Verified Document

Forensics, Law, & Psychology: False Confessions It Research Paper

Forensics, Law, & Psychology: False Confessions It is a well accepted law in the forensic field, that only recently slipped through, that investigations can be helped by compelling people to confess. However this forensic law that encourages and enables forced confession spirals off methodological research in psychology that shows that such confessions can be harmful to the field since many prisoners end off confessing under duress and admitting to actions that they actually never perpetrated.

More than 80% of criminal cases are settled by a coercive confession (Zimbardo, 1967) and indeed, Dr. W. Sargant said that without confessions convictions may be reduced by about 70%. Confessions are an accepted part of the forensic scene and an "attractive way of solving crimes" (cited in Brandon & Davies, 1973). However, many confessions are elicited under duress -- an acceptable law in forensics -- and consistent empirical research shows that this may well result in miscarriages of judgment where the individual resorts to false confessions. How often false confessions actually occur, and how often they result in wrongful conviction, is unclear although there is significant research on the subject (e.g. Zimbardo, 1967) showing that the phenomena happens enough times to elicit signficant concern, particularly if the confession results in a conviction. Huff, Ratner, and Sagain (1986) estimated 6000 wrongful convictions in the U.S.A., whilst taking all the research into consideration and estimating that much remains unknown. Conti (1999) approximates that 300 false confessions occur each year in a high-volume area

Forensic law accepts three different types of confession: voluntary, coerced-compliant, and coerced-internalized (Conti, 1999). The latter two types of confession...

In fact, the history of confessions in forensic legal system is interesting. In the nation's early history, confessions were seen as a significant part to conviction. Physical coercion to elicit confession was common but waned during the later 1800s to 1900s when the U.S. courts became cynical of such confessions and tended to dismiss them as questionable. Forced confessions however continued and were particularly common in Black / White cases where Blacks were often falsely convicted under duress of coerced confessions. One such notorious case was the Brown v. Mississippi (1936) case where three Black men had to sign a police-written confession to a murder of a white individual. The men were beaten, tortured, and threatened with their lives and were disallowed consultation with an attorney. Each was convicted and sentenced to death, but the Supreme Court reversed the decision insisting that a trial "is a mere pretense where the state authorities have continued a conviction resting solely upon confessions obtained by violence" (Conti, 1999, p. 287). So the confession has to be voluntary, given freely and compliantly without physical or other coercion. The repercussions of the Civil Rights Movement in the '60s and '70s set the precedent that "that a state court conviction resting upon a confession extorted by brutality and violence violated the accused's general right to due process guaranteed by the Fourteenth Amendment" (McCormick, 1992, p. 232).
Confessions elicited by mental abuse fall under the same category. In the case of Chambers v. Florida (1940) for instance, five drawn-out days of interrogation were castigated by the Supreme Court and similarly in the case of Haynes v. Washington (1963) where the defendant was refused telephone contact with his family…

Sources used in this document:
References

Brandon, R., & Davies, C. (1973). Wrongful imprisonment. London, England: Allen and Unwin

Brothers Ltd.

Conti, R.P. (1999) The Psychology of False Confessions. The Journal of Credibility Assessment and Witness Psychology, 2, 14-36.

Huff, C.R., Rattner, A., & Sagarin, E. (1996). Convicted but innocent: Wrongful conviction and public policy. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Forensic Fabric Analysis
Words: 2310 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

Forensic Fabric Analysis Some of the basic tools that a fabric examiner should at least have at any given moment include a stereomicroscope, along with a composite light microscope that is fitted with polarized light capability, and a comparison microscope. When examining both questioned and known fabric, the examiner must do this side by side, and within the same magnifications in terms of visible light. Alternative lighting, which includes fluorescent lighting

Forensic Accountant Must Possess Accounting
Words: 1557 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

Assets in the investment portfolio were overvalued. Financial transactions were structured to report smaller amounts of debt and create the appearance of greater cash flow. Financial results were represented in a false and misleading manner. Forensic accountants also played an important role in the Enron case by doing audits and investigating accounting practices to gather evidence of how the fraud was performed. They played vital roles in the court room

Law and Society
Words: 909 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Law and Society The Nature of Law and Justice - Sadomasochism Sadomasochism presents the complexities and nuances involved in the nature of law and justice. In its purest definition, socially and legally, sadomasochism is a consensual act. There may even be actual contracts involved. However, this presentation shows that just because there is consent to the act, doesn't mean that the dominant can get away with anything. In cases in which the

Law in England Are: Common Law, Statute
Words: 2941 Length: 10 Document Type: Essay

law in England are: common law, statute law, subordinate legislation, custom, and European community law. Common law: This is the cannon of law applying to the general swathes of law that are decided by the judges and adapted to changing times. Judges make its rules over the years that have relied on precedents of other cases and adapted preceding rulings to suit the circumstances of the present instance. Each new

Lesson Plan Amp; Reflection I Didn't Know
Words: 857 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Lesson Plan Amp; Reflection I didn't know what state you are in so was unable to do state/district standards! Lesson Plan Age/Grade Range; Developmental Level(s): 7-8/2nd Grade; Below grade level Anticipated Lesson Duration: 45 Minutes Lesson Foundations Pre-assessment (including cognitive and noncognitive measures): All students are reading below grade level (5-7 months) as measured by standardized assessments and teacher observation Curricular Focus, Theme, or Subject Area: Reading: Fluency, word recognition, and comprehension State/District Standards: Learning Objectives: Students will develop

Branding New Service Dominant Logic
Words: 12522 Length: 50 Document Type: Dissertation

Branding in Service Markets Amp Aim And Objectives Themes for AMP Characteristics Composing Branding Concept Branding Evolution S-D Logic and Service Markets Branding Challenges in Service Markets Considerations for Effective Service Branding Categories and Themes Branding Theory Evolution S-D Logic and Service Markets Branding Challenges in Service Markets Considerations for Effective Service Branding Branding Concept Characteristics Characteristics Composing Branding Concept Sampling of Studies Reviewed Evolution of Branding Theory Evolution of Marketing Service-Brand-Relationship-Value Triangle Brand Identity, Position & Image Just as marketing increasingly influences most aspects of the consumer's lives, brands

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now