Yet, many critical care nurses have reported that they received little preparation in their basic education programs to deal with these sensitive issues. (Nibert, Ainslie T. 2005)
This may constitute a moral dilemma as the study points out. "A moral conflict exists because two opposing obligations collide: an obligation to the family members who desire to be present with their loved one during CPR and an obligation to the healthcare providers who do not want patients' family members to witness resuscitation efforts." (ibid)
The study suggests that resolving this ethical dilemma lies in hospital and medical policy which would allow for clear instructions for "reinforcing the existing policy that prohibits their presence, or selectively permitting them to be present on the basis of screening according to predetermined criteria." (ibid) Nibert establishes four areas that should be taken into consideration when assessing the implications of family presence. These are (1) medical indications; (2) patients' preferences; (3) quality of life; and (4) social, economic, and health policy issues. (ibid) Another aspect is that nursing staff may find that the presence of family members may affect their authority.
Brown and Ritchie (1990) reported nurses were threatened by the perceived loss of authority that was associated with increased parent participation.
An important aspect in attempting to resolve this problem is the fact that many medical institutions do not have a firm set of policy guidelines on this issue. In a survey of 1500 members of the American Association of Critical-Care Nurses and 1500 members of the Emergency Nurses Association. It was found that "nearly all respondents have no written policies for family presence yet most have done (or would do) it, prefer that it be allowed, and are confronted with requests from family members to be present. Written policies or guidelines for family presence during resuscitation and invasive procedures are recommended. (Desy, Pierre. 2003)
Conclusion
Despite a growing movement in support of family presence, many healthcare professional still continue to resist adopting the practice. One of the arguments made is that "not enough research supports making a change in practice." (Mason, Diana J. 2003) There are no easy solutions to these issues. On the one hand the tendency to allow family presence is justified by factors such as family dignity and moral and psychological support. On the other hand there is also justification in the assertion that family presence may be counterproductive, not only for the nursing and medical staff but also for family members who may be emotionally traumatized. Part of the answer to this dilemma lies in the clarification of policy, as has been suggested, and in the improvement in nursing training to deal with the issue of family presence. As Nibert suggests:
Nurse educators teaching critical care courses can increase...
presence of family members in the resuscitation room, various factors must be taken into account. In regards to such events leading to traumatic repercussions, if the patient does not respond to the measures, it is likely that the next of kin would be affected by the experience. Moreover, by allowing family members to be present, staff is expected to ensure a minimum of support. However, given that resuscitation measures
Family Life Education Consider NCFR Substance Area # 8 - FAMILY LAW AND PUBLIC POLICY and Substance Area # 9 -- ETHICS. Compare and contrast these areas with particular focus on how they might conflict with teach other. According to the National Council on Family Relations, Area Number Eight, Family Law and Public Policy refers to a comprehension of the legal factors, policies and pieces of legislation which can influence the well-being
Many nations do not use restorative justice as a policy, but eventually bright, progressive leaders worldwide will hopefully learn the value of restorative justice, and implement it at some level. Youth Justice Process in New Zealand. (2005). Family Group Conference. Retrieved 29 June 2008, at http://www.justice.govtnz/youth/fgc.html. This government-produced review of the ideologies and practical implementation of the Family Group Conference was a valuable and basic article in terms of the understanding
Family Law Amendment (Shared Parental Responsibility) Act U v U [2002] HCA Over the years, the moral fibre of the society has continued to crumble. One of the most affected social units in the society is the family. Spouses exchange vows only to go back on their promise that 'till death do us part.' Children are often at the receiving end of such scenarios since family disintegration often has a negative impact
Conjoint Family Therapy What is Conjoint Family Therapy? Family therapy, also known as conjoint family therapy is a technique or a subfield of psychotherapy which basically focuses its attention towards helping couples and families cope up with the various kinds of problems they are facing in their relationships. They aim to get to the root of the situation and the reason why problems arise and then systematically resolve these by encouraging the
Nevertheless, the family capacity does not receive full exploitation during most intervention programs. A central challenge to most interventions is the need to broaden the chemical abuse treatment focus from the addict to the family. The initial stages depict diligent commitment and focus from the families. Upon receiving pre-counseling, families shift more attention in uniting to help their loved ones free themselves from substance abuse. The initial stages of the
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now