Verified Document

Ethics Scenario Essay

Ethics Scenario Public health ethics relates to the ethics as it relates to an entire population, in contrast to medical ethics, which relates more to the rights of individuals. Rosenau and Roemer (2013) note that there are often ethical conflicts that emerge when individual rights conflict with the greater good. They highlight the overarching public health principles, that provision of care is regardless of external factors, that there should be equity in the distribution of resources, and that there should be respect for human rights. The case of the burn patient is primarily regarding the human rights dimension.

The human rights dimension results in an ethical dilemma here for a couple of reasons. The first is that the individual in this instance has rights -- or the family members have rights -- and there is question as to whether those rights were respected. The outcome might have been the same for the burn victim, but the rights are embedded in the process, not the outcome. Indeed, the fourth-year resident violated the basic rights of the victim to make his own decisions -- or for his family to make those decisions -- about his life and how it should end. There is an assumption embedded in medical ethics that conduct should be in accordance with certain imperatives, and this Kantian approach to ethics does not allow for the rights of the individual to be disrespected in this manner.

The decision to give the patient a lethal injection does not appear to be rooted in a decision about scarce resources, or about equitable access...

If there was a rationing issue, the case could be more complex, but it does not appear that rationing was involved, so the issue is simply one of individual rights.
In this situation, the law leaves little room for ethical interpretation. The resident may have felt that he acted in the spirit of not causing harm, in that he was reducing the suffering of the patient, but that is not his decision to make in this instance. There is almost no likelihood that the resident would have had legal sanction to end the patient's life, even if there was universal agreement that the patient is about to die. The patient or the family of the patient has the right to make that decision. Indeed, they may have religious beliefs on the subject, and the resident's actions would not only be against the law, and against the ethical standard of respecting the independence of the patient, but also would be culturally insensitive as well.

Rosenau and Roemer (2013) provide an outline of mechanisms for resolving the dilemma. At this point, the dilemma is whether or not to pursue further investigation into the matter. The law does not provide the opportunity for ethical decision making here -- killing a patient is against the law and there should be an investigation into the circumstances surrounding the death of this patient. Formal mechanisms can be used to help investigate this case, but there is no need for a formal mechanism for resolving…

Sources used in this document:
References

Curtis, J. & Vincent, J. (2010). Ethics and end-of-life care for adults in the intensive care unit. Lancet. Vol. 375 (2010) 1347-53.

Rosenau, P. & Roemer, R. (2013). Chapter 15: Ethical issues in public health and health services. Introduction to Health Services In possession of the author.

Sprung, C., Cohen, S., Sjokvist, P., Baras, M., Bulow, H., Hovilehto, S., Ledoux, D., Lippert, A., Maia, P., Phelan, D., Schobersberger, W., Wennberg, E. & Woodcock, T. (2003). End-of-life practices in European intensive care units. Journal of the American Medical Association. Vol. 290 (6) 790-797.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Business Ethics Scenario -- Expansion
Words: 792 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

In that regard, even the protections available in more sophisticated societies cannot prevent major governmental corruption, exploitation, or unethical business practices in the private sector. Therefore, the prospect of expanding our company presence to Kava does not obligate us to become more directly involved in Kava government or politics, but it does impose an obligation on our part to encourage the most beneficial organizational values and practices at every level.

Ethics Awareness Inventory the Individual Ethics Awareness
Words: 1067 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Ethics Awareness Inventory The Individual Ethics Awareness Inventory examines which of four different components is the most critical in an individual's ethical position: character, obligation, results, and equity (CORE). When a person makes a decision or analyzes a scenario, their personal ethical perspective helps determine how they approach the issue. When character is the most important issue, the person's ethical perspective s based upon what it is good to be, rather

Ethics in the Workplace
Words: 2655 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Ethics in the Workplace Organizational ethics is an area that is gaining increased importance in formal professional education. Ethics are moral rules that guide the behavior and conduct of an individual. Since ethics are shaped by personal factors like religion, family, society, law and culture, it is unlikely that two people share the same ethical standards or viewpoints (Weiss 2008, p. 116). This frequently gives rise to ethical conflicts or internal

Ethics Journal in Goldman, Wall Street, and
Words: 870 Length: 3 Document Type: Essay

Ethics Journal In Goldman, Wall Street, and a culture crack up, Ken Makovsky describes an ethical issue in which a mid-level banker at Goldman Sachs, Greg Smith, alleged that the firm relegated client needs to its search for quick profits. What he describes is more behavior that reaffirms the idea of a culture of greed permeating Goldman Sachs prior to the financial meltdown. While Goldman had been the subject of a

Ethics in For-Profit and Not-for-Profit Companies
Words: 1058 Length: 3 Document Type: Annotated Bibliography

Ethics in for-Profit and Not-for-Profit Companies *****************this assignment*********** Annotated Bibliography Annotated bibliography: Ethics in for-profit and not-for profit companies Barkemeyer, R., Holt, D., Figge, F., & Napolitano, G. (2010). A longitudinal and contextual analysis of media representation of business ethics. European Business Review, 22(4), 377-396. This article is a survey of the contemporary media's representation of business ethics, encompassing a meta-analysis of 62 international newspapers. Particularly in the U.S., the emphasis was upon 'hot' scandals

Ethics in an Organization Ethics Are the
Words: 1738 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Ethics in an Organization Ethics are the values and principles that a person utilizes in order to rule his actions and choices. In an association, a code of ethics is a set of moralities that direct the organization in its programs, rules and choices for the corporate. The ethical attitude an association uses to conduct commerce can affect the standing, efficiency and also what is considered to be the bottom line

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now