Verified Document

French Revolution: Taking A Macro Book Review

Aston begins his book by discussing the special, privileged role of the First Estate, as well as different theological debates raging at the time, such as the Jansenism controversy. He also gives attention to other faiths, including Protestantism and Judaism, which were present in France at the time. Protestants and Jews were some of the Revolution's earliest recipients of additional rights in the new, secular, equal society.[footnoteRef:4] [4: Nigel Aston, Religion and Revolution in France, 1780-1804, (Washington, D.C: Catholic University of America Press, 2000), 244.] Another important influence was what Aston calls a lack of 'enlightened piety,' or the persistence of a mixture of folk traditions and populist Catholicism despised by intellectuals, but professed in practice by members of the working classes. Although France would come to seem like the paradigmatic example of Enlightenment revolution (or non-religion) during the later phases of the Revolution, during the pre-Revolutionary period, the community ties of religion held the population fast. Intellectuals would come to see this as problematic later on, just as members of the official clergy preached against it. However, this is evidence that religion was a source of continual friction regarding the attitude of the state towards religion and often formed a way for the lower classes to articulate resistance. [footnoteRef:5] it was not always a mechanism of instilling state order and imposing ideas upon the populace, and the people had control over how they interpreted and articulated religion. [5: Aston, 55 ]

Despite the eventual, official atheism or quasi-paganism of the later revolutionaries, during the early phases the majority of the French public, even the revolutionary-minded French public was religious and supported the ideals of the faiths they professed. From Aston's specific analysis of the phenomenon of religiosity in France, it is possible to draw a conclusion about his view of the inevitability of the Revolution: unlike Doyle, Aston does believe the Revolution was inevitable. Tensions...

However, while Aston may be more inclined to portray the Revolution with an inevitability lacking in Doyle's account, he does not believe that the culture clash between faith and revolutionary principles was inevitable. It only came when gradually, the tone amongst the revolutionaries in the Assembly turned bitterly against the clergy. Eventually, "the Assembly voted for the complete dispossession of the clergy, and turned its face against some powerfully argued last-minute speeches by those advocating leaving the First Estate with some property."[footnoteRef:6] [6: Aston, 138]
Rather than seeing this as commensurate with revolutionary ideals, Aston believes that the radicals fail to consider the real, important role many sympathetic clergy had taken during the revolution. During the 1790s, in reaction to the anti-religious rhetoric, there was a resurgence of religious fervor, and Aston makes it clear that people did not see their faith as inherently in conflict with the Revolution. They said: "We wish to be Catholics and republicans and can be both one and the other."[footnoteRef:7] in other words, the populace did not see itself as 'oppressed' by religion, but nor did it necessarily wish that things had remained the same, so they could hold on to their old faith structures as they existed during the Ancient Regime. This envisioning of alternative possibilities, suggests Aston, means that the trajectory of the Revolution was far from expected. With this personal testimony specific to religion, Aston thus echoes Doyle's more critically-focused and broader historical analysis that the Revolution did not have to take the extreme and bloody course that it did to enact change. [7: Aston, 284]

Bibliography

Aston, Nigel. Religion and Revolution in France, 1780-1804. Washington, D.C: Catholic

University of America Press, 2000

Doyle, William. Origins of the French Revolution. New York: Oxford…

Sources used in this document:
Bibliography

Aston, Nigel. Religion and Revolution in France, 1780-1804. Washington, D.C: Catholic

University of America Press, 2000

Doyle, William. Origins of the French Revolution. New York: Oxford University Press:
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Macro Vision of Jefferson Vs.
Words: 2374 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

Hamilton's Arguments in Favor of the Debt and the Bank Jefferson would have no position against witch to argue had not Hamilton made the argument for the national debt so eloquently and so forcefully. Essentially, Hamilton and Jefferson entirely disagreed on the proper course to put the nation on a prosperous track. The greatest issue was whether the multitudinous colonial debts piled up by the individual colonies during and since the

Francoise Roy's Diversity Management Plan Pbq Panaccio
Words: 1441 Length: 5 Document Type: Case Study

Francoise Roy's Diversity Management Plan PBQ (Panaccio & Waxin case study) applying conceptual framework Shen, Chanda, D'Netto, Monga (2009) related readings. Human resource management case 3 -- Diversity management plan The current HRM context The status of the personnel has evolved dramatically throughout the past recent century. The bases of the modern day labor force were set in the commencement of the Industrial Revolution, when the people moved from villages to towns

Discovery of the "New World"
Words: 2822 Length: 9 Document Type: Term Paper

As a result, the majority of European business companies that handled the large number of fur trades were English. The largest of such firms was the Hudson's Bay Company established in 1670 (Belden, 82). This institution was the center of North American fur trading for more than two hundred years. It was founded by two French fur traders English merchant. The English government granted the company sole trading rights

Market Driven Management
Words: 25695 Length: 75 Document Type: Term Paper

Pharmaceutical industries have to operate in an environment that is highly competitive and subject to a wide variety of internal and external constraints. In recent times, there has been an increasing trend to reduce the cost of operation while competing with other companies that manufacture products that treat similar afflictions and ailments. The complexities in drug research and development and regulations have created an industry that is subject to intense

Marketing and Economics Agricultural
Words: 18779 Length: 68 Document Type: Term Paper

Origins, History of the IMF The International Monetary Fund was first conceived between July 1-22, 1944, at the United Nations Monetary and Financial Conference in Bretton Woods, New Hampshire. The conference was attended by representatives of 45 nations, which were called together in order to plan and lay the groundwork for a cooperative economic framework to solve global financial crises before they occur. One key reason for the conference was to

Soft Systems Techniques in the Preparation of
Words: 20187 Length: 73 Document Type: Dissertation

Soft Systems Techniques in the Preparation of Information Technology as a Systems Manager Company Systems Consulting process and model Systems approach, client relationships Company Culture Client defenses, attachments to existing systems Interaction with the company culture in order to facilitate change System and Culture working together Dependancy issues Lewin Company Systems Consulting process and model Systems approach, client relationships Company Culture Client defenses, attachments to existing systems Interaction with the company culture in order to facilitate change System and Culture working together Dependency issues Lewin's model of

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now