Verified Document

Frank Stella Versus Dana Schutz S Aesthetics Of Design Essay

Related Topics:

Coolness vs. Passion: Frank Stella's Abstract Designs and Dana Schutz's Narrative Frenzy of Color

Frank Stella's massive 1967 painting entitled Haran II takes the form of a geometric design that seems deceptively simple at first but becomes more and more complex as the viewer gazes upon it. The work is a series of rectangles and half-circles fused together with bright rainbows of colors embedded within them. The painting is childish in its brightness. The color palette strikes the modern viewer as very much of the 1960s and 70s with its garish orange and blue shades counterpoised against brown and red earth tones. Dana Schutz's 2015 Fight in an Elevator is similarly arresting in its brightness but in contrast to Stella's use of abstraction, Schutz's Cubist-Futurist approach has a narrative sense of form. The work depicts a swirl of fists and legs. A brown-skinned woman in high heels fights with a man in a baggy white suit but their faces are not evident, merely the conflict in which they are engaged. Stella's work is flat and deliberately one-dimensional while Schutz's is highly layered, with a busy visual field to suggest the two protagonists' angry, conflicted motions.

Frank Stella has been credited with revolutionizing Abstract Expressionism by introducing a radical new aesthetic. In 1959 his series of "coolly impersonal black striped paintings" were said to lack the "gestural brushwork and existential angst" of Jackson Pollock's works and other Abstract Expressionists.[footnoteRef:1] They were immediately well-received by critics of the era and set the tone of Stella's later works which focused on the use of color and dimension. Stella rejected the notion that art was an expression of the inner life of the artist and instead advanced the idea that paintings should be solely about form itself. He was a pioneer of nonrepresentational painting and resisted any attempts to ascribe "underlying meanings, emotions, or narratives" to his work and stated they were simply about the principles of "line, plane, volume, and point, within space" and "color, shape, and composition."[footnoteRef:2] [1: "Frank Stella," The Art Story, accessed December 16, 2015, http://www.theartstory.org/artist-stella-frank.htm] [2: Ibid.]

Dana Schutz, in contrast, gained immediate attention as an artist because of her merging of emotion and geometry in what has been called a Cubist-Futurist style. Her works are very explicitly narrative (although...

Schutz has said: "My paintings are loosely based on metanarratives. The pictures float in and out of pictorial genres. Still lifes become personified, portraits become events and landscapes become constructions."[footnoteRef:3] Schutz is interested in how humans can resemble objects and vice versa. "I embrace the area between which the subject is composed and decomposing, formed and formless, inanimate and alive."[footnoteRef:4] [3: "Dana Schutz and the Saatchi Gallery," Saatchi Gallery, 2004, accessed December 16, 2015, http://www.saatchigallery.com/artists/dana_schutz.htm] [4: Ibid.]
Schutz's rise in the art world has been described as meteoric in nature. "She shot to overnight fame in 2002. Her first solo show ... [was] of different-size canvases of high-keyed, unfixed color, depicting collapsing scenes of noses exploding, faces fracturing, figures in combat."[footnoteRef:5] Schutz was notable for having paintings with clear yet unsettling narratives that were identifiably human yet distorted and discursive in the stories they told. According to the curator of the Montreal's Musee d'Art Contemporain, where Schutz's work was recently displayed: "One of the great qualities of Dana's work is the caustic wit. It's this perfect sort of collision between hilarity and the grotesque."[footnoteRef:6] [5: Jerry Saltz, "Why have there been no women bad boy artists," Vulture, accessed December 16, 2015, http://www.vulture.com/2015/09/maddening-fate-of-the-bad-boy-female-artist.html#] [6: Julia Felsenthal, "Artsplainer: Dana Schutz's work in New York and Montreal," Vogue, October 19, 2015, accessed December 16, 2015, http://www.vogue.com/13362181/dana-schutz-artsplainer/]

Harran II is considered significant because it marked a departure from Stella's earlier, smaller, monochromatic compositions. It is one of Stella's Protractor sequence, based upon "the semicircular drafting instrument used for measuring and constructing angles."[footnoteRef:7] The paintings take their names from ancient cities located in Asia Minor and "a Roman numeral following the title indicates which of three design groups -- 'interlaces,' 'rainbows,' or 'fans' -- encompasses its surface patterning," versus any sequential order.[footnoteRef:8] Harran II is specifically "composed of a full circle formed of two vertical protractors, each of which interlocks…

Sources used in this document:
Bibliography

Chin, Mei. "Dana Schutz." Bomb, 95 (Spring 2006). Accessed December 17, 2015.

http://bombmagazine.org/article/2799/dana-schutz

"Dana Schutz and the Saatchi Gallery." Saatchi Gallery. 2004. Accessed December 16, 2015.

http://www.saatchigallery.com/artists/dana_schutz.htm
October 19, 2015. Accessed December 16, 2015. http://www.vogue.com/13362181/dana-schutz-artsplainer/
http://www.theartstory.org/artist-stella-frank.htm
http://www.guggenheim.org/new-york/collections/collection-online/artwork/4003
2015 at http://www.vulture.com/2015/09/maddening-fate-of-the-bad-boy-female-artist.html#
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Aesthetics of Change by Bradford
Words: 617 Length: 2 Document Type: Book Review

According to Kenney, it is the responsibility of clinicians to use their sensory processes to determine how these communications are articulated and to then to reflect them back to the communication system that is experiencing difficulties. This recursive mirroring process is described by Kenney as being "sociofeedback" that people can use to help readjust their relationships with their environment. In sum, the author maintains that it is the clinician's mirroring

Aesthetics and Contemporary Product Design
Words: 2194 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Now, turn to Arizona Green Tea with Ginseng. The packaging for the single serving uses the label that is mint green with an oriental flavor, suggesting the benefits of Zen and the addition of ginseng and honey. Now contrast that with the Family One Gallon size, in a clear plastic, industrial container that looks more like detergent or motor oil than a delicious health beverage. Are the products identical --

Aesthetics Norms of Beauty and
Words: 2508 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

..]. Furthermore, studies indicate that between 60 and 80% of college women engage in regular binge eating and other abnormal behaviours that fall short of the criteria set by clinical scales. Many college women who are at normal weights continue to express a strong desire to be thinner and to hold beliefs about food and body image that are similar to those of women who have actual eating disorders" (Hesse-Biber

Medicis Aesthetics SWOT Analysis and
Words: 719 Length: 3 Document Type: SWOT

Threats Luckily, Medicis Aesthetics' capital position as a subsidiary of Medicis Pharmaceutical Corporation also enables it to better weather external threats to the company, which certainly exists for the industry as a whole. Threats of litigation are a very real factor of how this industry does business, especially with certain product lines. In addition, the industry is now facing the threat of a prolonged recession, which many analysts claim we are

Hanna Segal's Psychoanalytic Approach to Aesthetics
Words: 5573 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

psychoanalytic as portrayed by H. Segal. It has sources. Psychoanalytic approach to aesthetics can best be understood by understanding the theory/ies that guide us on the study of this particularly complex discipline. The theory and guidelines of psychoanalytic approach enable us to offer some insight into the worlds of literature, art and music, and on the other hand, it also allows us to better understand artists' perception and inner approaches

Analyzing the African Aesthetics
Words: 1591 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

African Aesthetics Artefacts from Africa exhibit their cultural context. Indeed, there is value in emphasizing formal aesthetics of objects and their expression of the religious and moral values (Ray, 1993) There is a moral basis in African aesthetics. One term that epitomises such truth is that in many African languages, there is a common usage of the same word that means good and beautiful. This is in line with the meaning of

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now