Verified Document

Fake News And Bee Research Paper

Political satire has long been a standard method of political and social commentary. Jonathan Swift's essay "A Modest Proposal" is a prime example of how satire is a powerful vehicle for raising awareness about critical social and political issues, but doing so in a relatively nonthreatening and accessible way. In the United States, political cartoons have long been the bastion of political satire. Howeve, r as Wallachy puts it, "American satire has changed a great deal since Benjamin Franklin's 'Join or Die' cartoon," (1). Technology is one reason why political satire in America has changed its approach. Both Jesse Watters and Samantha Bee have traditional television shows on the one hand, but both also benefit from new media both to find fodder for their discussions but also to propagate their ideas. However, there are critical differences between these two political humor shows. The most glaring difference is that Bee offers a more classic and biting sort of satire, what Wallachy would call "satire evolved towards advocacy" (1). Becker and Bode call Samantha Bee's show Full Frontal part of the "new political satire" in which "information-rich, longer format programs" have replaced shorter segments. Because "Watters World" is a small segment format that avoids information richness, it cannot be considered "new political satire." Bee uses ambush style interviews on occasion, but the ambush street interview is Watter's primary schtick, limiting the scope and effectiveness of "Watters World." However, both Full Frontal and "Watters World" reveal the importance of political comedy as an adjunct to straightforward media reporting. Both Samantha Bee and Jesse Watters blend comedy and politics, using comedy as a vehicle for social commentary. However, Samantha Bee's show offers far more in depth social and political commentary and touches upon deeper issues related to race, class, gender, power, and intersectionality. Bee is critical of Trump, but uses logic even more than emotion to substantiate her claims. Furthermore, Bee's recent Not the White House Correspondents' Dinner episode proves her overarching commitment to veracity in reporting, in spite of her role in comedy news. In the opening monologue to the Not the White House Correspondents' Dinner, Bee congratulates the media for remaining strong in spite of the President's numerous and direct attempts to shut down the free press by disallowing specific members of the media at White House press conferences. Bee lauds the media for "continuing to fact check the president as if one day he might actually be embarrassed," which is also one of the core purposes of Full Frontal: fact checking. Becker and Bode highlights extensive research showing that "comedy viewers are more likely than news viewers to pay close...

Full Frontal seems to encourage further investigation of the issues more than a show like "Watters World" that mainly dances around the actual issues by focusing more clearly on what ordinary Americans think or believe about the issues. Watters makes fun of Americans; Bee makes fun of the people in power.
Both Samantha Bee and Jesse Watters use humor to lighten what could actually be considered major and serious issues, with Bee focusing far more on deeper discussions and analysis than Watters. Watters avoids deep discussions, partly because the Fox News contingency he panders to does tend to shun intellectualism on principle. Both Bee and Watters showcase the role of comedy as a "stress reducer" that "helps create feelings of solidarity and morale among the oppressed," (Batalion 34). Even the perceived oppression of Trump voters finds voice and solidarity in the likes of Watters and O'Reilly. Comedy shows like Full Frontal and "Watters World" "enable criticism, cohesion, coping -- and hope," that comes from bonding with like-minded people (Batalion 34). Karpt criticizes the creation of echo chambers in new media; Johnson likewise calls out Facebook and other social media venues for using algorithms in a way that helps to perpetuate fake news. Even if the like-minded bonding creates the cognitive echo chambers that lead to Trump victories, the emotional importance of comedy cannot be underestimated. Some of Watters's interview subjects, even the conservative ones, understand the potential dangers in fake news and recognize the difference between fake news and comedy news satire the likes of Bee and Watters.

Samantha Bee's Full Frontal is more complex than "Watters World" because it encourages critical thought to a deeper degree. As Ward points out, "satire is the most complicated form of comedy; it requires an audience to understand the satire and to know enough context to appreciate the message," (1). In one episode of "Watters World," the host actually makes fun of his own audience's lack of education and critical thought, as when he states, "If people were educated, I'd be out of a job." Therefore, Watters to a degree shows that there may be "multiple layers of meaning" and even the potential for critical thought in "Watters World," (Ward 1).

