Verified Document

Frame Analysis It Should Come Term Paper

Another significant similarity between frame and discourse analyses is that they both generally use qualitative methods of data reduction and presentation. This is in comparison to quantitative analysis, which is more objective and generally presents group rather than individual data. This can make it difficult to apply what it learned to a broader group of people, because they are looking at specific information for different people. This does not mean it is impossible. In both frame and discourse analysis, researchers often take a two-step approach. The first step is to help define the theory, and the second step is to examine text in order to code it and see how it applies.

In addition, both discourse and frame analyses are actually well-suited to study through focus groups and other types of group research. Social movement research can be helped by the use of focus groups because the groups, like the underlying texts, not only reflect the underlying values in a social movement, but also demonstrate the ways that different groups might communicate with one another, helping explain and define a social movement. Convening focus groups helps explore social construction processes in a proactive way, which can blur the line between research and activism, a common "problem" in both discourse and frame analysis. Rarely do researchers from either perspective merely report findings; they are generally invested in the findings and believe them to be a source of encouragement for some type of social change. Focus groups permit insight into thought process, by encouraging people to reveal the thoughts behind beliefs and words without the pressure of a one-on-one interview scenario. However, much like the general society, discussion in focus groups can be dominated by those who are better informed or who have particular goals in the discussion.

Another common element of discourse and frame analysis is that they are prone to the same significant source of error: the incorrect or biased coding...

This is critical because researchers tend to present coded information to their audience, not the underlying data that prompted the coding. "Once coded and enumerated, the basis of the coding decision is lost to the analyst" (Johnston, p.87). Therefore, simple coding processes are important. Likewise, having multiple independent coders or a panel-system, so that coding is not simply an individual's subjective judgment can help reduce coding errors.
An additional similarity between frame and discourse analyses is revealed when one compares the two to other types of analyses. "Applied to social movements, they ask different kinds of questions and demand different kinds of data than structuralist and rationalist approaches" (Johnston, p.88). As a result, they might embrace a wide variety of methodologies, and this embrace of varying methodologies is one of the reasons that it is difficult to differentiate between frame analysis and discourse analysis.

Because both frame and discourse analyses have broad definitions, they can be blurred, which can lead to overlap. Therefore, the individual researcher needs to take on the burden of defining the type of study used. "It is crucial that the concepts be clearly defined and used consistently from the initial study design to the final write-up" (Johnston, p.85). Therefore, by not blurring the two in an individual research scenario, it becomes easier to group different research approaches as either discourse or frame analyses. It seems almost impossible to conclusively distinguish the two. From Johnston's description, it appears that discourse could be considered a way of framing information for an analysis. This means that the frame would be determining what all information the discourse includes. Of course, this differentiation really depends upon the individual definitions used by each researcher.

References

Johnston, H. Verfication and proof in frame and discourse analysis. P. 62-89.

Sources used in this document:
References

Johnston, H. Verfication and proof in frame and discourse analysis. P. 62-89.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Frame Analysis Vs. Quantitative Frame
Words: 1315 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

A number of researchers think that qualitative and quantitative methodologies cannot be pooled because the assumptions fundamental to each tradition are so greatly different. "Other researchers think they can be used in combination only by alternating between methods: qualitative research is appropriate to answer certain kinds of questions in certain conditions and quantitative is right for others. And some researchers think that both qualitative and quantitative methods can be used

Frame-By-Frame Analysis: The First Ten
Words: 2599 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

This 'floating' use of body parts and fluid use of human and mouse anatomical characteristics is another distinct feature of the graphic style of Maus. Frame 6 In this frame, we discover the source of the father's displeasure with Mala. Mala was putting Artie's coat on a wire hanger. The petty nature of this tantrum indicates the stress under which Artie's father labors. He is angry about small things, despite having

Frame the Problems/Issues Into a Decision Question:
Words: 1484 Length: 3 Document Type: Case Study

Frame the Problems/Issues into a Decision Question: frame the major issues and/or problems around a key goal or objective, differentiating the long from the short-run. What is the best course of action for this case in order to achieve lower blood prices while spurring economic competition in the Carolina's? In the long run, all health care organizations want to lower the overall cost of blood operations. Economically, the cost of these operations

Analysis of Nibcos Big Bang Case Study
Words: 658 Length: 2 Document Type: Case Study

NIBCOs Big Bang Reasons behind NIBCO's Decision to Implement an ERP System One of the main reasons behind the decision by NIBCO to execute an ERP system that spun across the whole organization was the need to incorporate all the operations of the company over an assimilated, single policy. This was to ensure that issues linked to matching and managing information as well as data from individual and separate systems could be

Analysis of Moschino Barbie Ad
Words: 1006 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Advertising Company Overview Mattel is a producer of children's toys, including the well-known industry brands Fisher Price, Barbie and Hot Wheels. The company has strategic partnerships with several other major brands such as Disney, WWE, Nickelodeon and Warner Bros. The company did nearly $6.5 billion in revenue in the last fiscal year, and turned a profit of just of $900 million. Nearly half of its revenues come from international markets. The Barbie brand

Analysis of Friedmans The World Is Flat
Words: 2944 Length: 10 Document Type: Essay

World is Flat" is taken from a metaphorical point-of-view to highlight the development and advancement of technology in the world. The author, Thomas Friedman, asserts that the world has become flatter because technology together with other factors has turned the world into a smaller place. The author describes the manner in which technology has made the world become more competitive and elucidates what is necessary to compete in this

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now