Verified Document

European Security And Defence Identity Term Paper

e. merger-mania of U.S. defense firms. But there are three other factors pushing the Europeans for taking concrete measures for pursuing the ESDI. The measures are must to overcome the delays and constraints the Union experiences. The first of the blockade is with reference to the defense spending of European countries. The new NATO Secretary-General estimated that, 'total military spending of European countries is around 60% of the U.S. total, and yields only 10% of the capabilities'. Secondly, European firms are becoming increasingly angry that the U.S. while procuring new weapons and equipment refuses to "buy European military products." Thirdly, European governments are not satisfied with U.S. restrictions 'on the transfer of technology even though the Europeans are investing money in the development of new U.S. built weapons such as the Joint Strike Fighter' (Military Journal: Monitor).

The development of an independent, strong and combined European military force able to act on its own is overdue. 'Demographically, Europeans are below the basic population replacement rate, and economics argue for combinations that surmount the old roadblocks created by nationalism and the heavy hand of the United States' (Jolyon Howorth, European Defense and the Changing Politics of the European Union). Presently the European countries are under no major threat of aggression or terrorist attacks; therefore 'Europe has the opportunity to find its own identity in a European security system that makes it an independent, worthy partner with the U.S. In future diplomatic and military endeavors. ESDI and NATO can happily co-exist. NATO will remain, but with a stronger Europe the call on North American resources will not be as frequent or as severe' (Jolyon Howorth, European Defense and the Changing Politics of the European Union).

Critics have highlighted another problem with reference to the adoption of ESDI is the issue of concern is the military engagements of Turkey and America, the problem with Turkey includes both ESDP and the existence of the EU. The possibility of finding political cum diplomatic agreement between Ankara and Athens is not practical, though EU hinted of adopting flexibility at Seville European Council in June 2002. 'Relations with the U.S.A. are at the...

Although growing numbers of Americans are disillusioned with ESDI, there remains a huge range of opinion within the U.S. about the project, including an important constituency which is favorably disposed' (Jolyon Howorth, European Defense and the Changing Politics of the European Union). The policy with reference to ESDI is likely to lose some supports with the circle of United States government; however European statesmen are much composed about this. 'Even collectively, they do not amount to a case against the development of ESDI, but rather constitute so many hurdles whose successful clearance will enormously strengthen it. Two more serious problems which are often cited as evidence that ESDI is unlikely to work are finances and leadership' (Military Journal: Monitor).
The major challenge experienced by European Union in moving beyond the consensus of joint military forces is, firstly to establish such new institutions that will allow the member states collectively to address issues of security and defense efficiently and expeditiously. Secondly, the European Union ought to establish large military capacity with new approaches towards budgeting and procurement. Thirdly, the union has to ensure that military progress is conducted with support of NATO; the union should avoid such happening that might push it to experience objections from NATO and from United States. These challenges are undoubtedly tedious, and needs to be handled diplomatically.

References

Lawrence Freedman, "The Coming War on Terrorism" in Lawrence Freedman, ed., Super terrorism (Oxford: Blackwell, 2002).

Julian Lindley-French, Terms of Engagement. The paradox of American power and the trans-Atlantic dilemma post-11 September (Paris: EU-ISS, 2002)

Gordon Adams, "Fortress America in a changing trans-Atlantic defense market," in Burkard Schmitt, ed., Between Cooperation and Competition: The Trans-Atlantic Defense Market (Paris, WEU-ISS, 2001)

George Parker, "France and UK call for new force at top of EU," Financial Times, 15 May 2002.

International Institute for Strategic Studies, London, "The European Rapid Reaction Force," The Military Balance 2001-2002 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2001).

Sources used in this document:
References

Lawrence Freedman, "The Coming War on Terrorism" in Lawrence Freedman, ed., Super terrorism (Oxford: Blackwell, 2002).

Julian Lindley-French, Terms of Engagement. The paradox of American power and the trans-Atlantic dilemma post-11 September (Paris: EU-ISS, 2002)

Gordon Adams, "Fortress America in a changing trans-Atlantic defense market," in Burkard Schmitt, ed., Between Cooperation and Competition: The Trans-Atlantic Defense Market (Paris, WEU-ISS, 2001)

George Parker, "France and UK call for new force at top of EU," Financial Times, 15 May 2002.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Common European Security and Defense Policy Development and Prospects...
Words: 5762 Length: 20 Document Type: Term Paper

European Security and Defense Policy: Development and Prospects United States Attitudes toward European Defense The Background to the Dilemma: In December of 1991, the Soviet Union - Ronald Reagan's "Evil Empire" - ceased to exist. Communism was dead. The Cold War over. Long live freedom and democracy! The Union of Soviet Socialist Republics was replaced by a weak and impoverished federation of fifteen republics. America stood alone. She had become - in

European Union and Turkey There
Words: 2785 Length: 8 Document Type: Term Paper

S. have two different approaches. While the EU represents the "soft power" the United States is the proponent of the "hard power" (Kagan, 2003). However, it is considered that the issue of soft power is representative for the way in which states would later on develop their foreign policy and their strategic coordinates. However, in the case of Iraq and Iran it can be said that the current hard power

European Union's Holistic Security Policy in One
Words: 1449 Length: 4 Document Type: Term Paper

European Union's Holistic Security Policy in One of Its Neighboring Regions The objective of this study is to critique the European Union's 'holistic security policy' in its neighboring region or that of Eastern Europe, Ukraine, Russian and Belarus and to analyze this region from different perspectives including economic, political, and traditional military power. The European Security Strategy is based upon "a comprehensive or holistic approach to security" and states that

European Union's Common Foreign and
Words: 3705 Length: 13 Document Type: Term Paper

To achieve these various purposes, NATO embarked on a series of interlocking efforts during the 1990s that were intended to provide some aspect of an overall concept of security. A series of initiatives resulted in NATO accepting new members with the possibility of still further additions in the future, crafted the Partnership for Peace and created the Euro-Atlantic Partnership Council; entered into a Founding Act with Russia and a Charter

European Union Member States Relations With Their Overseas Territories...
Words: 17554 Length: 50 Document Type: Thesis

political framework of EU and OCT European Union (EU) and Overseas Countries and Territories (OCTs) are in association with each other via a system which is based on the provisions of part IV of the Treaty on the Functioning of the EU (TFEU), consisting of detailed rules and measures which are laid down in the document issued on 27th November 2001 title Oversees Association Decision. The expiry date of this

Security Issues of Online Communities
Words: 15576 Length: 60 Document Type: Term Paper

This researcher rejects the existence of online communities because computer mediated group discussions cannot possibly meet this definition. Weinreich's view is that anyone with even a basic knowledge of sociology understands that information exchange in no way constitutes a community. For a cyber-place with an associated computer mediated group to be labeled as a virtual settlement it is necessary for it to meet a minimum set of conditions. These are:

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now