Verified Document

Financial And Economic Impact Of Worker's Compensation Essay

Financial and Economic Impact of Worker's Compensation Regulations And Compliance The program and concept of Workers' Compensation might appear to be a product of a civilized society and the modern era, but nothing could be further from the truth. In fact, Workers' Compensation has essentially been around for as long as people have been completing task for payment of some form of another, because people have always been getting hurt in some way, on the job. "The history of compensation for bodily injury begins shortly after the advent of written history itself1. The Nippur Tablet No. 3191 from ancient Sumeria in the Fertile Crescent outlines the law of Ur-Nammu, king of the city-state of Ur. It dates to approximately 2050 B.C.2. The law of Ur provided monetary compensation for specific injury to workers' body parts, including fractures. The code of Hammurabi from 1750 B.C. provided a similar set of rewards for specific injuries and their implied permanent impairments. Ancient Greek, Roman, Arab, and Chinese law provided sets of compensation schedules, with precise payments for the loss of a body part. For example, under ancient Arab law, loss of a joint of the thumb was worth one-half the value of a finger. The loss of a penis was compensated by the amount of length lost, and the value an ear was based on its surface area. All the early compensation schemes consisted of "schedules" such as this; specific injuries determined specific rewards" (Guyton, 1999). This compensation schema demonstrates the notion that is present today that not all injuries are as serious as others and that different injuries deserve different forms of payment.

Of course, one could make a strong case for the fact that this system was coarser than the one in place today (though some disgruntled workers might argue the opposite) as the value of a body part seems largely connected to its size. Today the concepts of "quality of life" and "pain and suffering" have been introduced and compensation can be immediately linked to these two issues. For example, the notion of a man being compensated for the loss of part of his penis based on the length of this organ that is lost is a completely ludicrous notion to a modern audience. The contemporary mentality is that once a man's penis is damaged or deformed in any sort of way, the appropriate compensation thus begins.

However, despite the fact that the notion of compensation for bodily injuries is as old as work itself, it didn't really leave an imprint upon modern society until the industrial revolution. Even though the industrial revolution was a crucial and exciting time for America and one which created an enormous push for modernity and progress, there was a price to pay for the rapidity of expansion. It was indeed the machine age, and human beings were the ones creating and operating these machines. At the same time, there was a certain give and take push and pull and margin of error and mistakes that had to occur. "As economic and industrial activities flourished, the number of work injuries also grew. The increasing use of machinery, new concepts of producing goods, and the pressure of increased demand for products resulted in more injury problems without solutions for employers and employees. For the most part, workers who were injured on the job had no recourse other than to sue their employers at common law, an expensive and time-consuming process. The court system was crowded, causing long delays. Compensation for injuries was usually insufficient and uncertain. The employee sometimes was forced to bear the expense of injury himself or had to throw himself on the mercy of welfare" (aascif.org). This demonstrates the very real consequences of not having a proper system in place for workers to seek financial help within, for their injuries. Without a formal system of workers' compensation the very real consequences were things like clogged court systems, overuse of the welfare system, and generally large amounts of wounded employees who had nowhere else to turn and no way to support their families. This demonstrates how even though this emerging machine age was providing a definitive benefit to society; it was also damaging a large chunk of the workers contributing to a participating in this crucial time.

Eventually, "Laws were enacted to provide workers injured on the job with prompt, equitable, and guaranteed benefits. Injured workers received medical care and disability income irrespective of fault. Employers, in turn, were protected from potentially catastrophic loss by a stated amount of specific benefits for the injuries suffered by the employee. The worker was prohibited...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

This clearly demonstrates how such a program protected both the company and the worker. The company benefited from knowing that they wouldn't be sued and forseeably put out of business indefinitely, and the employee benefited from knowing that he would be taken care of, if anything should happen to him on the job. Aside from signaling a higher level of humanity for workers and employers, giving both of them peace of mind, the modern emergence of workers' compensation meant that work was regulated in such a way that it wouldn't wreak havoc on the court system or on the welfare system.
Analysis of the Field

