Verified Document

Fortune Summary And Rebuttal Stipp, David. April Term Paper

¶ … Fortune Summary and Rebuttal

Stipp, David. (April 5, 2004) Chasing the Youth Pill. FORTUNE.

He or she who patents the pill that will magically extend human life, states David Stipp of Fortune magazine, will be not only healthy and wise, but also quite wealthy as well. Although most readers might take a more physical and personal interest in extending life, this reporter from Fortune Magazine points out that, as potential anti-aging drugs have become a legitimate research area they are also a potential financial bonanza for pharmaceutical companies and scientists.

According to Huber Warner, head of the Institute's Biology of Aging Program, the purpose of a recently funded study was to "identify drugs that foster a healthier old age" and also to discover "compounds that lengthen mouse lives" that "may well ward off ills like cancer, which shorten the lives of rodents as well as people." Stipp adds that drugs that "extend human life and confer a healthier old age are probably coming," and coming soon although, "perhaps not fast enough to make much difference to the baby-boom generation," he notes, presumably in regards to himself. "Even a drug that modestly slows human aging -- extending the average lifespan by, say, 15% -- would change everything," he adds, enthusiastically, although vaguely as regards to what everything might mean.

Thus Stipp's initial ethical analysis seems a bit shaky. In his commends regarding mice, for instance, he ethically equalizes curing the disease of cancer with prolonging natural, healthy, but invariably terminal aging. True, there are long-lived examples in natural history, such as France's Jeanne Calment. But she is the exception rather than the rule.

Moreover,...

"Animals fed 30% to 40% fewer calories than they usually prefer to eat generally live 30% to 40% longer' and many individuals have put themselves on CR diets today. However, from a 'wealth standpoint' it might seem that there is little lucrative benefit for an individual who wishes to profit off of the longevity drive. Wouldn't a CR diet simply take more money out of the pockets of food sellers and drugs companies who benefit from cholesterol reducing drugs and drugs to treat the consequences of obesity?
Furthermore, calorie restriction as a lifestyle seems to harbor little hope for the survival of the species. Long-lived rodents are unusually small and infertile, only highlighting a rather 'creepy' aspect of longevity studies that Stipp, in his enthusiasm, does not seem to notice. When Stipp notes that "the mutants' idiosyncrasies support a theory that explains everything from the marked longevity of dwarf animals like Chihuahuas to the infertility of anorexic women," the idea of a future of skinny, old individuals and tiny dogs as the future of life upon earth is less than pleasant.

Another possibility exists in lab of Leonard Guarente, a Massachusetts Institute of Technology biology professor, which discovered an "enzyme called Sir2p that appears to act like a famine sensor: It registers calorie intake and, when it is very low, helps activate the formation of long-living spores -- a yeast cell's version of hunkering down in a state of slowed aging, "mimicking caloric restriction" in yeast. "Now the race is on" to determine whether it does the same thing in mammals, including humans, possibly yielding the…

Sources used in this document:
However, all of these modifications are quite different than simply popping a pill to prolong human existence. The idea that some individuals would have access to a life-prolonging pill because of greater wealth and available pharmaceutical health care would not simply exacerbate the differences between the lifestyle and lives of the rich and poor, it would effectively create a 'brave new world,' where alpha long lived humans dominated and planned their lives differently than shorter lived epsilons, whom had no hope of getting the longevity drug. Even if everyone was accorded such a drug, the greater lifespan over such a short period of time would mean that individuals would require more health care, dwell in apartments and homes for longer periods of time, require more help when elderly (even if the longevity pill was accompanied by greater resilience of constitution) and perhaps even have a prolonged adolescence because they knew they would life longer.

In short, many of the modern cultural effects of aging would become even more pronounced than they are now in the United States -- and the difference between countries where the drug was present with other nations is even more striking. Even recent MSNBC article on calorie restrictive diets, which are perhaps the least noxious form of this urge to prolong life was entitled, "Starve your way to health." Of course, at very least such diets would not enrich the makers of a drug at the expense of those in other nations or Americans who could not afford a prescription. But the title shows the unnaturalness of the diet and its incompatibility with not only modern cultural lifestyles but also the human body.

Far from making the adherents healthy, one man who "used to run 20 miles a week," is now down to 10. "He doesn't have the calories to spare."(Adler and Underwood, 2004, Newsweek article retrieved at (http://msnbc.msn.com/id/3927655/)The article goes on to say that although the man is actually "philosophical about the question of dying, conceding that he could get run over by a truck next week, perhaps while fantasizing about a chocolate-chip cookie. But he thinks the prospect of another decade or two of life is worth some sacrifices." (Adler and Underwood, 2004, Newsweek article retrieved at (http://msnbc.msn.com/id/3927655/)This notion of the inability to control human life and risk, however, indicates the final argument against the drive to extend human life in a predictable and marketable fashion -- it is ultimately impossible to with either a diet or a drug to perfectly curtail risk and chance and human error, even in the developed world -- why restrict human enjoyment in the process and divert research dollars from improving the lives of all humans, all over the world, whom are dying young from famine and deadly diseases?
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Brave New World and the Island
Words: 787 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Brave New World and the Island The Need for a "Way Out" in Brave New World and the Island The future looks grim for mankind in the dystopian novel Brave New World and the film The Island. In both works, a terrible dependency upon technology and "science" has caused mankind to lose its "soul" and forget the transcendental values that make life worth living. Both works are effective in displaying the negative

Brave New World Aldous Huxley's
Words: 1664 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

There will always be savages, and the attraction of savagery. Huxley wrote Brave New World as a warning. Today, in the age of test-tube pregnancy, genetic manipulation, powerful drugs and the mass media, it appears that his warning has gone unheeded and that America is on the road to the scientific utopia he describes. Certainly the world of the savages has been left behind, and for good reason. Modern Americans

Brave New World Novel
Words: 1350 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Brave New World: Oh Wonder! That Has Such Similar People (to us) in it! Aldous Huxley is often cited as an architect of a society that is eerily prescient of our own future. "In a number of specifics Huxley's prophecies are tellingly accurate," writes literary critic Kirkpatrick Sale, such as "the ubiquity of sports, television in hotel and hospital rooms, a general ignorance of history," and "psychology and chemistry as important change

Brave New World Largely, the World State
Words: 1533 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Brave New World Largely, the World State is able to control society through technology in this fiction, set in the year 2540, or for 632 years after the creation of the first Model T. car by American industrialist Henry Ford. This is the Central London Hatching and Conditioning Centre, a savage reservation in New Mexico, a Utopia, where no family life has existed for more than six centuries. Human life is

Brave New World What Is
Words: 646 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

He went to jail for refusing to pay taxes, to protest America's involvement in the Mexican War"(Henry David Thoreau," Microsoft® Encarta® Online Encyclopedia, 2007). While it could be argued that refusing to pay taxes hurt Americans who had nothing to do with the government's decision, Thoreau would counter that if no one obeyed their conscience, and everyone simply conformed to societal dictates, positive change would be impossible in the

Brave New World
Words: 692 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

living in the kind of horrific society that Aldous Huxley warned about almost a century ago. In Brave New World, Huxley wrote about a world where people are only concerned with satisfaction of desires. They are constantly entertained through visual and tactile means in addition to being constantly drugged. Although we have not yet reached a pointer where we are artificially reproducing, there are still far too many similarities.

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now