Verified Document

Food Ban Food Should Be Banned From Essay

Food Ban Food should be banned from the New York City subway system. There are a few reasons why the food ban should be enacted, chief among them are the health concerns cited by state senators. Proponents of eating food on the subway system generally have weak arguments based around their own personal desire to eat food on the subway, rather than any coherent responses to the central sanitation and public nuisance argument.

According to the text of the bill (S6312), the purpose of the bill is to "mitigate the growing rat infestation in the NYC subway system." The bill would establish fines and other punishments for eating food on the subway system. There are a number of problems with the rat issue in the subway system. In general, people experience a sense of revulsion at the sight of rats, in particular the large, greasy variety found in the subway system. This alone is a good case for action taken to reduce the rat population in the New York City subway system.

However, there are sound medical reasons for eliminating eating on the subway. Subway passengers often spill food, on the trains which creates a mess, but also on the platforms. This spilled food provides nourishment for the rats that live in the subway system. The rats, however, pose a health threat to humans. Rats carry parasites, such as fleas, worms and mites, and these spread disease. Such parasitic insects, such as ticks, can carry disease like Lyme disease that can be spread to humans.

Worse are the communicable diseases that can be carried by rats. These include leptospirosis, a disease that affects the kidney and liver, damaging those vital organs. Rats are also carriers of meningitis, and can carry illnesses that cause respiratory damage. In addition, rats are known carriers of bubonic plague. The subway system is a densely packed...

As such, it is a major risk factor for the spread of communicable disease. An outbreak in the city would be horrific, and could easily be spread very quickly via the subway system. It is worth considering that the current rat population poses significant risks.
The legislation also outlines that food is one of the major causes of the rat population explosion. Also cited was a perceived poor job of pest control by the MTA. Controlling rat populations, however, can be difficult. Rats are prolific breeders, and hard to capture. With their current population, it will be difficult for the transit authority to eliminate the rats entirely. Thus, additional measures need to be taken.

There is significant opposition to the bill. Prendergast and Buiso (2012) note that for many people, the subway is where they have the opportunity to eat meals. New Yorkers are often busy, and forced to eat meals on the go. Therefore, banning eating on the subway would be a terrible inconvenience for people. There were also concerns that banning food was impractical and unenforceable. Arguably, transit police have better things to do with their time as well, as food is not something that is usually a danger to security in the subway.

The convenience argument abuts against counterarguments based on the same line of reasoning -- personal preference. Prendergast and Buiso (2012) note that some people find eating on the go to be distasteful and not representative of civilized society. Such views are a little harsh, perhaps, but they reflect that the issue is one of personal choice and not everybody agrees. Subway passengers may, for example, have food spilled on them by careless co-passengers. In addition, food aromas could be offensive to some. If a cigarette is so noxious…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited:

AP. (2012). MTA chief says he opposes subway food ban. ABC News. Retrieved May 10, 2012 from http://abclocal.go.com/wabc/story?section=resources/traffic&id=8543501

Prendergast, D. & Buiso, G. (2012). Pol push to ban eating in the subway. New York Post. Retrieved May 9, 2012 from http://www.nypost.com/p/news/local/pol_push_to_ban_eating_in_the_subway_ZvKq3qRxecSkAMTWoE6wmJ

S6312-2011: Prohibits the consumption of food in New York City subways. New York Senate.gov. Retrieved May 9, 2012 from http://open.nysenate.gov/legislation/bill/S6312-2011
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Banning Soda There Is No Real Argument
Words: 1469 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Banning Soda There is no real argument in favor of soda; it adds absolutely nothing positive to anyone's daily dietary intake. In fact, it is said to contribute heavily to obesity, diabetes, heart disease tooth decay, and other serious health issues. It is argued that by banning soda many of these negative aspects will be eliminated or at least reduced and therefore reduce health care costs associated with drinking soda. With

Food Trucks Have Brought a
Words: 703 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

This is due to the fact that they will have attracted and retained many customers leaving very few people visiting the restaurants. This high command of the market share really cripples these restaurants. Restaurants no longer dominant the food industry and if food trucks continue gaining popularity then they will eventually loose the battle of trying to be dominant in the market. They will end up loosing most of

Food Safety Critical Analysis
Words: 1443 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Food The case of Stephanie Smith is certainly alarming, and having familiarized myself with both the ammonia in hamburger issue and the pink slime issue, I will argue that my faith in the USDA and FDA to provide protection to American consumers in terms of the food they eat is sorely lacking. I understand the reality that I have personally not become sick from eating food in America, but that does

Food Inc. After the Current Outbreaks of
Words: 2765 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Food Inc. After the current outbreaks of salmonella which brought a scare to those living in the U.S., looking at the documentary Food Inc. has actually been the best thing. This film is known as the expose of the food industry. Directed by Robert Kenner, the documentary was brought to the movie theaters in the U.S. In 2009, and then it hit the DVD stands in 2010. Even though it did

Food Supply Safe and Adequate The Question
Words: 615 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Food Supply Safe and Adequate? The question to be answered in this essay is whether or not America's food supply is adequate and safe. The two issues are related. One of the reasons America has an ample food supply is because of advances made in the biochemistry of agriculture. This affects food coming from both animals and plants. New advances in herbicides have helped farmers increase the size of their crops. The

Food As a Public Good and Obesity As an Externality
Words: 1729 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

Health Public Good Public Health as a Public Good The United States has one of the lowest cost food options available to its consumers in the world. For an extended period, people assumed that this was a benefit of capitalism and that competition had helped push down the prices and made food available at lower costs through the market. However, many externalities have arisen in these circumstances that are now pointing researchers

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now