Workers' compensation is a vital component related to employment and safety, but at the same time, it's a program that doesn't simply exist because people want it to: it needs to have a strong financial backing and needs to be fiscally supported. Finding ways to make workers' compensation more affordable for employers is pivotal as the overall success and longevity of the program depends on it. One of the major issues present in worker's compensation today is as a result of increasing prescription drug costs. "Alex Swedlow, Vice-President of Research for the California Workers' Compensation Research Institute, reported on CWCI project which reviewed workers' compensation pharmaceutical costs. Through analysis of detailed claim specific medical data, CWCI uncovered some very specific causes for the growth in pharmaceutical costs. One interesting result was the rise in physicians dispensing drugs within their own clinics; this practice allows physicians to circumvent pharmacy fee schedule restrictions through clever repackaging techniques" (iaiabc.org, 2010). This highlights an issue that's neither the fault of the employee or the employer; rather it demonstrates a fault of one of the parties: involved doctors.

Doctors, it appears, are taking the opportunity to raise prices, simply by virtue of the fact that they can. While this increases profits for them, it means that certain workers' comp benefits are becoming pricier, and with that, less affordable. However, part of the increased prescription costs is just by virtue of the fact that the drugs prescribed are pricier by nature. "Although a physician-dispensing is certainly contributing to the rise of drug costs, the most significant increase can be attributed to the shocking growth in opioid prescription use. The use of Schedule II drugs, which have restrictive applications for the relief of serious chronic pain, is being prescribed for a variety of claims that historically did not require such drugs. Swedlow's research showed prescription patterns in California in which a tiny fraction of physicians were generating a very large share of the opioid prescriptions" (iaiabc.org, 2010). Opioids are extremely powerful drugs which are expensive by nature. However, this isn't the only reason that their usage is driving up the system costs all over the nation: opioids have an extreme and indelible impact on the lives of workers. "Workers on opioids are often highly dependent, face delays in return to work, and may suffer other physical or psychological challenges due to addiction" (iaibc.org, 2010).

This issue with workers' compensation and the rate of prescription of opioids is completely out of control. It has been calculated that between 55-86% of all Workers comp claimants are on opioids of some sort as a means of soothing chronic pain (Morgan, 2012). However, the problem with this fact is that it's generally an effective long-term drug when it comes to conditions like cancer treatments (Morgan, 2012). In fact, there's hard evidence which points to the prevalence of opioids doing more harm than good; the Center for Disease Control cites how deaths related to the usage of painkillers has increased at least 300% in the last 13 years, more than the deaths connected to cocaine or heroin usage combined (Morgan, 2012). In fact, the incorrect usage or abuse-related addiction to painkillers was accountable for half a million trips to the ER in 2009, a number which had doubled in just half a decade (Morgan, 2012). If these numbers demonstrate anything, they showcase the vital need of a better means of regulation for opioid use and workers. It's a heavy-handed approach which demonstrates poor health care techniques and shoddy judgment on behalf of medical professionals. It's so problematic as opioids are far too potent, powerful and addictive forms of substance to give individuals dealing with chronic pain. It's the equivalent of giving a child…

Sources used in this document:
References

Benyamin, R., Buenaventura,, . R., Datta, S., & Adlaka, R. (2008). Opioid Complications and Side Effects. Pain Physician, S106-S111.

Boggs, C. (2008, July 29). Workers' Compensation History: The Great Tradeoff! Retrieved from mynewmarkets.com: http://www.mynewmarkets.com/articles/91833/workers-compensation-history-the-great-tradeoff

Ceniceros, R. (2012, December 12). State reduces workers comp opioid prescriptions. Retrieved from Businessinsurance.com: http://www.businessinsurance.com/article/99999999/NEWS080102/399999826

