Verified Document

Evidence-Based Models Case Study

Evidence-Based Models for Substance Abuse Treatment in the Criminal Justice System The United States currently incarcerates a higher percentage of its citizens than any other industrialized nation in the world. A majority of Americans who are incarcerated were taking drugs or drinking alcohol, or both, during the commission of their crimes, or were actively engaged in substance-abusing behaviors that resulted in their involvement with the criminal justice system. The costs that are associated with incarcerating these millions of convicts each year are staggering, making the need for cost-effective interventions that can help divert substance-abusing nonviolent offenders from the penal system into other, less expensive community-based alternatives. Likewise, from a strictly pragmatic perspective, treating existing substance abuse among prison populations using methods with proven efficacy just makes good business sense. To this end, this paper compares and contrasts two evidence-based substance abuse treatment models that have demonstrated efficacy in the criminal justice system. A discussion concerning how this model best fits in a given agency with respect to economic, human resource, therapist expertise, and other relevant factors is followed by a summary of the research and important findings in the conclusion.

Review and Discussion

Today, there are almost eight million Americans in various correctional systems, and these populations have inordinately high rates of chronic medical and mental health issues, infections, sexually transmitted diseases, as well as substantial substance abuse disorders (Gondles, 2010). According to Grella, Hser, Teruya and Evans (2005), there has been a growing consensus among healthcare providers in recent years concerning the need to improve the quality and provide for better accountability by using evidence-based treatment interventions for substance abuse problems. In this regard, Gondles emphasizes that the criminal justice system has "a responsibility to society and to offenders to continue developing and evaluating efficient, effective, and cost-conscience methods of delivering valid, evidence-based treatment and programs" (2010, p. 6). In addition,...

Parts of this document are hidden

View Full Document
svg-one

6).
Some salient examples of efforts by the healthcare community to develop such guidelines include:

1. The principles of drug abuse treatment developed by the National Institute on Drug Abuse (NIDA) identify a core set of empirically based interventions that can be used to guide clinical practice (Grella et al., 2005, p. 469).

2. Likewise, Hon (2003) reports that, "The active ingredients of effective treatment for alcohol problems have been distilled from several generations of research into the treatment of alcohol abuse and dependence" (2003, p. 2).

3. Finally, findings from treatment effectiveness research have provided the foundation for a set of clinical practice guidelines, including the American Society of Addiction Medicine's Principles of Addiction Medicine (Grella et al., 2005, p. 470).

Clearly, then, the use of evidence-based treatment regimens for substance abusing populations in general and prison populations in particular represents a timely and valuable enterprise, and two such evidence-based treatment regimens that have demonstrated efficacy with substance-abusing behaviors, ancillary pharmacological support and monitoring programs, are described further below.

Ancillary Pharmacological Support

Clinical studies have shown time and again that treatment regimens for substance abuse are more effective when used in conjunction with pharmacological support. These are especially important issues with respect to prison populations where the transition back into society may require ongoing treatment and monitoring. Prison populations in particular can benefit from treatment programs using medications such as methadone for alcoholism and buprenorphine for heroin addiction (Principles of Drug Abuse Treatment for Criminal Justice Populations, 2011). According to Byrne, Lander and Ferris (2009), "Buprenorphine/naloxone is an evidence-based pharmacological treatment that offers a new and different option for treatment of…

Sources used in this document:
References

Byrne, M.H., Lander, L. & Ferris, M. (2009). The changing face of opioid addiction:

Prescription pain pill dependence and treatment. Health and Social Work, 34(1), 53-55.

Gondles, E.F. (2010, October). Investing in healthy communities. Corrections Today, 71(5), 6.

Grella, C.E., Hser, Y-I, Teruya, C. & Evans, E. (2005). How can research-based findings be used to improve practice? Perspectives from participants in a statewide outcomes monitoring study. Journal of Drug Issues, 35(3), 469-470.
on Drug Abuse. Retrieved from http://www.nida.nih.gov/podat_cj/principles/.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Methadone and Methadone Clinics Methadone
Words: 378 Length: 1 Document Type: Essay

But despite this medicinal veneer, methadone is "increasingly being abused by recreational drug users and is causing an alarming increase in overdoses and deaths" (Belluck 2003). Heroin and prescription opium abusers are turning to methadone often with alcohol or other drugs. They buy the drug illegally on the street -- often it is sold by addicts who have been able to obtain a large supply, though fair or foul means.

Methadone Treatment for Heroin Addiction
Words: 671 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Cons: Methadone use has a number of side-effects such as constipation, sweating, loss of libido, sleep disturbance, weight gain, dental problems, vomiting, and serious bowel problems. While most of the side-effects are reduced or managed by controlled prescription, they can occasionally be severe enough to affect a person's health sufficiently for him to discontinue treatment (Withers, 1999) One of the 'advantages' of methadone, i.e., it blocks the euphoric high of heroin can

Addiction Methadone Maintenace Methadone Maintenance Methadone Maintenance...
Words: 1417 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

Addiction Methadone Maintenace Methadone Methadone Maintenance Methadone maintenance is essentially the use of methadone over a period of time for the treatment of individuals who are addicted to opioid drugs such as heroin. In more formal terms the central aim of methadone maintenance is defined as follows: "Methadone maintenance treatment (MMT) can help injection drug users (IDUs) reduce or stop injecting and return to productive lives" (METHADONE MAINTENANCE TREATMENT, 2002) There is still however a

Contingency Management Alcohol & Marijuana
Words: 11354 Length: 41 Document Type: Term Paper

" (1995) The authors state: "The amphetamines occasioned dose-related increases in d- amphetamine-appropriate responding, whereas hydromorphone did not. Amphetamines also occasioned dose-related increases in reports of the drug being most like "speed," whereas hydromorphone did not. However, both amphetamines and hydromorphone occasioned dose-related increases in reports of drug liking and in three scales of the ARCI. Thus, some self-report measures were well correlated with responding on the drug-appropriate lever and some

Drug Use According to Pam
Words: 392 Length: 1 Document Type: Term Paper

Drug users should continue to receive it, because it goes a long way towards curbing the greater problem created by the primary addiction. I believe that methadone is very useful in terms of helping drug users to rehabilitate. People who make mistakes in their lives should be helped to remedy these in the best way possible, and I believe that methadone is a good tool to accomplish this. The

Drug Use Needle Exchange Program
Words: 644 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

S. Government Publication. Methadone is an opioid that is often used as an analgesic for purposes of treating such drug addictions as heroine. It has especially been found to be successful at treating heroin withdrawal symptoms and thus originally was popular on the street before also becoming a recognized treatment used in hospitals. A study lead by Vincent Dole of Rockefeller University discovered that drug addiction was a disorder and thus

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now