Verified Document

Ethics: Green's Dilemma Identifying Logical Fallacies Fallacy Term Paper

¶ … Ethics: Green's Dilemma Identifying Logical Fallacies

Fallacy 1: Circular Definition (The definition includes the term being defined as a part of the definition, it is assumed because something is a rule it must be obeyed without saying why)

"I believe that all rules should be strictly obeyed," the officer told himself.

Fallacy 2: Conflicting Conditions (The definition is self-contradictory)

"But this is a special circumstance. Don't all rules have exceptions?

Fallacy 3: Argument from emotion. (No logic, just emotion.)

Besides, I really do love Greek food!"

Fallacy 4: Straw man. (Attacking the person, not the argument.)

"We can't have officers accepting free meals, you dumb rookie!

Fallacy 5: Slippery slope. (Assumes unconnected chain of causal events.)

Free meals lead to cash bribes and corruption. Eventually people will be asking you to get them illegal drugs!

Fallacy 6: Post hoc. (The conclusion doesn't follow from the evidence.)

Besides, the year we started banning free meals, the city's car thefts went down by 20%! We can't risk messing with success like that.

Fallacy 7: Appeal to Authority (When the authority is not an expert in the field)

Anyway, I read that Martha Stewart was against free meals for cops. That clinches it for me!

Fallacy 8: Hasty Generalization: (The sample is too small to support an inductive generalization about a population_

This is the third time I've had a restaurant owner trying to get one of my officers to break a rule. I guess restaurant owners just don't have any respect for rules and policies.

Fallacy 9: Appeal to Force (The reader is persuaded to agree by force.)

"Either drop this matter and agree with my decision

Fallacy 10 and 11: Consequences (The reader is warned of unacceptable consequences...

Or you aren't being a good cop."
Fallacy 12: Attacking the Person: (The person's character is attacked and the person's circumstances are noted, not the argument and the person making the attack does not practice what is preached.)

Terrance replied, "You're just prejudiced against Greek people! Anyway, I heard that you got into trouble once for using excessive force on a suspect. Who are you to lecture me about ethics?

Fallacy 13: Popularity/Bandwagon fallacy: (Proposition is argued to be true because it is widely held to be true.)

One recent survey of officers found that 75% of us believe we are entitled to free or discounted meals. That many people can't be wrong.

Fallacy 14: Argument From Ignorance: (Because something is not known to be true, it is assumed to be false.)

I don't care what all the so-called experts in law enforcement ethics say -- there's nothing wrong with an officer accepting free meals!

Fallacy 15: Irrelevant Conclusion: (An argument in defense of one conclusion instead proves a different conclusion.)

Fallacy 16: Post hoc, ergo: (False conclusion -- just because underpaid doesn't mean free food is the solution.)

We're underpaid and under-appreciated!

Fallacy 17: Argument from authority (Assumes must have experience to 'understand')

People on the outside can't possibly understand all that we go through as police officers.

Ethics model: Central decision to be made: What should Officer Green do about Mrs. Athens' offer -- how to balance community policing with positive community relations?

Evaluate the Problem

The problem is that the officer in question wishes to disobey reasonable police department protocol regarding accepting free gifts. Accepting free gifts from a Greek owner…

Sources used in this document:
Works Cited

Downes, Steven. "Logical Fallacies." 16 Aug 1996.

http://www.datanation.com/fallacies/index.htm

Shef, A.C. "Rawls' contractarianism in A Theory of Justice." 1997. http://www.shef.ac.uk/~pip97pjc/essweb1.htm

"Utilitarianism." The Free Dictionary. com. 2004
http://encyclopedia.thefreedictionary.com/Utilitarism
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Law Enforcement: Ethics, Stigmas, and
Words: 1528 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Police officers need to understand that there exists a balance between security and the individual's freedom (Banks, 2009). Officers are also susceptible to corruption, and therefore need to understand that the causes of corruption are often identified and combated through an understanding of and respect for the justice system that is currently in place. Police officers also need to be trained properly, with a foundation in the same concepts

Ethics in Law Enforcement
Words: 2406 Length: 8 Document Type: Essay

Ethics in Law Enforcement Ethics are what almost anyone would define as a person's determination between what is good or bad, or more accurately what is right or wrong. Although many of these attitudes can be a product of parenting or other factors in one's maturing environment, ethical decisions could also be a product of environmental factors that are outside of the control of individuals. It is difficult to determine where

Vagueness of Law Enforcement Ethics Code
Words: 669 Length: 2 Document Type: Essay

Law Enforcement Code of Ethics" is deliberately written to be vague. The reason for this is obvious. There are plenty of practices employed by law enforcement on a daily basis that are widespread and are not actually illegal, but that would not be considered ethical even under the most sloppily-enunciated and lax ethical code. Everyone in law enforcement knows this fact, as does every defense attorney; pretty much everyone

Law and Ethics in the Business Environment
Words: 1681 Length: 5 Document Type: Term Paper

Law and Ethics in the Business Environment RIGHT FROM WRONG Business Ethics and the Law Business law fixes the minimum standards of behavior for businesses (Bramble, 2013). Enforcing these laws generally consists of fines involved in the exercise of trade and commerce. Criminal accountabilities must be proven in the appropriate court of law through evidence. Even when found culpable, a business can only be fined as a penalty. But business ethics exceeds simple

Ethics in Law Enforcement "Sometimes Police Officers
Words: 1373 Length: 4 Document Type: Essay

Ethics in Law Enforcement "Sometimes [police officers] may, and sometimes may not, lie when conducting custodial interrogations. Investigative and interrogatory lying are each justified on utilitarian crime control grounds. Police are never supposed to lie as witnesses in the courtroom, although they may lie for utilitarian reasons similar to those permitting deception & #8230;" (Skolnick, et al., 1992) Is it ethical for law enforcement officers to use deception during the interrogation process?

Ethics in Law Enforcement Every Individual Dreams
Words: 1827 Length: 5 Document Type: Essay

Ethics in Law Enforcement Every individual dreams of living an ideal life filled with peace, prosperity, love and comforts. Many a time's people get money but no peace of mind and often they have incomparable mental solace without the wealth. Scholars like Aristotle, Plato and Socrates believed that an ideal life did not exist but a successful; peace filled life was only possible with adherence to ethics or moral principles of

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now