Eley, L. (n.d.). FEDERAL AGENCY HELPS COAL MINERS DETECT BLACK LUNG DISEASE. Retrieved from Denversworkerscompensationattorney.com: http://www.denverworkerscompensationattorney.com/2011/03/federal-agency-helps-coal-miners-detect-black-lung-disease.shtml
Harrison, S. (2011, December 4). Employers helping workers fight opioid abuse. Retrieved from businessinsurance.com: http://www.businessinsurance.com/article/20111204/NEWS08/312049984
Hickey, S. (2012, January 13). Opioid Use a Growing Epidemic in Workers' Comp. Retrieved from Property Casualty 360: http://www.propertycasualty360.com/2012/01/13/opioid-use-a-growing-epidemic-in-workers-comp
Iaiabc.org. (2010, September 23). Emerging Issues in Workers' Compensation Discussed at the IAIABC Annual Convention 2010. Retrieved from Iaiabc.org: http://www.iaiabc.org/i4a/headlines/headlinedetails.cfm?id=191&archive=1
Morgan, C. (2012, October 2). An Update on Opioids and Impact on Workers Compensation Insurance. Retrieved from Caitlin Morgan: http://www.caitlin-morgan.com/blog/an-update-on-opioids-and-impact-on-workers-compensation-insurance
Prnewswire.com. (2012). Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine Study Illustrates Impact of Opioid Use on Workers' Compensation Claim Costs in Michigan. Retrieved from prnewswire.com: http://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/journal-of-occupational-and-environmental-medicine-study-illustrates-impact-of-opioid-use-on-workers-compensation-claim-costs-in-michigan-167543605.html
Umwa.org. (n.d.). Black Lung. Retrieved from Umwa.org: http://www.umwa.org/?q=content/black-lung
Workcompwire.com. (2010, November 4). Narcotics Abuse in Workers' Compensation. Retrieved from Workcompwire.com: http://www.workcompwire.com/2010/11/narcotics-abuse-workers-compensation/
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Workers Compensation Law
Words: 1136 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Workers Compensation Law The paper contains an in-depth explanation of Workers' Compensation Law in light of various court cases. The terminology implies a payment given to employees by their employers for a portion of the cost of damages, injuries or occupational diseases. The magnitude of this responsibility upon the employer varies in different countries and states of United States. Most of the worker's compensation systems today, comprise of a proper legislation

Workers' Compensation Insurance Was First
Words: 1879 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

For instance, any retraining measures should focus primarily on the Medical Provider Network and the Independent Medical Evaluator as these issues will be where a majority of client questions will come in. When a potential client calls with a question regarding getting medical treatment for a work injury, a staff member must be capable of both providing accurate information and in convincing the caller that professional legal services are

Workers' Compensation in America, a
Words: 339 Length: 1 Document Type: Term Paper

.. society should bear the burden of any misfortunes." (Review guide for the CRC examination: Workers Compensation). Thus, according to this review guide, worker's compensation emerged to treat industrial accidents as predictable costs shared by all consumers regardless of fault. It replaced a failed legal system where employers had once successfully defended themselves against workers' law suits using various common law defenses that made them virtually immune from legal responsibility.

Worker Compensation and Termination
Words: 1602 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

WORKER COMPENSATION AND WRONGFUL TERMINATION 1Worker Compensation and Wrongful TerminationCase Scenario 1Georgia�s case presents several ethical and legal issues related to employment. Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights raises legal issues related to racial discrimination and retaliation at the workplace. Title VII covers all employers with at least fifteen employees and makes it unlawful for an employer to discriminate against an employee on the basis of national origin, gender,

Worker's Compensation Is a Well
Words: 872 Length: 3 Document Type: Term Paper

Other acts include the Federal Employment liability Act, the Marchant Marine Act and the Longshore and Harbor Workers' Compensation Act. There are also workers compensation acts that are geared towards problems associated with illnesses or health concerns that have arisen from working in certain industries. One example of this is the Black Lung Benefits Act. This particular act provides compensation for miners who acquire www.nlm.nih.govPneumoconiosis a lung disease that develops

Compensations and Benefits Issues Inequities,
Words: 3157 Length: 10 Document Type: Thesis

The IRS may also impose a 10% excise tax or a maximum of $10,000 on an officer who knowingly entered into a transaction (Samuels and Shoretz). When this happens, the official endeavors to enter a rebuttable presumption that the compensation and benefits are reasonable (Samuels and Shoretz 2002). The board of directors or trustees must approve the three criteria for the rebuttal. In the first, the board must be composed

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now