It was felt that the update was required to shore up some of the deficiencies in the Smith Guidance that have emerged since it was published. There were characteristics of the market that it was felt needed to be addressed, in particular the oligopolistic nature, which exposed the market to considerable uncertainty in the event of a failure of one of the Big Four (FRC, 2008). This report remains a work in progress at this time.
Corporate Examples
One company that has been impacted by the changes brought about by the Combined Code is oil services firm Lamprell. The company joined the London Stock Exchange in early 2008 and was immediately required to make changes to its governance structure in order to comply with the Combined Code. The company needed to make several changes to its traditional Board structure. The first was that it needed bring in several new independent non-executive directors. Lamprell also needed to split the roles of chief executive and chairman (Bland, 2008).
In September 2008 Lamprell moved closer to Combined Code compliance by adopting a Policy on External Auditor Independence. The company's policy states that they will not use auditors for non-auditing services unless such services do not conflict with the auditor's independence (Lamprell, 2008). The external auditor must be independent of the company both in fact and in appearance. The policy specifies a wide variety of situations that would be interpreted to compromise auditor independence, and lays out ground rules for hiring auditors. All of these moves were new to the company, a consequence of listing on the LSE.
When the Combined Code was implemented, many UK firms were thus obligated to make changes to their corporate governance programs. One such company was Reed Elsevier, a content provider. This company has a strong Netherlands presence and was forced to comply with the Dutch corporate governance codes as well. Reed Elsevier's board, based in the Netherlands, was presented in 2005 with the need to improve their governance measures, to bring them in line with the Combined Code.
Ultimately, the changes enacted by the company were in compliance with the Combined Code, rather than the Dutch code. However, the company could have opted out of the Combined Code had it so desired, by taking advantage of the Code's "comply or explain" philosophy. The situation is an interesting parallel to the experience of British firms that evacuated the U.S. markets as a result of SOX, in that they could have opted out of the Combined Code if they complied with SOX, but the added expense of the American regulation negated any desire to take such action. Likewise, the Reed Elsevier experience also favoured the Combined Code vs. The Dutch regulations.
Among the changes enacted as a result of compliance with the Combined Code was the creation of an audit committee comprised of all independent non-executives. Another initiative was the establishment of a remuneration committee, again comprise of independent non-directors. The company had become cognizant of the corporate governance issues in the UK, and reacted accordingly.
Future Direction
The Combined Code is subject to frequent evaluation and update. While the results of recent studies and audits have found the Combined Code to function effectively, there is no particular reason why this should be the case. The Combined Code is a system based on principles rather than rules. Thus, enforcement capabilities are limited. Indeed, some recent studies have shown as few as 33% of LSE-listed firms adhere to the Combined Code in its strictest sense.
There are several ways in which the current UK corporate governance model can fall down. These include having a dominant CEO, having an ineffective or incompetent board, deliberate distortions of published financial figures, and employees who exploit their positions for personal gain. These are precisely the scenarios that led to many of the governance problems that provided the impetus for the Combined Code in the first place.
With the Financial Reporting Committee organizing another evaluation of the Combined Code for 2009, it is not expected that any significant changes are going to be made. The FRC is content with the current system, as is the business community in the UK. The currency system has all the right rules on the books, but because they are not mandatory, firms are not obliged to fulfill each and every component of the Combined Code.
However, it is fully reasonable to expect that the impetus for change will come as it has before, at the conclusion of a crisis. The Cadbury Report was precipitated by a crisis, as was the flurry of reports in the early 2000s. The corporate community in the UK prefers their version of corporate governance rules because they appear to be equally effective but without...
However, there has also been hesitation within government to challenge auditors too aggressively. Because accounting scandals have the power to wipe out a major auditing firm, there is considerable sentiment that the existing industry structure needs to be protected, and that all four major firms should be kept from significant scrutiny, lest one of them collapse, ruining competition in the industry. Already the rapid acceleration of audit fees indicates oligopolistic
As noted at the conclusion, these metrics and measures would be qualitatively analyzed by the consultant and quantitative values assigned for each of the questions which would correspond to the five general dimensions under consideration in the short-duration supply chain audit; high attribute examples would be assigned a "1," in this analysis, and a low-attribute example would receive a "7." Table 1 Short-Duration Supply Chain Audit Questions and Corresponding Performance Indicators Question High
audit committee characteristics affect firm performance in Saudi Arabia? What are audit committees? Many studies have been carried out to demonstrate the manner in which audit committees reports affect the overall performance of companies in Saudi Arabia and elsewhere in the world. The interest in conducting audit of accounts in different firms peaked in the early 1960's. Two main approaches of doing accounts investigations have emerged in financial literature. The first
The panels could also be assembled quickly often within a day. Some panels have an in-built wiring in them making the housing construction to be faster. The panelized off-site building technologies could also involve exterior wall of building designed to provide the load bearing structural support, and the panelized building system could be made of light gauge steel, timber, structural insulated panels (SIPs), non-structural or concrete, which could be
Operational issues of IT Department NHS Organization UK The objective of this report is to provide a proposal to reduce the IT operational costs. National Health Service (NHS) is a biggest healthcare service provider in the UK, and the organization delivers both primary and secondary healthcare since its formation. The UK government major objective for forming NHS is to provide the affordable and quality healthcare delivery for all social class in the
International expansion is one of the growth strategies that are embraced by companies in order to improve their bottom-line/profitability. In this paper, we present an elaborate international marketing strategy for Red Bull energy drink. The marketing plan begins with an introduction into the concept of international expansion and marketing and a brief overview of the company. A review of the main conclusions and recommendations is then presented. This is then
Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.
Get Started Now