Verified Document

Future Lie In China Or America The Essay

Related Topics:

¶ … future lie in China or America? The series of essays pertaining to the winning essays in the Ging Hawk Club Essay Contest in 1936 illustrate different arguments and perspectives regarding the question, "Does my future lie in China or America?" The winners, Robert Dunn from Harvard University (winning essay) and Kaye Hong from University of Washington (second place), portrayed different perspectives regarding the issue. To add further debate not only on the choice of winners, but on the discussion of the issue within each winning essay, reactions from the Chinese Students' Club in Stanford University and Jane Kwong Lee provided more in-depth analysis of the issue being discussed. The texts that follow are vital points debated in these sets of essays answering and contemplating the vital question, "Does my future lie in China or America?"

Dunn's stance on the issue is, "I choose a course of life whose future lies here in America."

In arguing his position, Dunn looks into the economics, politics, and culture of both countries. Meanwhile, Hong, in contemplating the said issue, provides a qualitative approach in gauging his judgment on whether to live out his life and career in China or America. Hong's "Go Further West, Young Man" motto illustrates his belief in nationalist belief inculcated in him by his environment, despite living in the Westernized American society.

Because Dunn chose a stance that deviates from the general sentiment among Chinese-Americans (second generation Chinese), his essay elicited reactions from his fellow Chinese-Americans, as shown in the letters of the Chinese Students' Club (CSC) and Jane Kwong Lee. While Lee gives merit to both Dunn and Hong's essays, primarily because of the diversity it offered in discussing the issue of Chinese-American patriotism to either China or America, CSC...

For the organization, Dunn's essay illustrates the shallowness of thinking of American-born Chinese who does not have enough knowledge about the realities happening in their native country, China.
Analyses of the Dunn, Hong, CSC, and Lee's essays reflect how even among the Chinese-American sector, there are different opinions and thoughts about the issue. As explained in the essay, it is true that the question posed by the Ging Hawk Club's essay contest is a loaded one, a question that is answered pragmatically rather than philosophically. Dunn's essay is prime example of this perspective, taking into consideration first the economic benefits/rewards that he will get once he settles down in China. Answering the question pragmatically is but the most effective way in which this value-laden question can be answered. This is illustrated in Dunn's contention that, more than expression of patriotism, one must also consider the individual's willingness to serve, employment opportunities, and more importantly, the kind of culture of a country in order to ascertain whether s/he is indeed suitable to live in that country or not.

The author cites how politics and personalistic ties pervades employment opportunities in Chinese society, where one needs to have the right 'connections' with the government or company in order to secure a job that is sometimes far below what the individual is trained or skilled for. Thus, job discrimination among the Chinese is not only rampant in America, but also in their native country China: "It is evident, then, that employment is hard to get anywhere; in America, perhaps, because of the color line; in China because jobs are scarce." Dunn makes it clear that economically, both countries pose certain disadvantages to the Chinese-American…

Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

America's National Pastime- The Evolution and Impact of Baseball
Words: 2083 Length: 7 Document Type: Essay

The history of baseball, widely recognized as America's national pastime, is a rich tapestry woven with legends, lore, and the cultural evolution of the sport over time. Although the exact origins of baseball are difficult to pinpoint, it is clear that the game developed from older bat-and-ball games such as cricket and rounders, which were played in England and brought over to North America by settlers (Thorn, 2011). The earliest known

What Is China's Role in Globalization Why Is It Significant
Words: 7994 Length: 25 Document Type: Research Paper

AFRICA'S PETROLEUM AND CHINA'S ECONOMIC GROWTH AND DEVELOPMENT How Africa's Petroleum Supply Is Important to China's Economic Growth and Development While China continues to grow, its oil demand is poised to grow rapidly. For China to ensure its oil security, it must obtain oil from the global world because it lacks adequate domestic resources to quench the thirsty appetite of the country's rapid economic development. Any approach for growth that the country

Ford Moving to China for
Words: 955 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

S.. Over a period of time, even the manufacturers, like Ford, move their manufacturing bases to China. (Chain Reaction: Big Three's Outsourcing Plan: Make Parts Suppliers Do it) manufacturing company that is giving employment to a large population of a town closes its operations and shifts its operations to elsewhere; this leads to loss of jobs. The entire town gets affected. As the public are not earning, they cannot buy

Challenging the Beijing Consensus China Foreign Policy in the 21st...
Words: 24240 Length: 60 Document Type: Dissertation or Thesis complete

Foreign Policy of China (Beijing consensus) Structure of Chinese Foreign Policy The "Chinese Model" of Investment The "Beijing Consensus" as a Competing Framework Operational Views The U.S.-China (Beijing consensus) Trade Agreement and Beijing Consensus Trading with the Enemy Act Export Control Act. Mutual Defense Assistance Control Act Category B Category C The 1974 Trade Act. The Operational Consequences of Chinese Foreign Policy The World Views and China (Beijing consensus) Expatriates The Managerial Practices Self Sufficiency of China (Beijing consensus) China and western world: A comparison The China (Beijing

Future of the WTO
Words: 1755 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Gonzales (2017) notes that emerging nations are calling for the WTO to support inclusive globalization: “The Philippines, together with the Friends of MSMEs, is seeking appropriate arrangements within the existing framework of the WTO and relevant committees, such as the establishment of a working group under the General Council that will be mandated to consider how the multilateral trading system can impact and benefit MSMEs [micro, small and medium enterprises],

Economy of China
Words: 2343 Length: 6 Document Type: Term Paper

Economy of china is one of the largest economies in the world after the United States of America. Over the years it has been regarded as the fastest growing economy in the world registering the highest number of exports and imports. This has been attributed to high population that the economy has to support. As a result, the economy has improved which has been reflected in terms of the infrastructure

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now