
Words: 17380 Length: 40 Document Type: Thesis

Government Since gang-related crimes fall within the jurisdiction of state, this research will give an insight on the need to find solutions that increasingly include all levels of government. Congress needs to pass legislation that will change immigration enforcement laws and make more aliens deportable. In addition, the federal government should take a more active participation in helping local and state jurisdictions develop anti-gang responses. The local, state and federal governments

Australia's Domestic and Foreign Policy
Words: 4433 Length: 15 Document Type: Thesis

S. President George W. Bush. Thus, when the blast in Bali, at the southern point of Indonesia, directed the fury of 9/11 at a popular attraction to Australian holiday-makers, Australia became a nation motivated in foreign policy by the apparent threat of global terrorism. This would be demonstrated by its unwavering willingness to follow the United States even into its poorly-informed and ill-advised invasion of Iraq, providing combat troops and civilian military aid. During the lead- up

Impact of School Culture on School Safety
Words: 33592 Length: 122 Document Type: Term Paper

School Culture on School Safety Many studies have been done on safety in schools. Likewise, many studies have been done on the culture of various schools. Unfortunately, there has not been significant research on a link between the two. This is not to say that these kinds of studies have not been done, but rather that there has not been enough of them. Many of the studies that have been

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now