Aristotle's Friendships
Elena Irrera interprets Aristotle's Nichomachean Ethics on friendship as having three distinct, but possibly overlapping purposes. In addition to friendships based on love, there are also friendships based on "ethical excellence" and "utility" (p. 7). Friendships based on love can be rooted in a mutual sense of understanding and trust, and are typically rooted in a long history of companionship. Friendships based on ethical excellence are more difficult to explain, but nonetheless easily recognized by most people as a mutual attraction based on similar values and ethics. 'Ethical excellence' friendships contrast with utilitarian friendships, because the former deals with the good of the individual and the latter deals with the good of the polis or political community (Zunjic). However, to understand the meaning of a Aristotelian friendship based on utility, the philosophical foundation upon which Aristotle's concept of polis must be understood.
Aristotle's view of morality was based on the concept of a political community consisting of individuals having a common goal; a striving towards a "supreme good" in the moral sense (Zunjic). In American society, this goal could reasonably assumed to be the fulfillment of individual, familial, social, and financial goals, but Aristotle would argue that these goals could not be achieved unless most, if not all, of society agrees on the same goals. Individual fulfillment and happiness therefore depends on a communal recognition of an overarching or "ultimate good" that everyone is seeking in their own way. In other words, for Americans to achieve happiness and fulfillment they must become organized around the pursuit of the same ultimate goal of individual actualization, otherwise they will struggle in futility.
This philosophy seems to contrast with American values such as individual achievement; however, if the vast majority of people in American society agree that this goal represents the ultimate good, then according to Aristotle, state institutions, such as financial, legal, education, and defense, should be organized in a manner that fosters the attainment of this ultimate good (Zunjic).
In light of Aristotle's definition of a political community, the only type of friendship that would be considered controversial from a moral and ethical perspective is the one based on utility. While the existence of such friendships is widely recognized to exist throughout society, many would likely argue that they are not inherently 'good' in the moral sense. Irrera draws a hard line between political friendships (utilitarian), which often exhibit many of the traits commonly associated with more traditional friendships, but often lack a long-term association (p. 3-4). From Irrera's perspective, a shared sense of justice acts as a surrogate for love in political friendships, but does not guarantee that such associations contribute to the attainment of an ultimate good.
This common sense of justice, according to Aristotle, is what ties a political community…
In addition to the diplomatic relationships established between the Greek poleis, in the frame of the political arena, there were also the alliances made between persons, usually high raking members of the ruling classes: "there was a fine-meshed network of personal relationships between prominent persons in the different cities based on 'guest friendship' (xenia): two friends (xenoi) from different poleis could promise to house and help each other when
For Aristotle, true freedom and liberty consists in ruling and being ruled in turn and not always insisting on fulfilling one's own personal desires at the cost of others. Thus, for Odysseus, true freedom can only come about when one is allowed to contribute to society for the betterment of everyone involved, a sure sign of moral correctness and rational thinking. In addition, Aristotle stressed the importance of justice and goodness,
Plato Given that Plato's Socrates is an Idealist and a dualist, the highest form of love is not the sexual or erotic kind, or that of family and friends, all of which are materialistic and impermanent. On the contrary, the highest form of love is for God (the Good), as expressed through the immortal soul, for God is a perfect and ideal Form and the soul longs for union with the
Identifying Opportunities to Reduce Income Disparities in South Africa Today and In the FutureDespite the end of apartheid in the early 1990s, South Africa remains racially and economically segregated. The country is beset by persistent social inequality, poverty, unemployment, a heavy burden of disease and the inequitable quality of healthcare service provision. -- Katusha de Villiers (2021)In 2019, the World Bank recognized South Africa as the most unequal country in
Politeia In the Politics, and the Constitution of Athens (Politeia), Aristotle lays out a number of ideas. In this short essay, the author will attempt to answer the question of whether or not man is a political animal." Further, if this is the cause, we will explore whether or not Aristotle's politics allow man enough room to live up to this nature. It is this author's contention that Aristotle answers that
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now