Verified Document

Ethics Case Study: Medical Law And Ethics Case Study

Ethics Case Study: Medical Law and Ethics Jerry McCall is Dr. William's office assistant. He has received professional training as both a medical assistant and an LPN. He is handling all of the phone calls at the office while the receptionist is at lunch. During this period of time, a patient calls and says he must have a prescription refill for Valium, an antidepressant medication, called in right away to his pharmacy, since he is leaving for the airport in thirty minutes. The patient notes that Dr. Williams is a personal friend and always gives him a small supply of Valium when he has to fly. No one except Jerry is in the office at this time.

Does Jerry's Medical Training Qualify Him to Refill the Order?

While Jerry's medical training qualifies him to receive a prescription order and transcribe it accurately for other nurses or physicians to implement or transmit to a pharmacist to dispense, Jerry does not have the authority to refill the patient's medication, as renewing/refilling/extending a prescription/order is considered originating a prescription (MBN, 2010, p.1). While the dilemma presented to Jerry by the patient at hand may sway Jerry's ethics, his medical training underlines the fact that under no circumstance is Jerry allowed to refill the medication, especially if there are no further refills depicted on the prescription bottle. In a situation such as this, the only option Jerry has is to refer the patient to another doctor who may be able to more immediately assist them, or reject the patient's request outright, citing that his or her physician may be able to assist them further when Dr. Williams returns to the office. Despite the time constraints the patient has explained, and the ethical dilemma raised by their impending departure, the circumstances of Jerry's medical credentials remain unchanged, leaving him unable to assist the patient in this manner.

Does Critical Medicine Alter the Decision to Refill?

Even...

Though the patient at hand may assert his or her frustrations with the situation, and Jerry may undergo an ethical dilemma in his own mind regarding the patient's time constraints and the need for medication, the repercussions that Jerry could face if he decided to call in a refill could prove extremely detrimental to his employment status or his licensure.
Doctrine of Respondent Superior

The doctrine of respondent superior, which literally means "let the master answer," states that in many circumstances, an employer is responsible for the actions of employees performed within the course of their employment (Lloyd, 2010, p.1). In a situation such as this, should Jerry decide to refill the medication, malpractice suits would likely be filed against Jerry and against Dr. Williams or any other physicians who hold stake in the practice. In malpractice cases involving physicians and nurses, a healthcare organizations credentialing process is questioned and can be revoked, recoveries and damages to injured parties are paid largely out of pocket, and physicians held responsible for employee actions are often held as directly culpable for the incident that took place, even in situations where the respective physician was not present (i.e. Jerry's situation) (Nowicki and Summers, 2004, p. 95).

As the case study does not specifically state whether or not Jerry, as an LPN an acting member of the physician's office, holds his own form of medical malpractice insurance, it can be inferred that such a circumstance as that previously-stated in which Dr. Williams is held accountable would go into effect.

Legal and Ethical Issues

While the legal ramifications of Jerry's decision to refill could cause significant damage to his career, Dr. Williams' career, and those affiliated with the…

Sources used in this document:
References

Lloyd, H. (2010). Workers' compensation: a brief history. Florida Department of Financial Services. Web. Retrieved from: http://www.myfloridacfo.com/wc/history.html on 1 November 2011.

Minnesota Board of Nursing. (2010). Nurses and prescribing. Web. Retrieved from:

http://www.state.mn.us/mn/externalDocs/Nursing/NURSES_AND_PRESCRIBING_090904125323_Prescribing%20FAQ2.pdf on 1 November 2011.

Nowicki, M. And Summers, J. (2004). Reducing your credibility liability. Healthcare Financial Management, 58.4: pp. 94-97. Web. Retrieved from: ProQuest Database.
Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Ethics Case Study: To Rescue Others at
Words: 994 Length: 3 Document Type: Case Study

Ethics Case Study: To Rescue Others at What Risk? What is the Ethical Dilemma? An ethical dilemma in the words of Fletcher, Holt, Brazier, & Harris (1995) "occurs when there are at least two possible courses of action that may be taken but each option is problematic" (p.7). With regard to the case study under consideration, the ethical dilemma each and every individual who has succeeded to make it to the roof

Medical Ethics Case Study Who Can Prescribe
Words: 1347 Length: 3 Document Type: Case Study

Medical Ethics Case Study Who Can Prescribe Medicine? Does Jerry's medical training qualify him to issue this refill order? Why or why not? Generally, LPNs and medical assistants are qualified to dispense medication prescribed by a physician ("Medical assistant, 2011). A medical assistant is a trained medical professional who works under the supervision of a board-certified physician ("Medical assistant, 2011). Typically, a medical assistant's work is administrative, but it may also include clinical

Case Study Analysis of Personal and Organizational Ethics and Values...
Words: 3494 Length: 10 Document Type: Case Study

Ethics Case Study This report presents an analysis of the ethical challenges faced by two organizations -- one in the not-for-profit sector named Susan G. Komen for the Cure and one in the for-profit sector named The Lubrizol Corporation. A brief background of the two organizations is provided which also includes a description of the ethical challenge. Several alternatives for each organization are discussed along with implications for various stakeholders. Out

Ethics Surrounding the Wayne Case Study
Words: 2850 Length: 10 Document Type: Essay

Ethics is a grey area in many instances within the medical community. Ethical codes help by providing guidance that allow for professional judgment or discretion and the idiosyncratic nature surrounding ethical dilemmas. As mentioned in the first lecture concerning ethics, ethics is mostly observed as being a serious reflective activity essentially concerned with a methodical inspection of the ethical life (Callaghan & Ryan, 2012). It is intended to illuminate what

Ethical Legal Dilemma in Advanced Practice Nursing Case Study
Words: 2822 Length: 9 Document Type: Case Study

Ethical-Legal Dillema in Advanced Nursing Practice Ethical-Legal Dilemma involving a Patient in Emergency Department (ED) The case study discussed in this paper presents ethical-legal principles in nursing which protects patient's privacy, confidentiality and security. Nurses have a professional obligation to protect the privacy of patients. Nursing Law and confidentiality define privacy as the right of patients to have their personal, identifiable medical information kept discrete and only accessible to the physician of

Critical Thinking Case Study Faith Community Hospital
Words: 2168 Length: 7 Document Type: Case Study

Critical Thinking Case Study Faith Community Hospital is a not-for-profit hospital and has a mission statement which is interpreted by everyone the way the want to interpret it. Their mission statement compels them to provide health care services and work towards better health and well-being of the people who belong to the communities that Faith Community Hospital serves. It further includes that they are to provide these services in collaboration with

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now