Verified Document

Evil The Humanity Of Evil Essay

If humans are not the architects of good and evil, then, it is easy to see how a human cannot be wholly good or wholly evil. An architect may be trying to emulate the style of Frank Lloyd Wright, but his or her work will, ultimately, be different from Wright's in some ways. The emulating architect will create some aspects of his or her building that are entirely his or her own. In the same way, a person may be emulating the metaphysical creator of good or evil, but he or she will be flawed in some ways, meaning that he or she is not wholly evil or wholly good. Edgar Allen Poe gives a good example of this in his story "The Black Cat." While the main character commits atrocities to his cat, Pluto, readers are able to find a glimmer of good through his actions before he commits his atrocities. The narrator says, "From my infancy I was noted for the docility and humanity of my disposition" (Poe 597). Thus, while he eventually does evil acts, the narrator is not wholly evil; for at one point in his life, he was good.

The fact that humans cannot be wholly good or wholly evil directly corresponds to the question of forgiveness. Some are of the opinion that certain acts are inexcusable, and cannot be forgiven. Although Govier presents this argument, along with others, in her essay "Forgiveness and the Unforgivable," she also makes the following statement: "To forgive is not to renounce the moral judgment that an action is wrong, because it is only wrong actions that need to be forgiven. Nor is forgiving the same as excusing or condoning. When we forgive, we assume that there is something to forgive - a wrong action for which the offender was responsible. Nor is forgiveness incompatible with punishment" (59-60). Just as the statement regarding evil encompassed the modern conception of evil, Govier's statment provides a rebuttal to the modern misconceptions regarding forgiveness. What this statement suggests is that is always possible to forgive, no matter the state of...

Still Govier points out Golding's description of what constitutes an unforgivable wrong as an antithesis to this argument. Golding argues that "a deed" can be considered unforgivable if the victim is dead, the "deed is utterly inexcusable," and if it can never be appropriately compensated for, as well as forever resented (Govier 63). But even if a deed can be unforgivable, the person who committed that deed can be forgiven, as in the popular Christian belief that "a wrongdoer may have clothed himself in evil, but he should not be regarded as immoral to the core" (Govier 64). Thus, if humans cannot be wholly good or wholly evil it is inappropriate to argue that some humans can remain unforgiven. It is possible to leave a deed unforgiven, but because a person has many deeds that he or she has committed in his life, it is inappropriate to say that person is wholly unforgiven.
Because of the fact that humans cannot be wholly good or evil, nor can they be wholly unforgiven, it is right to recognize forgiveness as the natural approach. Because a person cannot remain wholly unforgiven due to his or her humanity, forgiveness is a tool of the victim, whether this is the primary, secondary, or tertiary victim. What forgiveness does is give the victim peace to deal with the atrocity, as he or she recognizes the wrong that has been done, the punishment, and the future.

Works Cited

Brians, Paul et al. "St. Augustine on the Problem of Evil." Washington State University.

18 December 1998. Resources for the Study of World Civilizations. 18 May 2009.

"Evil and Otherness."

Govier, Trudy. "Forgiveness and the Unforgivable." American Philosophical Quarterly.

36.1 (1999): 59-75.

Poe, Edgar Allen. "The Black Cat."

Webster, Richard. "Freud, Stan, and the serpent." Richard Webster.Net. 2002. 18 May

2009.

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Brians, Paul et al. "St. Augustine on the Problem of Evil." Washington State University.

18 December 1998. Resources for the Study of World Civilizations. 18 May 2009.

"Evil and Otherness."

Govier, Trudy. "Forgiveness and the Unforgivable." American Philosophical Quarterly.
2009. <http://www.richardwebster.net/freudsatanandtheserpent.html>
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Evil What Is the Nature
Words: 2945 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Initially St. Augustine favoured the dualistic view that evil was external and separate from the world and mankind that in evident from the Manichean worldview. However, he was later to reject this strict dualism and taker another view of the nature of evil. This was more Platonic and was based on the writings of Plotinus and Porphyry. This refers to the view that evil is a measure and result of

Humanities Annotated Bibliography Annotated Bibliography Beowulf:...
Words: 1029 Length: 3 Document Type: Annotated Bibliography

Humanities Annotated Bibliography Annotated Bibliography Beowulf: A dual-language edition. (1977). NY: Doubleday. One of the most striking examples of literature to come out of the Dark Ages was Beowulf, created by an anonymous Anglo-Saxon poet and considered by many scholars to be the most important work of its time. There is no official date to the work, but it has been traced to somewhere between the 8th and the early 11th Century.

Evil for Christian Theologians, One
Words: 1250 Length: 4 Document Type: Journal

"I'm not religious, I'm spiritual." Conversely other people state that they dislike the formality of religion, of beliefs and practices, but do believe in God and in some sense of 'higher truth.' This confusion might be best addressed by doing away with the category of religion altogether -- religion is whatever a society defines it to be, and the term has grown so meaningless, people even speak of making golf

Evil Is Divided Into Two
Words: 924 Length: 3 Document Type: Book Review

4. How does Luther and Calvin's view of moral evil differ from that of Catholicism? The classical Christian approach to the dilemma of moral evil has been that people are abusing the freedom of choice given to them by their creator. With free will and the ability to choose between good and evil actions, people who exercise the wrong choices can create moral evil, which impacts others. The Catholic Church essentially

Evil Is Ambiguous As It
Words: 1970 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

God would have never created human beings if everyone was to be perfect. There are certain problems with the view that there is evil in the world despite the presence of an almighty God who is omnipotent and omniscient. Critics believe that evil should not exist if God is omnipotent and omniscient. They believe that there is evil in this world because God doesn't exist. There is no to govern

Humanity Is That of People Who Are
Words: 654 Length: 2 Document Type: Book Report

humanity is that of people who are shallow and empty. So many people out there face the idea of not fitting in and express fear about going against the grain. Here, Frankenstein was born a freak of nature, something people are instantly repulsed by. It would not matter if he were a good and kind person, because society would not view him as a person. He is a monster. Monsters

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now