Verified Document

Evidence-Based Models Case Study

Evidence-Based Models for Substance Abuse Treatment in the Criminal Justice System The United States currently incarcerates a higher percentage of its citizens than any other industrialized nation in the world. A majority of Americans who are incarcerated were taking drugs or drinking alcohol, or both, during the commission of their crimes, or were actively engaged in substance-abusing behaviors that resulted in their involvement with the criminal justice system. The costs that are associated with incarcerating these millions of convicts each year are staggering, making the need for cost-effective interventions that can help divert substance-abusing nonviolent offenders from the penal system into other, less expensive community-based alternatives. Likewise, from a strictly pragmatic perspective, treating existing substance abuse among prison populations using methods with proven efficacy just makes good business sense. To this end, this paper compares and contrasts two evidence-based substance abuse treatment models that have demonstrated efficacy in the criminal justice system. A discussion concerning how this model best fits in a given agency with respect to economic, human resource, therapist expertise, and other relevant factors is followed by a summary of the research and important findings in the conclusion.

Review and Discussion

Today, there are almost eight million Americans in various correctional systems, and these populations have inordinately high rates of chronic medical and mental health issues, infections, sexually transmitted diseases, as well as substantial substance abuse disorders (Gondles, 2010). According to Grella, Hser, Teruya and Evans (2005), there has been a growing consensus among healthcare providers in recent years concerning the need to improve the quality and provide for better accountability by using evidence-based treatment interventions for substance abuse problems. In this regard, Gondles emphasizes that the criminal justice system has "a responsibility to society and to offenders to continue developing and evaluating efficient, effective, and cost-conscience methods of delivering valid, evidence-based treatment and programs" (2010, p. 6). In addition,...

6).
Some salient examples of efforts by the healthcare community to develop such guidelines include:

1. The principles of drug abuse treatment developed by the National Institute on Drug Abuse (NIDA) identify a core set of empirically based interventions that can be used to guide clinical practice (Grella et al., 2005, p. 469).

2. Likewise, Hon (2003) reports that, "The active ingredients of effective treatment for alcohol problems have been distilled from several generations of research into the treatment of alcohol abuse and dependence" (2003, p. 2).

3. Finally, findings from treatment effectiveness research have provided the foundation for a set of clinical practice guidelines, including the American Society of Addiction Medicine's Principles of Addiction Medicine (Grella et al., 2005, p. 470).

Clearly, then, the use of evidence-based treatment regimens for substance abusing populations in general and prison populations in particular represents a timely and valuable enterprise, and two such evidence-based treatment regimens that have demonstrated efficacy with substance-abusing behaviors, ancillary pharmacological support and monitoring programs, are described further below.

Ancillary Pharmacological Support

Clinical studies have shown time and again that treatment regimens for substance abuse are more effective when used in conjunction with pharmacological support. These are especially important issues with respect to prison populations where the transition back into society may require ongoing treatment and monitoring. Prison populations in particular can benefit from treatment programs using medications such as methadone for alcoholism and buprenorphine for heroin addiction (Principles of Drug Abuse Treatment for Criminal Justice Populations, 2011). According to Byrne, Lander and Ferris (2009), "Buprenorphine/naloxone is an evidence-based pharmacological treatment that offers a new and different option for treatment of…

Sources used in this document:
References

Byrne, M.H., Lander, L. & Ferris, M. (2009). The changing face of opioid addiction:

Prescription pain pill dependence and treatment. Health and Social Work, 34(1), 53-55.

Gondles, E.F. (2010, October). Investing in healthy communities. Corrections Today, 71(5), 6.

Grella, C.E., Hser, Y-I, Teruya, C. & Evans, E. (2005). How can research-based findings be used to improve practice? Perspectives from participants in a statewide outcomes monitoring study. Journal of Drug Issues, 35(3), 469-470.
on Drug Abuse. Retrieved from http://www.nida.nih.gov/podat_cj/principles/.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Evidence-Based Models
Words: 1844 Length: 5 Document Type: Research Paper

Evidence-Based Models While there is a debate regarding the criminalization that is being done to people just because they consume drugs, as of now the whole global community is against the offenders and addicts and wants them reformed or locked away. The reason is that there is a demonstrated relationship between drug abuse and crime, and the use of drugs and the peddling of the drugs have been shown to be

Evidence-Based Practice Model
Words: 964 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

EBP Evidence-based practice model EBP project issue: Obesity "The prevalence of obesity (BMI > 30) has been increasing; currently; at least 27% of the adult population is obese" (McTigue 2003: vii). Despite being one of the most pervasive health problems in modernity, there is relatively little information on obesity available in the annals of evidence-based medicine. This may be due to the fact that obesity is such a complex and multifactorial disease, without

Evidence-Based Counseling: Implications Counseling Practice, Preparation,...
Words: 1879 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Evidence-Based Counseling: Implications Counseling Practice, Preparation, Professionalism. ERIC Digest. Hauenstein, E.J. (2008). Building rural mental health system: From de facto system quality care.ID Review the Sexton article and make a case for the utilization of EBTs in counseling. According to Thomas L. Sexton's article "Evidence-based counseling: Implications for counseling practice, preparation, and professionalism," the theoretical basis of the counseling profession emerged from the academic disciplines of psychoanalysis and social work, both of

Evidence-Based Group Work How Can I Increase
Words: 1002 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Evidence-Based Group Work How can I increase attendance of a support group for at-risk teenage Latino students in a school setting? Search for Evidence In order to search for evidence in increasing attendance of a support group for Latino students in a school setting, I went to PubMed as my initial search engine. I chose PubMed because I have found it to be a great starting place for health-care research. Not only does

Evidenced-Based Practice - Environment There Are Perhaps
Words: 1054 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Evidenced-Based Practice - Environment There are perhaps few environments and professions within which change is both as important and as difficult as it is within health care. While there are many barriers to the change process, there are at least an equal amount of drivers that indicate the necessity for change. In evidence-based practice, nursing practitioners, administration personnel, management personnel, and all involved in the health care profession need to form

Evidence-Based Practice EBP Is the Term That
Words: 895 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Evidence-based practice (EBP) is the term that refers to the need for nursing to be based on research that has been conducted in the most thorough scientific manner, consistently tested, rigorously proved, and only then published by peer-refereed academic journals. Evidence-based nursing is popular in nursing since it joins science with practice and bases nursing on a more critical scientific basis. It puts the nurse, so to speak, in the driver's

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now