Verified Document

Euthyphro, Socrates Euthyphro Discuss Concept Piety/Holiness. This Essay

¶ … Euthyphro, Socrates Euthyphro discuss concept piety/Holiness. This essay test ability recognize engag The principle tenet discussed in the Socratic Dialogue Euthyphro, which centers on a discussion between Euthyphro and the great Greek philosopher, is piety or holiness. This topic emerges in the dialogue because it is of immense importance to the future of both men. They meet on the porch of King Archon, and quickly ascertain that each is there for a legal trial. Socrates discloses the fact that he has been charged with corrupting the youth principally because his accuser believes he is slandering the gods by disavowing their piety or by creating new ones (which is disrespectful to the established ones). Euthyphro is there to bring his father up on charges of murder. Since he professes to be extremely well versed in the conception of piety and holiness, Socrates asks him to discuss this topic (Plato, 380 B.C.E.). Socrates does so in order to become more familiar with the allegations that he is being charged with so that he will either learn how to successfully refute those allegations or blame them upon his teacher (of piety) -- Euthyphro. Therefore, the Greek philosopher asks the young man to define the term as a basic starting point in order to familiarize him with public perception of the concept.

To his credit, Euthyphro is able to disseminate three definitions before he is pressed for time and has to leave. By utilizing the Socratic method of questioning,...

The first that Euthyphro offers is that piety is simply punishing the wicked, and that failing to punish the wicked is impious. Socrates is able to show him the faulty nature of this particular definition by telling Euthyphro that the definition is too narrow. The philosopher points out that what Euthyphro initially offers as a definition is merely an example of an act of piety, and alludes to the fact that there can be several more such acts that are different from that one. Therefore, Socrates asks for an immutable, comprehensive definition, and not a mere example. Euthyphro's second definition is that which is dear to the Gods is pious and holy, and that which maligned by them is impious. Socrates takes great pains to demonstrate to Euthyphro that the gods themselves were notorious for bickering and arguing with one another. His point is that it is rare for these deities to have a uniformed opinion about some matter -- particularly one in which they feel strongly about something -- and that therefore what one God holds as dear is actually disliked by another. In essence, he argues that this particular definition is too subjective to form a unified definition. Finally, Euthyphro posits the viewpoint that piety is that which the gods are able to form a consensus opinion about which they loved, and that impiety is simply that which they can uniformly dislike. Socrates wastes little time in thoroughly confusing the young man with philosophical…

Sources used in this document:
References

Plato. (380 B.C.E.) Euthyphro. www.classics.mit.edu. Retrieved from http://classics.mit.edu/Plato/euthyfro.html

Rahimi, S. (2008). "Swinburne on the Euthyphro dilemma. Can supervenience save him?" Forum Philosophicum 13: 17-29.

Sharpe, M. (2010). "Uncovering Euthyphro's treasure: reading Plato's Euthyphro with Lacan. Helios. 37 (1): 23-48.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Euthyphro, Socrates Euthyphro Discuss Concept Piety/Holiness. This...
Words: 1042 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Euthyphro, Socrates Euthyphro discuss concept piety/Holiness. This essay test ability recognize engag The concept of holiness is central to the Platonic dialogue that takes place between Euthyphro and Socrates in Euthyphro. This topic is of immense interest to both of the aforementioned participants due to the fact that they are both headed for a legal trial. Socrates has been brought up on trial for charges that he is corrupting the

Holiness in Euthyphro Holiness in "Euthyphro" in
Words: 992 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Holiness in Euthyphro Holiness in "Euthyphro" In Plato's Euthyphro, the concept of holiness emerges in the dialogue when the title character Euthyphro tells the philosopher Socrates of his intention to prosecute his father. Euthyphro is convinced of his father's guilt and thus sees himself as virtuous for valuing justice over familial respect. Because Socrates is going to court to defend himself against his accusers, who claim that his teachings corrupt the Athenian

Socrates the Context for This
Words: 1475 Length: 5 Document Type: Thesis

Socrates believed that defining which of the actions taken by man are good, and which are not, provides man with the definition of piety and impiety. Aristotle also felt that "every action and choice, seem to aim at some good; the good, therefore, has been well defined as that at which all things aim."(Aristotle, 1094a) Socrates also presents a defense for his actions by asking Euthyphro whether the holy acts

Euthyphro What Is Socrates' Definition of Piety
Words: 1362 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Euthyphro What is Socrates' definition of piety in the Euthyphro? The Socratic dialogue of the Euthyphro is initiated by the case of a young man who has brought charges against his father for murder. The father, hearing that a slave on his property was himself accused of murdering another man, bound the accused slave and threw him in a ditch, causing the man to die from overexposure. In Athens, there was no

Euthyphro and Piety an Analysis of Euthyphro
Words: 1024 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Euthyphro and Piety An Analysis of Euthyphro with an Alternative Definition of Piety Euthyphro gives three definitions of piety which fail to satisfy Socrates. Socrates' goal in this dialogue is to reveal the shallowness of Euythyphro's argument and obtain a better understanding of truth. In other words, Socrates' objective is the same as always: To point out, as Rudebusch (1999) states, "that one who is aware of one's ignorance is in a

The Old World Concepts of Virtue Versus the Modern
Words: 1666 Length: 6 Document Type: Essay

Platos views on education are seldom accepted today, while Dewys are the philosophical foundation for much of what goes on in schools. Explain why this is the case. Dewey's approach towards education is based on the scientific method that grew out of the Renaissance and the Age of Enlightenment. It, in effect, builds on the theory of William of Occam, who denied the existence of universals (Weaver, 1984). Thus, Dewey and

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now