The age of alternative facts is a frightful threat to American democracy, which is why Bee's show has value, whereas the Watters show does not. Bee's views can be construed as biased and yet she offers factual evidence in ways that Watters cannot. Jesse Watters relies on the familiar trope of interviewing ordinary people on the street with the goal of making them look stupid. The method of selective interviewing is deeply flaws, and when Watters does it, barely funny. The people he finds on the streets of New York are not shockingly dumb in any appreciable way, not at all like some of the panelists Bee interviews who affirm that three million voters in California were illegal and that Trump actually won the popular vote. The technique of street interviews can be funny when used well, but Watters fails utterly. Furthermore, Bee dives right into intersectionality -- issues linking race, class, gender, structural inequality, and power disparity. Bee is a…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Batalion, Judy. "Jewish Joke's On You." Jewish Quarterly, Vol. 64, No.1, 2017, pp. 33-35.

Becker, Amy B. and Bode, Leticia. "Satire as a source for learning? The differential impact of news versus satire exposure on net neutrality knowledge gain." Information, Communication, and Society, 2017, DOI: 10.1080/1369118X.2017.1301517

Bee, Samantha. Full Frontal. [Various Episodes].

Johnson, Derek. "Activating Activism." Critical Studies in Media Communication, 2017, http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/15295036.2017.1298142
Wallachy, Alexandra. "The Evolution and Importance of News Satire." University of Oregon Thesis, 2016. Retrieved online: https://scholarsbank.uoregon.edu/xmlui/handle/1794/20384
Ward, Emily. "Feminism and Political Satire." Colgate Seniors Honors Theses. Retrieved online: http://commons.colgate.edu/theses/10/
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Cross-Border Marriages Between Hong-Kong and
Words: 3062 Length: 10 Document Type: Term Paper

(Cattelain, 1997; paraphrased) the work of Cattelain additionally states that as of the beginning of "...July, 1997, approximately 66,000 children born to couples of which one is a Hong Kong resident and one is a mainlanders were waiting to come to Hong Kong, and around 2,000-4,000 children who had entered the territory illegally or overstayed visit permits were estimated to be in Hong Kong." (Cattelain, 1997) Marriage between individuals

Flapper Movement the Effect of the Flappers
Words: 8916 Length: 28 Document Type: Essay

Flapper Movement The Effect of the Flappers on Today's Women The 1920's in the U.S. And UK can be described as a period of great change, both socially and economically. During this period the image of the women completely changed and a "new women" emerged who appears to have impacted social changes occurring in future generations of both men and women. This new symbol of the women was the Flapper. The Flapper

Text Stage and Screen
Words: 4297 Length: 16 Document Type: Term Paper

Screen Shakespeare's rhetoric has always astounded his contemporary audiences through his almost supernatural ability to perceive and present the universality of human nature on stage, regardless of the time his characters lived in. The three different types of techniques used in rendering the play to the public are different, but related art forms: literature, theater and film. They reflect their author's or directors' vision of the story originally presented by Shakespeare

Jungian Phenomenology and Police Training
Words: 23346 Length: 70 Document Type: Term Paper

and, so that brought in a whole new perspective. I had never realized the degree to which they were afraid of us and often feel as though - now the situation becomes very life threatening for them. Because often they don't know how to follow the protocol, how to properly respond to police officers. and, so it just supercharges the whole event." The training] gave us an opportunity to ask

Carl Jung and Personality Carl
Words: 2306 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

One of the most common uses of employment tests is in the area of employment. Many employers use personality tests as a means to assess potential job candidates for their suitability, honesty, and loyalty to a future employer. Individual experience and interpretation can skew answers in such as manner as to render these tests unreliable. For instance, a person who is naturally unassertive might view the actions of an

Appearance and Reality in Shakespeare's
Words: 342 Length: 1 Document Type: Essay

" (III.i.26-8). This is a powerful scene because we begin to think that Hamlet is not what he seems and we cannot figure him out. Another scene where things are not what they seem is when Hamlet is talking to refuses to give Rosencrantz and Guildenstern a direct answer regarding Polonius' body. He says the "body is with the King, but the king is not with the body them a straight

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now